Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout5C - Consideration of a demolition permit application for 819 6th St. (HIS2007-00301) - for the demolition of the primary structureMEMORANDUM January 9t°, 2008 TO: Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board FROM: Susan Richstone, Acting Director of Long Range Planning James Hewat, Historic Preservation Planner Marcy Cameron, Historic Preservation Intern Chris Meschuk, Historic Preservation Planner SUBJECT: Public hearing and consideration of a demolition permit application (HIS2007-00301) for the demolition of the primary structure located at 819 6"' Street, pursuant to Section 9-11-23 B.R.C. for non- landmarked buildings over fifty years old. STATISTICS: 1. Site: 2. Date of Construction: 3. Zoning: 4. Owner/Applicant: 819 6~" Street 1954, addition 1959 RE, Residential Established Estate for M.S. Uberoi STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Landmarks Board adopt the following motion: The Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board issues a stay of demolition for the building located at 819 6th Street, for a period not to exceed 180 days from the day the permit application was accepted by the city manager, in order to explore alternatives to the demolition of the buildings, adopting the tindings as listed on page 11 of the staff memorandum. Alternatives to be considered indude rehabilitation of the building, incorporation of the existing house into redevelopment plans, moving the building, or withdrawal of the demolition permit. Staff encourages the applicant to consider landmark designation of the house and a portion of the property and to incorporate the historic house into redevelopment plans for the property. Landmark designation would make state tax A¢enda Item # SC Paee 1 Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 ' Re: 819 6rh Street- Demolition Permit credits available to help offset the cost of rehabilitation, as well as providing the possibility of a waiver of sales tax on building permits. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: On November lit, 2007, the Planning Department received a demolition permit application for the house at 819 6th Street. The building is not in a designated historic district or locally landmarked, but is over fifty years old and meets the criteria for demolition defined under Section 9-11-23 of the Historic Preservation Ordinance. On November 7th, 2007 the Landmarks design review committee referred the application to the Landmarks Board for a public hearing based upon the design review committee's finding of probable cause to believe that the building may be eligible for designation as an individual landmark. The house was built after designs by noted Boulder modernist architect, Hobart Wagener. It survives as an early, unique, and remarkable example of Expressionism architecture in Boulder executed by Hobart Wagener. Staff recommends that the Landmarks Board impose astay-of-demolition in order to consider alternatives to the proposed demolition. DESCRIPTION: Located in the Spackman Fi ure 1: Location Ma - 819 6`h Srreet Addition of University Hill on _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ¦ the west side of 6th Street, ~ ~ 8196th Sine[ ~ between Cascade Avenue and Aurora Avenue, the ~ 'i ~ ~ ~ approximately 20,538 square ~ e foot lot is located with the ~ ~ ~ ~ foothills serving as a dramatic w ~ ~ ~ ; ~ backdrop. The 1450 sq. ft. one- - story brick and wood frame r house is set obliquely on the property and accessed via a ' ~ ~ horse-shoe shaped driveway. ~ ~ , ~ i The house at 819 6th Street was constructed for Sylvester Labrot in 1954 and subsequently expanded five years later with the construction of a Hobart Wagener designed addition. Stylistically, the house can best be described as Expressionistic in inspiration as exemplified by its strong sculptural forms paired with Aeenda Item #SC Paee #2 S:V'LANWataVongnngV{IS71Demos\6th.819\01.09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda IIem N SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 6'h Street- Demolition Permit non-traditional structural elements. The building is comprised of a pair of related, though distinct wings arrayed in a modified "V"-shaped plan, with the open end facing away from the street and sheltering a patio in the back. The most distinctive characteristics of the house are the complicated intersecting of swooping butterfly and planer shed-roof forms and exposed skeletal structural systems. These forms are accentuated by the ribbon windows, stacked Norman brick walls, and use of the same materials on both the interior and exterior walls of the house. The building was altered in 1959 with the construction of an Wagener designed addition for Theo & Margaret Lord; the remodeling consisting of a south facing shed roof at the north of the house to provide south-facing clerestory lighting into the house and an extension of the carport roof at the south elevation. These changes were obviously of a functional nature to provide light and additional parking space on the property, but were also consciously executed to enhance the sculptural angularity of the building. The property was surveyed in 2000 as part of a survey of Modern buildings in Boulder. (See Attachment B: Architectural Inventory Form). , ~,y ~ J .--.r -n.,, ~ ~ y , ~ f, ~eil , ~ x } ~ s ~ I- x c S ~ . r i:, ~IIMI 5' L ' ~t~f~e s ~ *r,;,~~ F*;5 tst4 ~ 4 yet € y,y "'no'r°'o -"mom ""'x-- 6i~~ `~"~w :`F ~ is !S,. ..t. Figure ZEast Lleuatiorl, 195 prig to addition Agenda Item #SC Paee #3 S:\PLANldato\IongrangWlS'I1Dcmos\6th.819\0].09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item#SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 6'h Street- Demolition Permit ~v, ''r..~nw~..:q~Y ~~aie het` ~ r { * ~ tSjY~ ~~y~~$,. .y.~~:`q ("~r 1 ~ I"s, ~ ,Fri, 1 ; ~ Z V { " - - ~l ~:1 4t ~~t[ _ p. ~ y'~, .t. ,Y• - ,fit ' 3''R t 4~..! yY. - y ~ ~ f y~S;7 , J '~~,S.w.,. er _ . ; _c ~ 3 ~ s ro~.- ( si ' .l 1.J91. ~t b -T .:~H=-~ tea- t - l i~~trr~~ l.~r~t E:It~vatiott, 2007 ' i i ~ , ' ' -r' Y~ j .i. F t . ,1 1~" rya" } s ~1 k: 1 Y I'r~tur~c~ Nurtlr 1=1~~~~ntiou, ?007 Agenda Item #5C PaQe #4 S:IPLANkIataUongrang1F11S'1\Demosl6th.8t910L09.2008 1.PAB mcmo.doc Agenda Item # 56 Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board 01 /09/2008 Re: 819 6'h Street- Demolition Permit t 3 ~ ~ . ~ , - ~ 'G ~ ~ I~~ ~ ~ ~ - _ _ - -yy. ~zi,Hk. ~ mot,. t . - -~-S' ~ - -lam - ' . x. t !xM Fi~urc~ 5: Soirtii Elevntior), 207 yak; w + j ~ r . j ' k A?7 ` t~ ~ ~ y. >T~.zy: f. t uu ;i A it y.. 3, ~ ti _ _ Fi~~ure 6: West Elevation, 2007 Aeenda Item #SC PaQe #5 S:\PLAN\data\longrang\HIST\Demos\Gth.819\01.09.20t1i; LPAB mcmo.docAgenda Item # 5B Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 ' Re: 819 6m StreeT- Demolition Permit CRITERIA FOR THE BOARD'S DECISION: The Historic Preservation ordinance states that the Landmarks Board shall consider and base its decision upon any of the following criteria [9-11-23(f)]: (1) The eligibility of the building for designation as an individual landmark consistent with the purposes and standards in Sections 9-11-1 and 9-11-2, B.R.C. 1981; (2) The relationship of the building to the character of the neighborhood as an established and definable area; (3) The reasonable condition of the building; and (4) The reasonable projected cost of restoration or repair. In considering the condition of the building and the projected cost of restoration or repair as set forth in paragraphs (3) and (4) above, the board may not consider deterioration caused by unreasonable neglect. As detailed below, staff considers this property is eligible for designation as an individual landmark and that demolition would have an adverse impact on the character of the area. The building has incurred considerable mold damage as a result of burst water piping but further information about the condition of the building or the cost of restoration or repair (criteria 3 and 4) has not been received at this time. For this reason, staff has concentrated on criteria 1 and 2 in assessing the building's eligibility for landmark designation and its relationship to the character of the neighborhood. CRITERION 1: INDIVIDUAL LANDMARK ELIBILITY The following is a result of staff's research on the property relative to the significance criteria for individual landmarks adopted by the Landmarks Board on September 17, 1975. See Attachment E: Individual Landmark Si ni cance Criteria Aeenda Item #SC Paee #6 S:\PLAMdata\IongrangW IS"IlDemos\4th.819\OL09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda I[em k SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board O1 /09/2008 Re: 819 61h Street- Demolition Permit HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE: Summary: The house located at 819 bs' Street has historic significance as per sub-criteria 1, 2, 3and4. 1. Date of Construction: 1954 Elaboration: The building is an early example of Boulder Expressionism, is over fifty years in age and, therefore, potentially eligible for designaiion as an individual landmark. 2. Association with Persons or Events: Hobart D. Wagener, Dr. Mahinder S. Uberoi Elaboration: The house is the early work of Hobart D. Wagener, an acknowledged master of Boulder Modernist architectural design. Born in 1921 in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, Hobart D. Wagener graduated from The University of Michigan in 1944 and moved to Boulder in 1950. He worked with Eggers & Higgens in New York, Pietro Belluschi in Portland, Oregon, and James Hunter before opening his own practice in Boulder in 1953. His firm, Hobart D. Wagener Associates, designed over 200 projects, sixteen of which were featured in architectural and professional publications; ten received national or regional awards from the American Institute of Architects (AIA). Examples of his work include the Wagener House, which was published in The Architectural Record in 1967 as part of a national recognition of twenty homes in America; Fairview High School, an addition to Casey Middle School (Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit Award, 1957), St. John's Episcopal Chapel, The Williams Village Dormitories at the University of Colorado, the Mountain Savings & Loans Building (Western Mountain Region, AIA, Design of Excellence, 1956), Presbyterian Manor apartments (Federal Housing Authority National Awards Program, First Honor Award, 1963), the Boulder County Justice Center, the Boulder City Hall Addition, Wesley Foundation Student Center & Chapel (Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit Award, 1958).Wagener co-authored the book 'The School Library' in 1963 and served as the president of the Boulder Chamber of Commerce in 1971, Chairman of the Boulder Planning Commission in 1966 and acted as Treasurer, Secretary, Vice President and President of the Colorado Society of the American Institute of Architects. He was named "Architect of the Year" in 1995 by the American Institute of Architects Colorado. Wagener died September 30, 2005. See Attachment F: Resume: Hobart D. Wagener, FAIA, Architect Mahinder S. Uberoi was a professor of aerospace engineering sciences at the University of Colorado from 1963 unti12000. Born in India in 1924, he earned his doctorate from Johns Hopkins University in 1953 and was named a Guggenheim Fellow in 1957. He served on the faculty at the University of Michigan unti11963, when he joined the CU faculty as chair of the newly named department of aerospace Aeenda Item #SC Paee #7 S:V'LAMdalaVongrangViIS7~Demos\61h.819\01.09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item # SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 bm Street- Demolition Permit engineering sciences. Dr. Uberoi had earned a reputation for his work in magneto hydrodynamics, turbulent flow and other basic sciences of fluid flow. As chairman, he built up_the new department, adding faculty strong in basic research areas in fluids, controls and biology (to create a bioengineering program). His term as chair ended in 1975. He was the author or co-author of a number of scholarly papers, including "Directional Spectrum of Wind Generated Ocean Waves," published in the Journal of Fluid Dynamics in 1963; "Magnetically Distorted Polytropes: Structure and Radial Oscillations," in The Astrophysical Journal in 1972; and "Magnetized Positive Column Between Coaxial Cylinders," in Physica Scripta in 1986. Dr. Uberoi later filed eight lawsuits over six years against the University, alleging among other complaints, discrimination against foreign-born faculty, hazardous laboratory conditions and violations of the state's Public Records Act. He was terminated as a member of the CU faculty in 2000, making him the first tenured faculty member to be dismissed by the Board of Regents. Dr. Uberoi died December 21~t, 2006. See Attachment G: University of Colorado Obituary: M.S. Uberoi 3. Development of the Community: Modernist Architectural Movement Elaboration: The building is associated with the development of the local Modernist architectural movement and survives as a unique and remarkable example of early Expressionist design from the post-war period in Boulder. 4. Recognition by Authorities: Modern Architecture Survey Elaboration: The building was recommended as being eligible for listing in the State and National Registers of Historic Places in the 2000 survey of Boulder Modernism. Its is also significant as an early, unique, and remarkable embodiment of Expressionism, as the work of Hobart Wagener, for its high standard of construction and craft, and its organic relationship to its site and associated landscape design. Furthermore, the house is significant for the special engineering features required to resolve the structural requirements of the roof and as a building identified as being a contributing resource to the proposed Flatirons Park Historic District. ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE: Summary: The house at 819 6th Street has architectural significance as per sub-criteria 1, 7_, 3, and 4. 1. Recognized Period or Style: Expressionism Elaboration: The house embodies the forward-looking architectural manner of Expressionism of the 1950s and 1960s through its dramatic sculptural forms, non- Agenda Item #SC Paae #S S:\PLAMdataVongang\}IIS'I~Demos\6N.819\01.092008 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item It 5B Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 6m Street- Demolition Permit traditional structural elements, butterfly and shed roofs, and uses of the same materials inside.and out. Architectural historians credit the forms found in American Expressionism to have been as influenced by Streamline Moderne architecture of the pre-war period as much as from 1920s German Expressionism from where the American variant takes its name. Never-the-less, Expressionism is a rare form of Modern architecture in the United States, but did find acceptance in Boulder where at least fifteen examples of this type were built including the Methodist Student Center (Wagener,1957), Volsky House (Haertling, 1966), and the Boulder Valley Eye Clinic (Haertling, 1967). The house at 819 6~" Street retains a very high degree of historic integrity. Original drawings of the house and addition are located at the Carnegie Library. 2. Architect or Builder of Prominence: Hobart Wagener Elaboration: Early work of Hobart Wagener an acknowledged master of Boulder Modernist architectural design. 3. Artistic Merit: Sculptural roof, high standard of construction and craft Elaboration: Unique and remarkable example of Expressionism exemplified by strong sculptural forms paired with non-traditional structural elements. The building is comprised of a pair of related, though distinct wings arrayed in a modified "V"-shaped plan, with the open end facing away from the street and sheltering a patio in the back. Building is notable for its complicated intersecting of swooping butterfly and planer shed-roof forms and exposed skeletal structural systems accentuated by ribbon windows, stacked Roman brick walls, and use of the same materials on both the interior and exterior walls of the house. High level of attention to detail in the structural requirements for construction of intersecting butterfly and shed roofs, custom brickwork and windows, exterior wall and associated landscaping. 4. Example of the Uncommon: Expressionism Elaboration: Unique and remarkable example of early Hobart Wagener architectural design in Boulder. Expressionism is a rare post-war variant of Modernism in the United States, but found acceptance in Boulder were a number of buildings of this type were built. Expressionistic buildings remarkably varied in form, but are characterized by dramatic sculptural forms, non-traditional structural elements, butterfly and shed roofs, and uses of the same materials inside and out. Expressionism is most often associated with the "jet age" and architecture of the late 1950s and 1960s in its soaring forms. Probably the most famous examples of Expressionism in America are Dulles Airport (Eero Saarinen) Aeenda Item #5C Pa¢e #9 S:\PLAMdataVOngrangV-IIS'I~DemosVith.819\01.09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda item # 5B Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 ' Re: 819 6m Street- Demolition Permit and the Air Force Academy Chapel (Skidmore, Owings, and Merrill, both constructed in 1962. The 2000 survey of Modern Architecture indicates that this building is the earliest example of Expressionism in Boulder by at least three years. Of the fifteen buildings identified as being constructed in this manner in Boulder, five were designed by Hobart Wagener. 5. Indigenous Qualities: None observed ENVIRONMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE: Summary: The building at 819 6t,, Street has environmental significance under criteria 1, 2, 3and5. 1. Site Characteristics: Sited at the base of the Foothills, landscaping Elaboration: Integration of house into the landscape; interior/exterior design of house. Mature juniper trees, native yucca, scrub, and grasses and boulders. 2. Compatibility with Site: Integration into site Elaboration: House is consciously sited and designed to b compatible with site. Flatirons to the north are echoed in the dominant roof forms of the house. 3. Geographic Importance: Familiar visual feature Elaboration: Unique placement, orientation and form represents an established and familiar feature of the 6"' St. streetscape, Flatirons, neighborhood, and city as a whole. 4. Environmental Appropriateness: None observed 5. Area Integrity: Contributing building in potential historic district. Elaboration: The property has been identified as being a contributing resource to the proposed Flatirons Park Historic District. CRITERION 2: RELATIONSHIP TO THE CHARACTER OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD: This property is located on the west side of 6th Street between Cascade and Aurora Avenue, and is surrounded by a residential subdivision and is set at the base of the foothills. The neighborhood is an eclectic mix of architectural expression, much of which is Modernist in inspiration.. Agenda Item #SC Paee #10 S:\PLAN\dataVongangV31S7~Demos\6th.819\DL09.2DD8 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item H SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 61h Street- Demolition Permit CRITERION 3: CONDITION OF THE BUILDING AND CRITERION 4: PROJECTED COST OF RESTORATION OR REPAIR: Because no information has been provided by the applicant about the condition of the buildings or cost of restoration or repair, staff concentrated on criteria 1 and 2, the buildings eligibility for landmark designation and their relationship to the character of the neighborhood in making a recommendation on the appropriateness of demolition. Staff has visited the site and, while the building appears to be in good condition structurally and to retain a very high degree of historic integrity, significant mold blooms were observed on the interior walls of the building. Such contamination might require removal of interior walls as part of an abatement program. The projected cost to restore the exterior of the house appears to be moderate. NEIGHBORHOOD COMMENT: Staff has received several a-mails from neighbors See Attachment F. THE BOARD'S DECISION: If the Landmarks Board finds that the house proposed to be demolished does not have historic significance under the criteria set forth in Section 9-11-23(f) B.R.C., the city manager shall issue a demolition permit. If the Landmarks Board finds that the house proposed for demolition may have significance under the criteria set forth above, the application shall be suspended for a period not to exceed 180 days from the date the permit application was accepted by the city manager as complete, in order to provide the time necessary to consider alternatives to the building. [Section 9-11-23(h)]. A 180-day stay period would expire on May 17, 2008. Should the Board choose to issue the demolition permit, or if the permit is allowed to expire, staff recommends that demolition be conditioned upon submittal of the following to the Planning Department for recording with Carnegie Library: 1. A site plan showing the location of all existing improvements on the subject property; 2. Measured elevation and plan drawings of the building depicting existing conditions, fully annotated with architectural details and materials indicated on the plan; 3. Black and white large format archival quality photographs of all exterior elevations. Agenda Item #SC Pa¢e #11 S:V'LAMdataVongrangV-IIS'I\Demos\6[h.819\01.09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item # SB Page Memo to Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board Ol /09/2008 Re: 819 6m Street- Demolition Permit FINDINGS: Staff recommends that the Landmarks Board adopt the following findings: A stay of demolition for the house at 819 6th Street is appropriate based on the criteria set forth in section 9-11-23(f) B.R.C, in that the identified property: 1. May be eligible for individual landmark designation based upon its historic, architectural, and environmental significance; 2. Contributes to the character of the neighborhood as an intact representative of the area's past; 3. Has not been demonstrated to be impractical or economically unfeasible to rehabilitate and add onto the existing house. ATTACHMENTS: A: Modern Architecture Survey B: Current Photographs C: Significant Criteria D: Resume: Hobart D. Wagener, FAIA, Architect E: University of Colorado Obituary: M.S. Uberoi F: E-mails from neighbors of 819 6th Street Aeenda Item #5C Pa¢e #12 S:\PLANkIataVongmngV31S71Demos\6th.819\01.09.2008 LPAB memo.docAgenda Item tt SB Page ' Attachment A An;hltectural Inventory Form Page 1 of 4 Resource # 58L8215 819 6tl Street j gF.1P1403 Offiaal eligibility determination grgg (OAHP use only) COLORADO CULTURAL RESOURCE SURVEY Date lnifiais !Eligibility not yet reviewed by the Determined Eligible - NR Boulder Landmarks Board or the Architectural Inventory Form Determined:Not Eligible - NR Colorado Historical Society Determined E(igible - SR Determined Not Eligible - SR _ Need: pate Contriliu~s to eligible NR District Nohcottributing to eligible NR District I. IDENTIFICATION 1 Resource number 5BL8215 2 Temporary resource number Noh~ 3 County Boulder 4 city Boaider 5 Historic building name t House 6 Current building name Labrot HuWse 7.1 Building address 819'<8tl€'Street 8.1 Owner name M. S. tlberoi 8.2 Owner address 8'1.9' th:; reef 8.3 Owner city Soul' er 8.4 Owner state GO.`:. 8.5 Owner zip 80302 i. GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION 9.1 P.M. 6TH 9.2 Township TlN . 9.3 Range R~1W 9.5 1/4 of NE 9.6 1/4 of S 9.7 1/4 of SE 9.8 Section 38 10.1 .Zone 13. r 10.2 mE "475559 10.3 mN 4427840 11.1 USGS quad name Bo Quadrah fe 11.2 Year 1' PFiotorevised-1979- _ 11.3 Map scale 7.5' Yes 11.4 Map scale 15' Not applicable 12.1 Lot(s) 8 12.2 Block N/A 12.3 Addition SpackmarrSubdivision 12.4 Year of Addition Unknown 13 Boundary Description /Justification Legal boundaries of property III. ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION 14 Building plan (footprint, shape) Irregular plan / 15.1 Length in feet k 15.2 x Width in feet Unknown 16 Number of stories One Architectural Inventory Form Page 2 of 4 Resource # 56L8215 819 6th Street 17 Primary extemal wall material(s) 2 max Brick, Glass 18 Roof configuration 1 max Other roof ~ 19 Primary external roof material 1 max Asphalt 20 Special features (all that apply) She architectural description 21 General architectural descri lion The Labrot House is set back from 6th Street behind ahorseshoe-shaped driveway on a large lot. Though the house is fairly modest in size, ft is densely composed. It comprises a pair of related though distinct pavilion wings arrayed in a mod~ed "V"-shaped plan with the open end facing away from the street and sheltering a patio in the back. The pavilions are linked together with a connecting corridor wing. There is an exposed skeletal structure. This exposed structure is composed of wooden posts and lintels, and is expressed in the exterior walls of the pavilion wings by a series of vertical wooden piers which have been submerged into the walls and pass through the ribbon windows. These submerged piers contain, under the ribbon windows, vertical rectangles of masonry carried out in stacked Roman brick. The same detail is used for garden walls that function as an extension of the house. The house has a complicated system of butterfly and shed roofs. The various roof elements that perch on the exposed structural members have been conceived as planes that seem to float above the house, an effect enhanced by the inherent transparency of the ribbon windows that line the top of the walls across the front. The landscape includes mature junipers, native scrub and grasses, and boulders. 22.1 Architectural style t=xpressionism 22.2 Building type Not applicable 23 Landscaping or special setting features See architectural description 24 Associated buildings, features or objects See architectural description IV. ARCHITECTURAL HISTORY 25.1 Date of construction, estimated None 25.2 Date of eonstrucfx>n, actual 1954 25.3 Source of information Building Permit No. 2823 26.1 Architect Hobart D. Wegener 26.2 Source of information Interview, Hobart D. Wegener 27.1 Builder /contractor R. C. Grayson _ 27.2 Source of information Building Permit No. 2823 28.1 Original owner Syl. Labrot 28.2 Source of information Buildin Pennft No. 2823 29.1 Mejor additions/alterations/dates Unknown ~d d. ~ ~ n. 30.1 Original location Yes/No Yes 30.2 Moved Yes/NO No 30.3 Date of move Not applicable AQ9rfdailem#~t,~Paosi ~ y " Architecture) Inventory Form Page 3 of 4 Resource # 56L8215 819 6th Street HISTORICAL ASSOCIATIONS 61 Original uses Single Dwelling 32 Intermediate uses Single Dwelling 33 Curzent uses Single Dwelling 34 Site types Not applicable 35 Historical background See Boulder Modem Context and statement of signrficence 36 Sources of information See bibliogrephy Boulder Modem Survey VI. SIGNIFICANCE 37.1 Local landmark designation No 37.2 Date of designation Not applicable 37.3 Designating authority Not applicable 38.1 A. Associated with events No 38.2 B. Associated with significant persons No 38.3 C. Architectural significance Yes 38.4 D. Yielded/likely to yield import hist No 38.5 Criteria considerations Letter Architecture 38.6 Meets no criteria Not applicable 39 Areas of significance Architecture 40 Period of significance 1954 41.1 National No 41.2 State Yes 41.3 Local Yes 42 Statement of si nificence The Labrot House is significant for its association with the development of the Modem movement in " architecture in Boulder. Built in 1954, ItiS an early example of an important building in the history of post-war arohitecture in Boulder. The Labrot House is significant in that it embodies the characteristics of the F~cpressionist style: it has a strong sculptural form with non-tredi6onal structural elements, the same materials. are used inside and out, then; is a geometric floor plan and ornamental program, there is the use of the" cantilever, and there is a complex roof stlvcture composed of butterfly and shed roof forms. The Labrot House is sign~cent for the high standard of the construction craft The masonry, wood and glass work is of the highest quality. The uncehvenfional building form created special constNCtion problems that were deftly solved. The Labrot Mouse is significant because k is the work of Hobart D. Wegener, an acknowledged master of Boulder architecture. The Labrot House is an early example of Wagen~r's work. Tire Labrot House is significant for fts relationship to Its site. The building is dremaficaly sited above the street at the rear of a large lot, set against the backdrop of the foothills. The Labrot House is significant for its relatonship to an associated landscape design. A related wood fence to the north divides the front yard from the rear. formal outdoor spaces behind the house serves, as outdoor living areas. The Labrot House is significant for the special engineering features required to resolve the structural requirements of its unconventional form. The Labrot House has been ident~ed as being a contributing building to the proposed Flatirons Park Wistoric""District. The Labrot House also satisfies Criteria Consideration G, achieving sign'fiicence within the past fifty years due to its exceptional significance, This exceptional significance is defined by its integral relationship to the post- war detelopment of Modem architecture in Boulder, a movement which has received extensive press Coverage; by comparison with other Modem architecture of the post-war period in Boulder, and as documented by an ever-increasing body of scholarly evaluation on the historical importance of Modem architecture which developed during the post-war period. p3 Integrity Largety original condition ~ l' ~ertda Mam#~pa9p#.J.~_ Architectural Inventory Form Page 4 of 4 Resource # 56L8215 919 6th Street VII. NATIONAL REGISTER ELIGIBILITY ASSESSMENT 44.1 NR Eligible Yes 44.2 NR Not Eligible Not applicable 44.3 NR Need Data Not applicable 45.1 NR District Potential Yes/No Yes 45.2 NR District Potential Discussion See Boulder Modern Context and statement of significance 45.3 If district potential, Contributing Yes 45.4 If district potential, Noncontributing Not applicable 46.1 If existing district, Contributing Not applicable 46.2 If existing district, Noncontributing Not applicable 4"l.1 Photograph Numbers Roll 02, Exposures 17-21 47.2 Negatives filed at City of Boulder Planning Department Files 48 Report Title Boulder Modern Architecture Survey 49 Date June 1, 2000 50 Recorder Diane Wray 51 Organization None 52 Address 3058 S. Cornell Circle Englewood, CO 80110 53 Phone number 303-761-8979 ~ { ~ , i' ~ r III 4 4. ~ 1 ~ t Y _ 1i~ _ r•.z _.-S ~t v _ ~ +r.. ~~L~ ' r ~ ~~F` ry`-'fit`. i~ Y a;fit ~ J~• K _ 1M1 T~~i f _ r L~'t<.'~. ~'e ~ E ~t ~ I P .t 1~ ~ , _~F''t g 7' ` SY- ~ _ - Iii ~r ~r, r ~ ~rlff8 ~1h ~ l _.._-s._ s. ai. a ~ e U.S. Department of the Interior Geological Survey Map Survey of Boulder Modern Architecture 1947-1977 Boulder C~uadrangle Completed June 1, 2000 Colorado -Boulder Co. 7.5 Minute Series (Topographic) State ID Number 5BL8215 SE/4 Boulder 15' Quadrangle Property Address 819 6th Street 40105-A3-TF-024 Property Name Labrot House 1 Photorevised 1979 1964 III SE -Series V877 g ~ i 1 4 3#~; ' '`:,~`S ~ ~ a ~'a ~;xz5r b r s ~ , a 'ti.~.,~~~ ~e z S~~ ~ r. ~,t ~ s ?~~y~ s r x~i ,z ? ,r ~ s # # ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ y~`~ 3 y sr y ~ n . y~ z .zr > ~'6F ,+oorm..& ~ 3"` ~ ~ a G'°A e ~ ~ :y i 1. ~ .3~ ~ 1 c6 : _ . R 4~ x`S'0~, ~ }z'~ o~~ . a ~ ~''Q 5 z }~ti r:<~r)~ 1 dr s3 ~ 'S'se~ ~ a~ i` n ~ 3 @5 b .'S, ~ t S s~ s 2 ~ ~ s ~ ms X>~ 3s:3. C °Yi~ ~3' i 1 ~ 4 Z.~, ~ S S t 7. ~ ~ fir t? < b~ ° ~s .4 F ii ~ ;4 ~~rz z r s ? ~ fW~~~~ ~ ~c~`'~'': Y`L-3a7~~ ~ Y~ e ~ ~ _ ~ S: 3 ~ ~ 3,~<2 i% ~~s''S ~ z i2 ~ tss y~ x ` ,t v S{ ~ ''v ~ ~ # ~ ,,~y uT ~t,, ~ ~x ttts, I~ ` ~s`6 e ~ ~ s~ s; d;l ~e a ~ ~ ~ ~ a > ~ ~ ~ 7r: &k :s3 # ~ I??~~"'~, x ~ x ) ~ ""4, ~ w J~. ~ .~S ~,~t.~. ~~+.o" ,~..~;.A,.,,,,s.., j~,# ~ ~ 0 4 ~K _ '~'~C~; ~ L yK ~ i .rx~ r_ e s ^'r3 ~i k:.~~,~i ~~°~~'°~~E w~~~_ ~^.3 of :-~~5~~``~*e' '.".y a w., E ~'i,~_ ati.~in°s~sr y%x p~`n. ~Z;i ~ck> ,rte ~ ~ t: w,n e`K '1 ' 3fi z'S s~~M.~ .c ~,'~"0j°',,(~ ri ~ r'~- ~„o -t z, b ~ i; - "%y` s 't` 4, ~ .k. ~ ~ r"' a^ ~x":~;~.,` L8}s~d~ ~ , arc "`s { ~ s ~ F . s~ , sS s ; ~ { * r a mss: ~~`Bt~C ,S ~ ~ t ir: j~ ~ ~ s ; ~ z s 3sw ~4~2 s£§ { 3 a ? ~ ~ ~ 3 s Y ~ ~ s ~ x . 4S~~~' , ~,~t 3 j~1 ~ ; :t~~~,a . ~Y ~ ~ ,k ~ ~s ~ fem. rk~k ' ~~s s• s 1s r t s~s~ _ ! ~ , s~' R ~ ~ v >?6~' f ~ ~ zm~ ~ . ~~r~~,r ~ ~ >^FH ~C~`,~.z{r;x{ 2~ j.( J~_; 3~ Gib. ~ ~ `.L` ~ ~ rtt , #3' -,w,~. y api i - j .`S_" .,C ~ _ 7 i i & - L ~q~ tw.i?: x' '+'Ca '~'~,v.. ~ ~ s z 3 ~......F ~~zY 2 : f ~z~`p ~ • a ;t~>?5 Z,AY'~--- s x t~ n t1 71!/ L~~:{3sc Y~ r''~ ~ E ~ " '8&r „y ~ r ~ ~ I. ~ ~ ~ j ~ w~ ' Y i r~ z,~,~,~ °Y~ t ~ ~F'6i~'Y1i7~w ~ s: a ~ i;# .ass ~ ~ X { ~ y~~.~ ~ a~ 'FFfi~„+<' x 1 zy~f 53 ~i z~s ~ ~ ^cc~" s d~~ ~ j ~ ~LL~~#3N' z~'^ztir ~ ~ xYl~ ~ ~s ~ j~ ~)~~I~~'~` ~ ~Z a ' 4~4Jfz sr ~,~{}C sit M" t.c'~s« ~ ~I;? :r.} ~ ~:s s#)q(~ f ~ } ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~p fit,' E ~u.. ~ ,~h, ,ar:~ s i f 3: 3~ ~ ~ rr 4 l ~a'~S2s fl i 3: ~ [ ~ ~ r ~ n e'a" t{ L~R1tFt ~Z ~ o~ ~ wt 3R'~¢ 1`5 ~ ~i Sl sZs ?j''''Z? t pit( 3 tf ~ s ~ ~ 3 ~ s ~ ~ *rl €t ~ f~ r ~ ~ ~,s~~#i~~. tt ~ 3 _ ~ 5 .3kfr t s ~r °:x s { '"'Z ~ s3~~'~~ s s-. ~'D i>~ ~ ^z s . rJ~g ~ # ~ ? ~ a~¢Q '"..w,..... ~ .M.,.~',y ~ .~,s sr ~ ~i~Y~ i~' . 1=z {t , `y,{lit ~ : ; s ~ l ka~'`~+--.,_ ~ ~ ' :s$S i*,^`1s4 j 1 + 4 ~ s 3 Tit{ j ~ 4:, s ~ ~{.:3z # ~ Z € x;m:~x-o~m a' 7 ".`K ws t : ~ ~ ~S` ~s } I; ; U1 ~ ~ { ~ 4 L i AtF , } ~S'?F"~`. ~ ~ ~3i•'~'~ ~ ! ~ ~ 's ~`7`~ ` q 1~ ~ 3 ~ ~ h ~ ~ q ` f s ) t 1~ ~`r'~ ~ ~ ~~y~~~ y 3c :::.'G ~ : ~1 ~ ~ ~ #a*' f3`~ Yf ~ s'.~I[ " rl s £ # f ts{ j~s-',r s ~ 4 a ~ i ~r ~t 5~~ ~"i { ' six{ ~Sy~c~f~ e~~ yi~ r~~# - ~ T~.~ ,~s 'h."P ~ .»d'"F~ ~3 ~ } ffi w+w."~~'° j ~ ~ ~,3 ~~~2 -t t ~ ~s ~~5 9 -G~+~' 2~ , ~ i~ 2 St ~ li 9~'s ~ ~ 3-. ,F ~ fig' f h~ ~ :~~ry~,~ j"a'" i~~~ - 7r ~ t€~ f~~~._';} 't ~ ~C ~~JQ VY~~$3 Y3..' ~Il.. ~a~~ _ y~~ ~ i i 3'+.~ r ^ `7 ~ t: f i > s{{- r~u ti'. ~ s ~ ~ E ~R „ rn , rrai€@rf tr 5 ~ -..K ,,,-,KS~., '~'Y" ~ "f ~^"'^~'>'^.x„--": ~ s~'8t3i:' .s f ~ t •~-e ~ a~ ~ S ~7' Y ; tt~~{2&~~' t 'rte sh'Ale3~` w ' it ~sr~ zs~t~.ss v{~G~~~~-`~"°O~~E I ~ ~„~t+i '^'i 1r s~ i <:1~ ~ Y . .r f ^e ~ ~873t r ~it~tfe#:4C e ~ 3r ~ 3~.N ~ L 'sue .t~ ~"a~~.3~~^....^..,.~~.~ ~ ~ ~d3' ~~at a..~.....~. J ~ :~,3H,4fS' ~:SY 3' ~ ~~r.. ~ ~~>G ZY ~`fp{-^. ~ . ~.s.~~~(e _ Mir Z ii+ '?c' ,V ..,i ? ~'S )Xw~''"""' '~.""P~ f ritr ~R !Y ; 6 r ~~?"~x~'~, ;~~`~>~aw. ~ ~ x < }~k ~~~~Si°'~~ ~ S ~ r e B .`S'~o-o'„°s°:~"'5 ~~'uQ~i[mu~~ ~ b~ ~ ~ f`E ~ e ~ ~`~-"~c ' ~ ~ s j# 1 1, fF ~ ~ ~ `w ~ : ~.E' Mek ~d" .x w„ .rx;. t JJ ~ I ~R { A ~ ~ ' ~G," a"^74v~„~hF~~Y'~`~ al'~t~ 5. '7 ~ f ~ J ~ X lr,c« `TM~fs~' ~ ~.I ~ V ~ ~o 4. f f~ ~4 %1~ { ~ 3~ S~,`~ ~ ~ z~ ~ 1~~' Y v~ {~x ` ~~~..3}" 4~ b - , r ^f1,~~;c s 1} ~ s .r ~ E~~i~~ S :p s.»L ~ ~,R~y~, ~'o<S4""'~ ` .:k r ~1~'~ A6 !am, G ,k' 1 - ~ @ ' 4 ~ i +CY~ ~ F ~ ~ ~ t.': h I ~i (qsir ~ x 9~~ 2 ~ - `~i SF'l. ) { x 2°°° are 3''E~l ~ , ~ }{:~~r y~. Q~ i ~1 ~s?ai s z ,z~;: ~ra- i ' r :c :ir g X r Lx`.€- _ p3+f'S~83 )f ~ •')It ~'~°3,~~ F zt ? y ^C ~,~Q ii d23`~~O`"r ~ S'!t'{n;~~0 cSF .1Y~ ~ ~ ~45 f 2... A? r,~~ ~ r. i`r~s ~ f o- rs ' ..5,: :s S c : ~F~ z*k 3-~' ~ _s. .~eaemwnr..... ~ 4r~ ~ 7~ x 7 J qtr LECa~ DESCR+>'noN ;IU;~~I p'~;, I~~~hgj FLat irv~s, ~~rtc. (provided by Clitmt) ~j11Hit~ ~r~ 'I' N SB?5 fi?f5 av£xue Lot 8, ~ PNLW Ie3~t70) SPACKMAN.S SUBOIVi$lOk, FAX: (30J) 4<3-9830 County of BOULDER, www. RalPUrv.aOm Store Of COLORADO. I aw SCALE ~ '°~30' : ~ ~_QT 3 ~ EaST ~ 60' ` reucc r aRicx wnLL-~ / ~ to _OT 8 ! ~ I a ~*~y'td~ ~ r` ~ Icn ~ ~ p ,io p n I G ~ .~i W + ~ ~ w 'Liar j T I~` P ~t1 ~ _ Y£I tfi I ~ - t7 6R~K 8 FR ` ~ I-, `b ~i e, q0a - _ I I. - ~ FOUND REBAR i ; CAST ~hC' FWt4O /ti ttEUAR i M/ M_UY CJID ~ DoT 7 a~~L,<i ~ NOte9; 1-•THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A TITLE SEARCH BY FLATIRONS, INC. TC DEFEKMINF. OWNERSHIP, Rt;,HTS OF WAY, EASEMENTS OR ENCUMBRANCES NOT SHUM+N RY T1-IE PLAT Ti~A7 MAY AFFECT TH15 TRACT OF LAND. TFIERE MAY 0E EASEMENT'S OR RIGHTS OF WAY Of THE PUBLIC RECORD 1YAF htAY AFFECT TrIIS TRACT OF LAND THAT ARE NOT SHOWN ON 7}115 CERTIFICATE. 2-AN IMPROVEMENT SURVEY PLAT !S RECOMMENDED TO DEPICT MORE PRECISELY THE LOCATION OF THE 1 7MPROVEMEkT'$ SHOWN HEREON. 3-THE FENCES ARE NOT COINCDFNT WITH T1•IE LOT ONES AS SHOWN li~RtON. ~K;yFltl?e:rl,U.br sa~a~,7;~13 ~gt~f,~, ;y~~ off;: ,,r., a. anal. ado L. ,;Hn o.ke C • ac, IMPROVEME~I LOCATION LL.RT1F~iC~k_~ seoNeeee4 {L• 7 heryD ce'lii that My im I ~'„n,~~~+Y1~„ 7 7 pravemenl locot+On coiillaatc em YMded !IX Si):vENS UTtNAN L.C. Choi it i¦ not a Plot Or ;mprowment Sarv.y 7lOt• orW Choi it ii nol to tie relied upm tar b+e estd>rs`~ment of Ivw, bWdinq or ut>yr future Fnprewnmt floral brthdr ~rGfy That thf tmproremsnb on ins anew oaecr~ed perer on UtM date. Oclabrr 0, 300), eearpt utility eann.ctbne. ar siur.y riWn the baundori:s Of the per W, eecpt ae hero. bqt Herr ara n0 rr:craneaments upon the desa i»d premier¦ by inprwpnentr on coy Wplning prerriixii. eraept oe ind;coted, cod thot N/xe 1e ne Opparrnt eNdenca a si4n of my t9tement cnpeeily a burdening a.y port OI wie poroM. accept p nosed. NONCE: ThIy trproeemant Loeetian Carti4crtr ie prepared for ttla role purpefe of uee Dy me parliee states tweon. ll ie n01 o Land Sarvey Plal a¦ de7Med oy GtLS 3ti-51-t02{i2) « en imafMment Survey prat w deRned ay t:.R.S ]E~-31-tal(8). 1l dar not niawbh paparty carnrn Amore predre nsoMOr:9nq of Cie filpraYfmNti la bps bobedo!7 Inm M determi~rd by a Ltrin Survry a irrprO~emtni Survey. ilia iryrwemenh ora generay situated M stwvm and Onty apparent (vtsibie rt re tine et IMtleork) lmprevnnantr and enoroaMimen4 as noted. FlaUrens, inc. and .bhn B. t +yten rL npl be Iib01e for rrrore than the eat of Chi ?npraremenl Location CrtiNeete, rA Chas arty to th¦ parliee rpegGcaty rlorn haeaa Acorptanrw and/a urs Of Mss lmprorwsenl laeetlen C.rt:fieoh for ony purp08e eaietl:uler oeMO.hdpmert and agrrsT~ent to dl t~.nr rioted hrrran. FFat+ane Ne. ry7-9~,57lt ntte Co. Ho. amour: i(ossoy • - - - Agenda Hem # C. Pads• I _ Apraised ~ - 19 Ap_ raised by I Seetion I Twp. I Range I - N TRACTS LOTS ~ BLOCK ADD_ TTION~ ~ ~ ~ j ~ " `II HOUSE No. ~ STREET ~ ~ CITY ~ ~ OWNER , - Width x Length i Area I Height I Cubic Feet I I ~ I I I I ! I ~ I I! I I y x r I 1 7 L I ~ ~ j t. , - , I ~C , d x I ~-I I ~ - ~ -x - Wall Ratio Total Sq. Ft. r `F `f ~ :-r , r _ Special Building Notes _r~_ - - DESCRIPTION ~r~.c ' d. 1Y~~i .:,,,r ~ it,.-rr -f , T - - Give Numbers ~ ~ ~ ~ ROOMS STORI)rS l ~ Al -..~-t~ .rt ` -c~ r L,/. v ~ ~ - I Basem't I 1 ( 2 ( 3 I Atic - ` ~ i2± om ~ _ Living Ro I - ---------I-- ---I--- I-----I----- L i~ , . - - ~ Dining oom - - R I I--_.__---I_ I - I._ ` " ~ Dinette I ~ ' . W.. r ~ - _ - - I - ----I--------I__--I------ rh~a,,~ , ~ t.. t' / I _ _..r____ _ . _ Kitchen I----------I-L--I---I ----I - - I Breakfast Nock - - .--.(_.--i-----I----.. = I --I ~ _ Bed Room I---------------' (--------I-----L...-_.- - - ~ - B~-th Room J i. - I I------~-I------I-------I - - Toilet Room I -----------I------I---I----I---- 1 - - r - Shower Raom I----------I ------I---I--------I~----_._.. - - ~ Sleeping Porch I--------------I-----I------I------I-------- - Sun Roam I---•--------I------I----i-------I--------- - ~ _ - ~ - ~ - Dan !-----~---------I------I----- I-------I------ _ ~ C Storage Room !.----~--•----`I'-••:----I-----I-----_I_._-. _ Halls _ - ~ ------------I------ I------ I--•----- -l- ed BY Date ~ I I I I I I I I f I( I I I I I I I I ~ I I I I 'I ~ I 5,~mrnary of Land and Building Values SU11I1V_t_A_R____Y ANNUAL ASSESSMENT _ _ _ Full Appraised _ I I Descr~ptim~ II Amount II Year II Land Improvements I, _ I g ! ~ _ ~ _ _^I I_ Tot=11 LAND Value Buildin Permit $ " 1949 - ~I S Original Cost, Improveme fly ~ ` f ~ II$ ~-i 1950 Ii$ II$ II Bui~di~iR_; and Improvements II _ _ (This Card) ~,~C,tier_~. ~4~..1 7951 II Additions and Betterments _ f I$ ~I $ II II Owners Estimate of Present Value I$ ~ 1952 II$- II$ II Card No. II Private Apraisa~l I$ ~ 1953 II$ II$ II 'I Insurance ;I 1.954 II$ i$ i~$ II Card No. BUILDING DESCRIPTION AND VALUE CALCULATION AREA-MAIN BUILDING ROOF ; ISH Cube Area i ~ ; , ~ LOCAL IMPROVEMENTS CLASSIFICATION Na. Type: J ~ t PlasteoeNdT oRIOR FIB`---`~ ~r-- - Fat ? Pitched Low ~ _ Street Paving d TYPE AND USE Medium ? Steep Wood Paruelin r ~ ~c:~ . Al'_ey Paving ,c Check Framing: Simple Kind: ' ` Sidewalks _ 1-Single Residence Average ? Difficult Sq. Ft. __1._ g - ' 2-Duplex - ROOFING Tile Walls: S ~ Water _ ~ ~ R /V ~C~ 3-Bungalow, Apt. Crt. _ ~ ' Storm Sewer Prepared Roll - Trim: Hardw . R s. p p - - ~ - ~ Sanitary Sewer 4-Flat or Terrace Built-u As halt ___.7.._'___::__.____. Softwood Rms. - _ 5-Apartment House Shingle: TAectricaty _ ~ V _ 6-Hfltel Waod ? Asphalt F:,lect LIGHTING Gas Total / ~ • ` ? as ? None - - - - Asbestos 7-Store Building ? Slate Telephonc Reproduction. Cost and Final Value Tile: I-iEATING 8-Auto Tourist Court - MAIN BUILDING iVietal ? Cement Cla Stove _ CHARACTER OF CONST. _ _ 9-OPfice Buildin y g - Tin ? Copper Warm Air: Pipeless _ _ Item ~ Area or ~ Unit J - - - Poor - n 10-Hoop. or Sanitarium ~ Piped Medium _ Quantity Cast Total Insulated - - Base - I- 11-Bank Building - - " - _ Forced Circulation Good _ ~ 13-Warehouse Percent of t Gmttmrl Area:- - - GatFlo'o~ Fur~~s • ~ ~__S. Non-FRireSt Res ling - -~--..---~_'J ~ / S~ / i ~ J. rl S- 1~-Factory m Stun ' ~ I I I - - - Finished % Undin. ` ~ , x STATE OF REPAIRS 15-Public Garage . - PORCHES Ga,~ia`Leam R~ha~rc ADDITIONS (PLUS 16-Private Garage - - Air Camditio(nin B^d _ - - < - Number: Open. CLsed g _ - ~ r-~-J! -T- 17-Service Station Fr it ~ ~ . ~ ~ - Unfinished Finished Automatic Burner or Stoker ~ - 18-Hot House ar Gr. House Goad ~ ( ` I~-=) ? Coal - - Excellent - - f r: i TERRACES O:1 ? Gas ~ ~ r J r FOUNDATION . ~ MB ING _ - f r r.. ~p~ , ~ ~ ~ Kir.~d 7 - BASEMEN' , - New - Post or Piers - Area: ~ 'N, None ? ~ ~ ater Only _ .f-C~ r v _ J ; j Y _ _ a-~' ~v~.-~' DEPRECIATION Walls _ _ ~ Bathrooms Tiled - J ~ J ~ Pht•cical DEDUCTIONS (MINUS) 100% ? 75M ? 50% ~ Number of fixtures: EXTERIOR WALLS 25% ? None :;snst<•tnris ___1-' Tubs Obsolescence _ _ J J ~ _ ' No F~nor Waterclosets _x:.. :~i~w1•s. _ I J Frame - - _ hing ? No sheathing Plastered Plastered Shower Stalls _ ~ J Masan Ceilin r``~ Automati r•3' -------~---K------- - g ? Walls -I~-- E , er J;Heater J ~ J - r Kitchen ~•"'+r~,[.-Laurndry ition - % Area Walls: Kid .,~r"'t. L Sink. f ' Tubs J--~~.__~ JG: Finished Rooms: • _ _ board ~ _ No. % Arca OTHER ITEMS I and Batten Natural Fireplar_es _ Base Reproduction - FLOORS Gas Fireplaces _ - _ Cost $ - IJ_l:-a~_-• Subflaor 1st 2nd u O Chii°rin6`~s l~ ? ~dvSsbesto - - ? p S. - No Subfloor 1st ? 2nd up _ - tnal Net Condrtton r Construction: ~ Ve~e~~-- ~ •y,.~.,,~ ~ ~ Final Value-- , Wood Joists _ . _ - - Com. ? Face - _ J~T-~ .~.t - - _ - Main Buildin $ Concrete?on Grade Y ~ _ - g p Native ? Cut Finish Flooring: UMMARY OF Solid: Hardwood ? Softwood - BUILDING VALUE Com. ? Face Tile: Sq. Ft. - _ - - ~e - - - B ]d $ ste Block - _ Vin. F`t. - - ~ _ t i g - i 6~ ~ - T - - - - - - - - Garage - J ADetel of ConstruStource hate ~ Aire A'teraDescrtntirAdditionsPcrecnt Jate ~ Age r A,lerap~srj•ipticmd~litionsPercent Minnr Buildings ~ ~ I _ _ _ J Other - - _ - - - ~ -----I I ~ Size - J GAP~AGE AND MINOR BUILDING _ - - I ~R~produ.' f - Improvements ~~~.y~.~ W. ~ ~ ~ ~ M~ ~ v-., ~ ~ a m ,i~~ ~Y ^s~l "V+~' `x{±;:- 'Yo-..K..4a ^ ? W Y~ n' CH T ~:°ti.:C a a E ~Ca~~" ~ kk 4= ~ * i rty.~,~ ;F n~ve 7`~~ ~ :a '"Wm~ q'6~ek ? ~?'r 'pw.; ~5 -_ks..i- - 3,;..-^, ~ ,,tr.: ~ Q `X 'T^;'YnnK ,.tirt~~~"^E" :,cl T ~ ..r:., g'ti ~/~s~- + n'M >""':w i n~4`~;~`:. 'q: +~.'`f ° ,~f § ~ ~t~.° ,.;h k { r Xk ~e ",:-.~,w«eu Ht ~ ~ h 0:.4 7 YP ~y ~ ~ 1 t ~,rtC"Mf a.{~"^A` iF 3,~?. Ltil9 ; '~•;ikas£;, Yv .ks. "tr 'r ^M4~ .s a+~~`2'--~~}y s,,, .R. ~yj,^ ,k, 2 5 ~J ;d ~n...~, a rk.'7ti- s, •"Ja: fl 4 ;..Fwc:. _ yY. yh s'' f+ 1f" dHYM1'fl '4 M^, i C.o 1 ` x~i r ~ ~ '•"-*t ~t d. «M es~ r ~I~ ~ ~~St, y.^ti f ± ,~.~y4 .s' Y~ ~r ; IFFs ~~~s r.. i+, i g(4 7 f ~ ~~~~~Mj A. i _ F M ~ ;E ~ rt S. 1 ~ F ..Y: _ 1- ~k f7]~ + 4~Y~'F~A aA~ Fy4 l' I II ~ I ~ ~ `A~ 1 h - 6' r~ "A•. 4 ,wax k~~.. 5 c Y t~K" ~ ~ ~ y ~ t^'G °~Z. , r w ~",,8~ P1r'" ~ „~s w i K+n'^l'-rn .._.N •7„ + °'S",w t~ - w 'S"~ i~'~!s# N . yp'•~ 4g t~a~_ Y~ hr.... • wr.c~1YY~' ~ Ltn"'~+x~pw~a k ; r ~:n~+i'+ s~ G.y a ~ Yfi?t ~ f } a apG c7~';s"~cj'.,;, , n~ • ~ , . : ~u L a~~m:M+F': ~ "~r# '~a ~ ~ ~ , ~ "'6i '6~y'~nr~l1'~N~~ .,.,n ,.w . y.•. ,pF'7Y+ ~ ~..~n -+o. aaM4p~Wd'-•+++wnwY ~s,~. + Fa~iyll~° k: .uie. vs~::.,w~ ~'p31'bw a"ra~`°;a :+yp ~ . ""~a'"^ ~ -.re+h.^~'~.'• ry+, ti y wkufi,ry++ ` ~ .rv- ~ +«+frl ~ s ~3 ~ „h ~4~"~"? "lug ~v'.~Y'"~ .t.. a star' » ~ >t s 3'14:1- v: . T ~ ~ti, R k £ n^ ~X 'j ~ dr a~.v` ~ v~.. n"ix~'w~+,,.Fnc~ ~~~~.q~ s~~ 7~ ~ 'fi`t ~ - . ,s +t4 „d ~ 4 +I`:k~'i;~ a. it - f "Ls " K 2pi t a , r - - , ;w . to ,,.L 1~ ~ IIr T , ~ : "fir-,1 i,(: ~''°~~'f"' ; 5> +r4 ~ Ca It;%.~ ~1 t ~ :;li. , ~ , f, 41~~r y'~ .w ~ e ~k„*`t`:.~'^°rv d~ ita, ~ n + n 9 s ~?i"~.:~'r. '~w~ rK'f h'ut'. w r 6r .,~~j X x wf x 1 f n '~+J~~`r ~"~~tr 3 ~ o-~' ~ ~ m,rg~.~b~~'v~ s s ~ u ~ ~ tilt 1 t 'c ~ 5 `i fix, ~ vA .r v n .~i 1a ''4 ~r~ '1 f } ~ -.i ~'~a`Y t ~ :_t ~ ~ ~"t [g.~ F~~ ,t ~a` a 9~ p 7~ y ~ r! t 7 r '8. j'' r^d~7v ~ i i sfiz a L ~ ~+k'~. k., 'R '7 c = 'a t'7 1 r~~ ~3 ~~s ~ t" ~ ~ ti ~ 4 9 ~ µ ; i . t ~ .y,,..P ~ t a , _ - . .w. ~ ~ { n .°x~ ~ ~ . ,~w a ~y x ~ I f r ti~ S fH~ ~ yip i;~, ~ ~F a~ . ~ ~ 1 Y ~ ~ ~ rW k, t ~~t i,~'b~ FJ r; i'~ v~ ~r .l"` "ic~~? yi^ ~~~'^~x ~5~+,e,, 1~ ~ !~'r~'D+41 l .p; T x 3 ~ x: a> 1 ,~aS~, , c. .v ,.;'~'v '5~. J,~ 1~i»+w-~"~ ~R'r~ .,f `v,.• X.f~° ~`rY;. ~ -.~~~t .s~y~• ~w~~ Ys.E~~, x' ~ 9',' . ~ 115. ..lily ti -x^' E~' K~ i t I 1 , r ~ .4; _ r, F~ 4 { I.' b t Z J`, f F '.4:., ~ ~ ,rre 5 , r 3 ~ sa. , it Z ~ ` .}`~v ~ 1 r _ 'B~~g" ~ nay t ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ I 4t 7 _ : Y. r Y p ~ p~ ! z Y 'e ~~r J ~ ~ 't ~ - ~+rsr . ~ Yi,., ~ eh. tit a~, 'fir, jc - ~ WA J"' R.. _ t' kMt„~~,}~j.' ,~,s k . ~w _ -ota.isrt~= .,.o,. , ~ ~ '.;:1id!':.`~.Z'~~4Sn.'yf.~~.~•a~irz'ui.~~&~i~iFii i~lu~ rte. N ~ ~ 5 C~~ ST N . ~ C.~ ~ l I~Z ~~a ~ ~N ~ i,~~ z.~ ~ i7~"~„F ~ , , Y~ ~ r tW , 4 . . r _i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~s x ~ ~ H '-c.. a -ems. w«..ti.~' r. .wv _ 9' ~r.. "~"^M"°°§^„ - ,fie '°aI ,i~3 G tk 4: a ~ , t>. P ~,...y.....-- ...-..~....A1 ""'~aS a } Gam. ~~,,,.rut'~,.b ~..,~ia~-WRY ~ F ~t .W 7~°t4~,k k - -y` .-...-.+e^-•^'° , 3 3 ~ 'y a ~i#`..wr M' T, n y -.•-•-.r.s" u.-».y'.,~-gig ; w ,v, 5~ r ~.,M- ` e f+.?.. v m~ i t Yi w~ 'f A J f I ~ ~ ~ C~~ ST• so ~~E~~Ctd r.l 1 ! jZ } f G a N 1 a t µ . _ f i ap - ~ ~1 ~~ur tic r •4 1"` ~ ~ ~tyf ' t . M` j ,.I r3 ,ire s~-/C~~.y'. y~rl r ~ r% -i ' , . k ~ ~-3(• a~ ~~s \ . "'i ~ p i~- Y~ ikt Mk t1 Y4e,E 3~ ~ ..'r ti. ~~y~~-q{~. -~1- i , 'j~.~a.~ f 1"''"^+"~ ~ ,y ~ ~ dl~ 7 zIY T^/~ r,'~, 'Sf ?:i 'mot }e ~ v < i r~~''j(~•I'rX~~`; 'X~1.'1`.ir"91,_~r W?~..'L:4nL~v.7w~,I. +tg 1 x y~ ~ i 't~ 4 I:i l 't it , [y` ! ti ~`r; '4 8 a, ~d V t;~ .ii' } ~ rl ~k' _ 1$T}~~.., ..~~ry 'kj'.: ~i.4QyT~..~9.'r.~iS'~~y~.~`.~~..~. `~:~i0~1°.3fi 1:~c ~L %j'~~?~r ~ `~,@ytw~~ i~1Y~~1,ty17J {`~1 ;R\!t4~-l,~l~a ~.~!~~'~It' a { v~} iL4~ Q'k~1_!'~d yT pilO ~tjFE4r ~~1 t4`i ,4t~ i _,.r' L rLa ~y`S¦ j~ Y ~~~~t11'. r .ey uryr~ x y 49. t ~ a H !4 L ;~~b r,. ~y :f ~R~ ii . t ytu ~;:~6 `..'~'~L'.. ~-!G:Z'~r II J r l~W rc'P~' t• ~f 'r7 li y •rr y f 1~. ~'f, Q 5 Lam' J iI4 r~\, as t ~N ~ tf r r xetM +FS' .s ~ tr ~ f IJ' 1 ~ S ~Ye'li,, ~'l ,,P ~ .4' r. i ~.t >.~1 r S~ f~ ti~a r 'Jr . . Jr4. tit I' l ~fr 't ~'r 7 17 'l l , 1~ ~r 4 ~ 4,. _ ~ r ~ T.. _ / w t,'t'~; s ~ 1' Y~.. lif ` , ~ . R~,' t ~ 7's•*: ~ ~ ~e ryr :'a•~ r aq Syr ! y 3W }f 4~}.. ~ 1} ' . 1 ~ +r ~5 l,)1 +i '3$ w J 1 T~`.1 i d 1~. Y 4 (ir F ` 4r ,I `A. 7 it `,"~,.r s• ~ ~ it ,•`4 ~+1~~, ,~:{7:y~rya <.t`; 1 'aa"~'.,6~ ,,..rti JtfY ir~ ! x1 41 iiN 1yd„r' ~J ~ i,l~ 1 1f~ `'I+4 + ~ ~•1 r..:. l a~ ~F'4 X11; Gk:4''~il.. ,r li ' r.~ s ~ RIL 1~;,,I ~rti~i ~ ~.,..:5 1, gl~,t~,lja~~+'._`r~~~ ;PZ .r~ i.L1l ,r `nek rr w . 3 v'"!. wi .~y i,~ \ I ~ ' t~ ~~ki~ ~\r'1 4 i 1 W r ' Arnl', J~~ atj' 3'~li 'p15 l i { ~lt y~•~r~. .tr ~ y4':} # iii.r`.' rK. Ma, Y~~,a ' ~ .r~ ,k, ~~1%~' . eys ~r; In1 .rt x ..sj c t~T~i~ 'r'`~.Ll,4y.,~1 ~`~i } {x~~'`y~ ~i.~Y il` !!~'iy ~ 5 4'«~ r; 'tl~~"~ d ~ °i'~~:r >a ~ ~ Y yMt(, t' h; ~ 4~1 7~~' F~t~~ r~~ ~ ~,c ~ i~e4 X11 ?r'i~,~~ 1 .?Lf ,44~r~~ 1 ~.y~.ri ~'re,~ f F ti, ~ '~.r y _ < 4 t i. f 'i ' r ~ , r ~ \ A , . ~ i \ r (1 1 t T~ - a ~~y~`!`~y 1 t'' 4 y.Y:. ~ 1. •.f ~ ~f Y., L ,,ir i 4 y ,~~v.r I Y ~ `y~(~y ~~i !~ji{` I 4r R , a Ibp~~j`, ~ r1 i~,~.~i++yyyy~' ~ ' Q f 1{. r ~c ~ ~~B ~ Il:~ !tL jf ~,~11,,~,,~~G ~ l~~ i ~ da ~ 7 ~~~~;h 2 ~irll W'Jj~L 1 r~~;. C~.i •~.i~?r,~-~'~ a. 't,f >+\~~~f i'.I~~J'r7~~~'yyr ~..I~• 4 I~ r f ~ 1'.u ~~p~}~. `J~~4 I~r~~}F t61a?k 11'~ { ~.rT.1~'!j~.~~ Yy 'l 1~'ryw. r tic ~r.4. 4i~'\\~t'l. i '~.1 ~If~f~. I, ~.~`r~'E .l yy}. [,9: 4r rit:dkr ley r~'.IJ~~ 'f'i`r ~~nl'1`, .~i r..~a ;X%~114T,~.iy,~`~r~,,l ~PJ n.:, St~.~~i'M'i'°+~ 4 ..r. IS` yy ...I~, s'+~,; 1 4 ti{~ +IM r Ti ,ry 1 ~ ~,I ~ ~ s.- r F y~ii•~ L d.I. J .f' - "f,i tf ;r7 ' .r1L 1~ty `"li~'r '~A .,lY.f ~{I t. t`~V~~ ,F?lr~;N~~~ ~ la 'l ~rfil ~ h~,', ~,~~ur'i r~{'.4 } 'e ~4 'lirj4 7.I+i ~~r`~,'i ,'}~~~4Ct~~11 ~ F~~~, :1~~~~%l,~ °.a~~.~riii~~iw..~u.,. ~;Tb.,'. L~f.,~~~t: 11 ~?r ~'~1~~:+.':~.~a~l ~.R I ~ +,r~.:l+uCvrti..~'7'~~t~a.;}~r'41L~rC~Y~~%~.u5t~r~:.~.~~:1'. 1~ ; ;y h~M~~F:, -~{A ~.~~~5 $ l~ ~~ts. cwt N . W ~ R nJ E ~ 1 I I Z ~ / 0 'I J ,~'zL ' Y,Yr Tro~~s~e{;,~' bl+ .i ~yr1 Y~r~+µµ°,Ir r~~RI a F• Edt .hi~.~ .}ps ~ ,tif, ,3' k ;w~cjer~1t71' "2~+#.a 1` ~pti`s 'f }!A + M+ r ~ { ~ + i T ~7 .l~a , t\~;,' may, `~hl':11N',~ T ~1~~t. ;i P ~3 J~ ~ ~ ~ .+~1~r~ ~ fi S?{i~ Y q~+ !~-ti ''b ~ ~ I f a , ~ t 4~ pY _ a i a4 ` pn ?t n •~Jti ~.~YI ~ p~,.5 1 "'~'6 ` 9.' ,dl"k y.,.. .,x".,11 S 1 _~~~~1ri; s st-.:'t, ae~'^r' ~ ~ ~ ~ riv ~,f ~q h• Ip ~ kt , ~ ° wh i~ ~ ; ~ z'i~°:w>Fxt t^~a f R~~~..+ ~ S fi„r'~~ ~l+k'~ + ~k Y rr.. ~•_'Ca ~ a ~ E Gt*~~ .y~F~kD. i7~~ Arn~}a~w.•~C'. rJ' h~4 ~t _ i'~. rYr~ w~ -i S `-.q d . s t..c`.< S r t ! Y . r,. Ik. ~~~vR ~~t } J ~ a 1 cry, ~ ~ - ' ~-ib >t~ ~ • v 3' + J: r+~„i ~ if `S~ N ~ } t ~Id: y, ~ ; 3}}' i~ j; r,~ ~ ~i;r 3 r 5 ~ y 7~ t - r + l I 3*'" 1 3 tt : ~t i , r i;~„,~.x~ _ w H i G., y,i ~ _ <.r. giq 5~ ~ war w~~ IZ~ ~o~ v , . - d f ryt * ..Yi 1 ~ t ` F 115. ~ "+~N1b~~,F S ~ ~ j~' l.Vr 1 4r r i3`~" f ~ ~ _ per' 7 ~ k ~r z ' r may... :•V °r~~•.• ~ • 11r _ rf '~y~ y:n s J'' r. _ t~ E`er.' ee. ' F. a is ~ f-.~.i:''~ i r J' k t I ~ _ 9 ~ ~ t ~ 4 " ~ ~ ~ ( ` ~ F p ~ ~ .s. ~ ~ ~ s- y r S - ` rte ~'i ~~~_t F p~` y~ 4;,~n4 ~ ~ ,y eF~ t 's§,. ;z'. ...a°'°m..9.' 1, r d~ . 'i : r. ~ - a [ .:L' rl ..~'saa, S 4 ~ yT. w ~r win.`- ~ i ~ I z ~o • ~ Attachment C - Landmark Preservation Advisory Board Adopted 9/17/75 ~i~~ Secretary to the Board SIGNIFICANCE CRITERIA Individual Landmark $eptember 1975 On September 6, 1974, the City Council adopted Ordinance #4000 providing procedures for the designation of Landmarks and Historic Districts in the City of Boulder. The purpose of the ordinance is the preservation of the City's permitted cultural, historic, and azchitectural heritage. The Landmazks Board is permitted by the ordinance to adopt rules and regulations as it deems necessary for its own organization and procedures. The following Significance Criteria have been adopted by the Boazd to help evaluate each potential designation in a consistent and equitable manner. Historical Si¢nificance The place (building, site, azea) should show chazacter, interest or value as part of the development, heritage, or cultural chazacteristics of the community, state or nation; be the site of a historic, or prehistoric event that had an effect upon society; or exemplify to cultural, political, economic, or social heritage of the community. 1. Date of Construction: This azea of consideration places pazticulaz importance on the age of the structure. 2. Association with Historical Persons or Events: This association could be national, state, or local. 3. Distinction in the Development of the Community of Boulder: This is most applicable to an institution (religious, educational, civic, etc) or business structure, though is some cases residences might qualify. It stresses the importance of preserving those places which demonstrate the growth during different time spans in the history of Boulder, in order to maintain an awazeness of our cultural, economic, social or political heritage. 4. Recognition by Authorities: If it is recognized by Historic Boulder, Inc. the Boulder Historical Society, local historians (Barker, Crossen, Frink, Gladden, Paddock, Schooland, etc), State Historical Society, The hnnrovement of Boulder, Colorado by F.L. Olmsted, or others in published form as having historical interest and value: 1 04.OSsignif-indiv Page I of 3 • ~a tri' n--~ Architectural Significance The place should embody those distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type specimen, a good example of the common; be the work of an architect or master builder, known nationally, state-wide, or locally, and perhaps whose work has influenced later development; contain elements of azchitectural design, detail, materials or craftsmanship which represent a significant innovation; or be a fine example of the uncommon. 1. Recognized Period/Style: It should exemplify specific elements of an azchitectural period/style, ie: Victorian, Revival styles, such as described by Historic American Building Survey Criteria, Gingerbread Age (Maass), 76 Boulder Homes (Bazkar), The History of Architectural Stvle (Mazcus/Wiffin), Architecture iri San Francisco (Gebhazd et al), History of Architecture (Flectcher), Architecture/Colorado, acrd any other published source of universal or local analysis of "style." 2. Architect or Builder of Prominence: A good example of the work of an architect or builder who is recognized for expertise in his field nationally, state-wide, or locally. 3. Artistic Merit: A skillful integration of design, material, and color which is of excellent visual quality and/or demonstrates superior craftsmanship. 4. Example of the Uncommon: Elements of azchitectural design, details, or craftsmanship that are representative of a significant innovation. 5. Indigenous Oualities: A style or material that is particularly associated with the Boulder area. 6. Other, if applicable. Environmental Significance The place should enhance the variety, interest, and sense of identity of the community try the protection of the unique natural and man-made environment. 1. Site Characteristics: It should be of high quality in terms of planned or natural vegetation. 2. Compatibility with Site: Consideration will be given to scale, massing placement, or other qualities of design with respect to its site. 3. Geog_raphio Importance: Due to its unique location or singular physical characteristics, it represents an established and familiaz visual feature of the 04.OSsignif-indiv Page 2 of 3 /~rttlaNem/~ Pa~nA 2FC community. 4. Environmental A-ppronriateness: The surroundings aze complementary and/or it is situated in a manner particulazly suited to its function. Area Inteerity: Places which provide historical, architectural, or environmental importance and continuity of an existing condition, although taken singulazly or out of context might not qualify under other criteria. 6. Other, if applicable. S:\PLAN\data\Comdev\IIIS'I1GEN\Designation\About Landmazks\signif crit-indiv.wpd 04.OSsignif-indiv Page 3 of 3 Attachment D RESUME' HOBART D WAGENER FAIA ARCHITECT r PROFESSIONAL PROFILE: My architectural practice, Hobart D. Wagener Associates, was established in Boulder, Colorado, in 1953, and continued as our partnership, Wagener Vander Vorste Architects, from 1977 until I retired in 1986. We designed ~ more than two hundred projects many of which received design awards and were published in professional magazines. ~ In 1995 I was selected "Architect of the Year" for the State of Colorado. This recognition, awarded by the American Institute of Architects Colorado, is made annually to only one architect in the state; my award was received in the third year since the establishment of this program. In 1984 the local organization Historic Boulder selected me for the recognition "the outstanding designer in Boulder over the past 50 years". The professional magazine The Architectural Record included our own house in Boulder in its annual selection of twenty houses for national recognition. These residences were featured in the May, 1967, publication. A photograph of our home was the cover picture. The book 25 Years of Record Houses, Edited by Herbert L. Smith, Jr., and published in 1981 by McGraw-Hill, includes our own Boulder home in its selection of 500 award houses constructed throughout the United States during the past twenty-five years, 1956 to 1981. I co-authored the book The School Library with Ralph E: Ellsworth, Director of Libraries at the Univesity of Colorado; this research project for facilities for independent~~udy in the secondary school was done for the Ford Foundation's Educational Facilities Laboratories. I was president of the Colorado Society of the American Institute of Architects in 1973, president of the Boulder Chamber of Commerce in 1971, Chairman of the Boulder Planning Commission in 1966. I was selected to the College of Fellows of the American Institute of Architects, in 1971. This recognition, awarded by colleagues within the profession, is the second highest award made at the National level by the AIA, and is held by approximately 2600 architects in the United States. I am included in the Marquis publication Who's Who in America. s W_~ L i• _ ~n .1; ~ ! f Page 2 RESUME OF HOBART D. WAGENER, F.A.I.A. PROFESSIONAL My architectural practice, Hobart D. Wagener Associates, ; PROFILE was established in Boulder, Colorado, in 1953. Our present partnership, Wagener. Vander Vorste Architects, continues our commitment to quality design by personal involvement of partners throughout aIl phases of each project. • My professional experience began with Eggers & Higgins, Architects, in New York City (1946-1947), and continued with Pietro BeIlusch ; an internationally recognized architect, in Portland, Oregon (1947-.195D). In Boulder I worked with lames M. Hunter, Architect (195D-1953). Hobart D_ Wagener Associates and Wagener Vander Vorste Architects have designed over two hand"red projects including: C OMMER C IALJIN D U STR IAL Boulder Country Club First National Bank and Drive-Up Facility,. Boulder Public Service Offices, Boulder Acacia National Headquarters, Boulder 13 Branch Offices for Midland Federal Savings, including Boulder, :Arvada, Aurora, Longmont, Wesunirister, Pueblo, Ft. Collins, Greeley,. Lakewood, Loveland, Denver. .Ball. Brothers Technical Tower; Boulder Fruehauf's Plant & Garden Center; Boulder Executive Office Building, Boulder Lifecare Services Building, Boulder Koch Construction Office Bu~7dfng, Longmon$ , Hohnstein Bloch Renovation, Ft. Collins Mountain Savings Office, Boulder North Broadway Shopping Center, Boulder - - _ _ Rolling Hi71s. Country Club, Golden , Sunset Office Budding., Boulder • DUR Plaza Office Bu>Zding, Boulder Boulder Medical Center Addition DiIlon Community Center, Dillon Bodin Realty, Boulder: Community Plaza Shopping Center, Boulder < g PUBLIC Boulder County Hall of Justice and Clerk's Offices Boulder County Health and V.s;faze Budding Boulder County Mental Health Building Boulder Justice Center Central Fire Station, Boulder D9artin Park Recreation Building, Boulder North Boulder Recreation Building South Fire Station, Boulder Boulder Municipal Budding Addition SCHOOLS Baseline Junior High Addition, Boulder Boulder High School Addition Casey Junior High School Addition, Boulder Centennial Junior High School; Boulder Fairview Senior High School, Boulder Southern Hi'Ils Junior High School, Boulder RELIGIOUS Congregational Chur~l~ Remodelling, Boulder First Methodist Sanctuary, Boulder First Presbyterian Education Bufiding, ~$oulder Methodist Student CeYiter, University of Colorado St. John's Episcopal Chapel, Boulder Trinity Lutheran Sanctuary, Boulder UNIVERSITY Wiliiams Village Dormitories, University of Colorado: Darley & Stearns Towers Kittredge Dormitory Complex, University of Colorado: Andrews, Arnett, Buchingham & Smith Halls, & Commons Building (Principal in charge in joint venture of architects) Engineering Sciences Complex, University of Colorado (Minor member in joint venture of architects) es..ns w..~. s 'r- i' _ ? ~ Page 4 MULTIPLE HOUSING . Presbyterian Manor Apartments, Boulder XIII West Apartments, Boulder Pazkhampden Apaztments, Denver Ski $anch on blt. Werner, Steamboat Springs Kappa Alpha Theta Addition, Boulder RESIDENCES Approximately one hundred new homes and additions including: Baztkus, Boulder Buchanan, Boulder Gazrett, Loveland Gebhazdt (now Fairbanks), Boulder Pazke, Ft. Collins Short, Boulder Souers, Boulder Stampfli, Salida UdaIl, Ft. Collins Wagener (now Moses), Boulder M~71er, Palo Alto, California Barrett, Caldwell, Idaho PROFESSIONAL We have received design awards from the Western AWARDS AND Mountain Region American Institute of Architects, RECOGNITION American Association of School Administrators, Federal Housing Authority, and Sunset Magazine. Projects receiving awards include: Fairview High School - . Southern Hffis Junior High School Boulder Country Club - Presbyterian Manor Apartments First Presbyterian Church Education Building Casey Junior High School Addition Mountain Savings Office Mercantine (now United) Bank .(before remodelled) :.:IvIetliodist Student Center Wagener Residence ~ l ~ ~ ; Pa e5 i / g Magazines which have published articles of our projects. include The Architectural Record, Architectural Forum, Nation's Schools, New York Times, House Beautiful, and Sunset. Published projects include: Fairview High School . Boulder High School Addition Southern Hills Junior High School Casey Junior High School Addition Boulder Country Club Midland Federal Savings Office, Aurora Mountain Savings Office Boulder Justice Center ' First Presbyterian Church Education Building Methodist Student Center Presbyterian Manor Apartments Kittredge Dormitory Complex William Village Dormitories Numerous Residences The Wagener Residence is one of twenty houses recognized by The Architectural Record magazine for its annual National. House Awards in 1967. The book 25 Years of Record Houses, recently published. by the editor o Arc 'tectur Recor ,includes the Wagener house as one of its selection of 57 Award Houses constructed throughout the United States during the past twenty-five years. I was made a Fellow :in the American Institute of Architects in 1971: This recognition, awarded by coIleagues within the profession, is held by approximately 1600 architects in the United States. I am included in the Marquis publication Who's Who in America. ~ ~ Page- s CIVIC AND I have participated on community boazds, committees, and PROFESSIONAL organizations including: ACTIVITIES Boulder City Planning Board (Vice Chairman & Chairman) Boulder Chamber of Commerce (Vice President & President) Boulder Lions Club (Vice President & President) Junior Achievement Program [President) Boulder Art Association (Vice President) Presbyterian Church IIder (Member of the Session) ' Colorado State Supreme Court Selection Committee appointed by the Governor of Colorado I have served as Treasurer, Secretary, Vice President,. and President of the Colorado State Society of the, American Institute of Architects. PERSONAL AND I was born in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, in 1921, graduated EDUCATIONP.I~ from the University of Michigan (B. Arch., 1944), and served as a line officer in the Navy during Work Waz::II. We have traveled extensively in Europe, South America, Central America, Canada, Mexico, and Japan. My wife,. Violet (B.A., Indiana University,. M.L.S., University of Michigan) is a librarian. " Our children are: Diane (B.S., University of Colorado, P.H.D., Stanford and Harvard) is a geneticist at the University of Pittsburgh. Jeff (B.S. & M.D., University of Colorado) is a ~•pediatrician:af.the UniveYsity.~of. flriznna..MediaaI Schmol. i,"Slvavf.:(B_A.,'ClaremnnY MerisrcCbllege):is an. executive intern at the Capital Group, Los Angeles. ' . _ _ iWho'sVVho in ~ine~ica® 54th Edition • 20DD a *WA54BC-0--0443910004 Since 1899, America's leading biographical reference source. MARQUIS WHO's WHO POST. PUB UPDATE BC 0 121 Chanlon Road• P.O. Box 2 ~ New Providence NJ 07974-0002 Phone: I-800fi21~669 ext. lots Fax: 1-908-771-8645 E-mail: ameriu@renp.com AMERICA-54 0443910( For your records, we have reproduced your biography as it will appear ie she 54th Edition of WHO'S WHO IN AMERICA. Our files for she 54th Edition are now closed. PLEASE: -HOLD ALL UPDATES to your sketch until you receive our update requut for the 55th Edition. (Updates submitted a[ Nis time cannot be incorpoutedJ MABBUIS WXU'S WHO exercises the premed care in pmoling, -DO CNECK CAREFULLY THE MAILING ADDRESS SHOWN BELOW. I( any changes are and otherwise handling dasa snbmilted to it. A biographical ss appropriate, please note them on this form and. return the form [o us in the envelope provided. is based an inlormetion submitted by she p~rrsoa under consider for inclusion. The stemA is edlled by Mm'gnis Who's Whe, ant Thant you for your rime and eoopention during the compilation of the 54th Edition. moss uses is nluroed so the Dersoe to eAecY iI tar accuricy. the event al any error fn publicalioa, tha sole responsiA ilisy of Mnquis Who's Who will ba to corraa ucA error le a sut[eeal edition of Dubli utloe. SY[h cofrenloa is +n lice of uy olAn Hobar t D . Wagener remedy. Margo fs WAO's Who expressly disclaims NI other li abl 1730 Avenida Del Mundo for loss or incidental or coasequenlial lama gs whetter arising ; OegIIgMO, conlratl, or other Ouse 1a ley party for errors is Coronado, CA 92118-3021 pnelisaing. Signature Date FOR OFFICE 04439100/N/110/950/ /1921/M/NNNNNNN---/A USC ONLY 9 Copy:igh[ 799S, hfARQUlS WisJ> Who. Aif r;gli~ ttsc Underlined information will not appear O NOT RETURN SKE7'C~ in the published biography. Unless 3'dP~are needed. BAS WAGENER, HOBART D., retiretl architect; b. PAR Sioux Falls, S.D., May 10, 7921; s. Frank Samuel and Beatrice (HODart) W.; m. Violet LaVaughn, Dec. 16, 7944; chtltlren: Diane Kay Wagener Welch, Jeffrey Scott, Shaw EDU 010 Bratltey. BArch, U. Mich., 7944. CER Registered architect, Colo. CAR 010 Draftsman Eggers & Higgins, 020 Architects, N.Y.C., 1946-47, Pietro Belluschi, Architect, Portland, Oreg., 030 1947-50: designer James Hunter, 040 Architect, Boultler, Coto., 1950-53; prin. - Hobart D. Wagener Assocs., Boultler, 1953-77; 050 prin. ptnr. Wagener VanderVOrste, _ 060 Architects, Boulder, 7977-86; vet., 7986; CRE mem. selection tom. Colo. Supreme Ct., CRW Denver, 7968-72. Co-author: The School Lf brary, 7962; work pub. in Archtl. Recortl, Sunset msg., N.Y. Times, House Beautiful, 25 CIV Years of Recortl Houses. Chmn. Boultler Planning Colmm~., 1966; pres. Boulder C. of C., 7971'. Lt. (S .g.) USN, 1944-46, PTO. 4WD Named Out Stantling Designer for past 50 yrs. Hirt. Boultler, 1983; also numerous nat. NEM and regional tlestgn awartls. Fellow AIA (pres. Colo. 1973, Colo. Architect of Yr. awartl 7985, pres. awar N, chpt. 1998), Lions 4CH (pres. Boultler 1965). Avocations: 4DR 070 travel, golf. Address: 1730 Avenitla - Del Muntlo Coronado CA 92718-3027 79 _435-5403 ~laa Nero roc Pam CHANGE See reservation form for your special pre-publication discounts. n n„,. ~e~nnn~ n .Lis csror_n___nuu]91. fl ti SLIDES OF BUILDINGS FROM HOBART D. WAGENER OFFICES 1: Our architectural office building at 777 Twenty-ninth Street. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit award, 1960. 2: -First Presbyterian Church Education Building & Courtyard at 16th and Walnut. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Honor award, 1957. This was my first major commission after opening my office in 1953. 3: Fairview High School, 1515 Greenbriar. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Honor award, 1973 4: Fairview High School interior, Student Center. 5: Casey Junior High School, 2410 Thirteenth Street. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit award, 1957. 6: Southern Hills Junior High School, 1500 Knox Drive. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit Award, 1962; special citation from American Association of School Administrators;. 7: Centennial junior High School, 2205 Norwood Avenue. 8: Kittredge Dormitory Complex, University of Colorado. I was the design architect with the partnership Associated Architects of Colorado for this project. 9: Kittredge Dormitory Complex. 10: Williams Towers Dormitory Complex, Baseline & 30th. 11: First Methodist Church Sanctuary addition, 1401 SpruFe. 12: First Methodist Church Sanctuary interior. 13: St. john's Episcopal Church Chapel, 1419 Pine. 14: Proposed expansion plan for St. John's Episcopal church courtyard. ~ _ , 31: Wesley Foundation Student Center & Chapel, 2400 University Heights. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit award, 1958. 32: Fruelsauf's Nursery & Greenhouse, 1665 33rd Street. 33: Community Plaza, Alpine & Broadway. (original before remodeling). 34: Our family home at 3230 Fifth Street. (the second home we built after remodeling a chicken coop into our first home at 3222 Fifth Street). 35: Our family home at 7060 Roaring Fork Trail, (the third home we built). Western Mountain Region, AIA, Honor Award, 1967. Sunset Magazine Western Home Awards program, Honor Award,19fi7 Published as one of 20 homes selected nationally as record homes for the year 1967 by the Architectural Record Magazine. Included in the book " 25 years of Record Houses" published by McGraw-Hill; selected as one of 57 award-winning of the record homes from throughout the co~untry~deusriens~g the period 1956 -1981. Now owned by RK fjt p1/'~~z 36: Udall residence, Claymore Lake west of Ft. Collins. This is the first project I designed after opening my own office in 1953. 37. Gebhardt residence, Gunbarrel. 38. Miller residence, Palo Alto, California. 39: Hewes residence, 335 Sixteenth street. 15: Boulder Country Club, Gunbarrel Greens. Western Mountain Region, AIA, First Honor award, 1965. 16: First National Bank original building, Broadway & Canyon. 17: First National Bank redesign and reconstruction; Wallace Palmer associated on this project. 18: Mountain Saving & Loan Building, Broadway & Mapleton. Western Mountain Region, AIA, Design of Excellence, 1956. 19: Mercantile Bank & Trust, 13th & Walnut (before remodeled as United Bank of Boulder, which, I believe, now is merged with Norwest Bank). Western Mountain Region, AIA, Merit award, 1957. 20: Midland Savings & Loan branch in Ft. Collins. (now Bank Western). 21: Midland Savings & Loan branch interior, Downtown Ft. Collins. 22: Midland Savings & Loan branch in Lakewood. (now Bank Western) 23: Midland Savings & Loan branch in Arvada. (now Bank Western) 24: Presbyterian Manor Apartments, 1050 Arapahoe Avenue. Federal Housing Authority National Awards program, First Honor award, 1963. 25: Ball Brothers Technical Tower, Boulder Industrial Park. 26: Boulder County Justice Center, 6th & Canyon. 27: Boulder City Hall addition, Broadway & Canyon. 28: Boulder Central Fire Station, 2405 Thirteenth Street. 29: Public Service Main office, Broadway & Canyon. (now a restaurant). 30: Durr Office building, 675 29th Street. Attachment E MAHINDER S. UBEROI (December 21, 2006) Former faculty member Mahinder S. Uberoi of aerospace engineering sciences at CU-Boulder died on Nov. 25 in Boulder. He was 82. Dr. Uberoi was born in 1924 in India. He later became a naturalized U.S. citizen. He earned his doctorate from Johns Hopkins University in 1953 and was named a Guggenheim Fellow in 1957. He served on the faculty at the University of Michigan until 1963, when he joined the CU faculty as chair of the newly named department of aerospace engineering sciences. Dr. Uberoi had earned a reputation for his work in magneto hydrodynamics, turbulent flow and other basic sciences of fluid flow. As chairman, he built up the new department, adding faculty strong in basic research areas in fluids, controls and biology (to create a bioengineering program). His theory was to bring in researchers strong in basic sciences and have them apply their work to engineering. His term as chair ended in 1975• He was the author or co-author of a number of scholarly papers, including "Directional Spectrum of Wind Generated Ocean Waves," published in the Journal of Fluid Dynamics in 1963; "Magnetically Distorted Polytropes: Structure and Radial Oscillations," in The Astrophysical Journal in 1972; and "Magnetized Positive Column Between Coaxial Cylinders," in Physica Scripta in 1986. Dr. Uberoi later filed eight lawsuits over six years against the University, alleging among other complaints, discrimination against foreign-born faculty, hazardous laboratory conditions and violations of the state's Public Records Act. He was terminated as a member of the CU faculty in 2000, making him the first tenured faculty member to be dismissed by the Board of Regents. His case arguing that CU was subject to the open records law went to the Colorado Supreme Court. The court ruled in 1984 that the law did not apply to CU, but in 1985 the Legislature enacted a subsection to the law, bringing-every state institution of higher education, including the University of Colorado, under the provisions of the open records act. Dr. Uberoi also was a longtime member of the folkdance community in Boulder. He had no family in the local area. Crist Mortuary of Boulder was handling arrangements. Regents terminate tenured professor MAHINDER UBEROI FIRED'FOR CAUSE' FROM UCB POST February 24, 2000 By Jefferson Dodge In a highly unusual move, the Board of Regents approved a resolution last week dismissing one of CU-Boulder's tenured professors, an individual who has filed numerous lawsuits against the university and has claimed for years that CU has hindered his teaching and research. Mahinder Uberoi, a 75-year-old full professor who has been rostered in UCB's College of Engineering and Applied Science since ig62, was terminated for cause. Whereas faculty are sometimes dismissed because of budgetary constraints or program discontinuance, termination for cause is described in the CU Faculty Handbook as "demonstrable professional incompetency, neglect of duty, insubordination or other conduct which falls below minimum standards of professional integrity." The board's resolution notes that iTberoi was given an opportunity to be heard before a faculty committee and the regents. It also states that the dismissal, which was recommended by President John Buechner, will not be effective until Feb. 28, 2ooi, so Uberoi will continue to receive his $40;520 annual salary for one more year. "This action by the Board of Regents makes a significant statement in two ways," the regents said in a prepared statement. "First, we value the tenured faculty at the University of Colorado. Their importance is strengthened by the board's action. Second, the regents are restating our long- term commitment that with faculty rights go responsibilities." Because of legal concerns, CU officials would not comment further about the action, and Uberoi did not return calls from Silver & Gold Record. But a review of previous 58cGR articles and several documents obtained in an open records request reveal that Uberoi and the University have been at odds for decades. Uberoi, a native of Delhi, India, who became a naturalized U.S. citizen, earned his Ph.D. in engineering in 1952 from Johns Hopkins University and six years later, was named a John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Fellow for study and research at European universities. After serving as chair of UCB's aerospace engineering sciences department from ig62 to 1975, he appeared before the regents in 1976 to object to the appointment of Franklin Essenberg as the new chair of aerospace engineering sciences, accusing engineering Dean Max Peters of ethnic discrimination. Six years latei, he filed a $i55 million lawsuit against CU and 6z University officials and employees, including President Arnold Weber, UCB Chancellor Harrison Shull, regents, faculty, department chairs and engineering deans. In the suit, Uberoi alleged that CU had blocked the hiring of foreign-born professors, claiming that when he was department chair he had been ordered not to hire C.S. Yih of the University of Michigan, who is of Chinese descent. Uberoi also said in the suit that the University had disrupted his research, reduced his academic standing and rendered him a "professor without a portfolio," with no classes or other academic work. Uberoi alleged that he had received poor teaching evaluations because of unsubstantiated student opinions and was exposed to carcinogenic chemicals after he was forced to clean up oil spills in his lab when his requests for better working conditions were ignored. The lawsuit ballooned over the following few years, as Uberoi filed a half dozen other complaints against CU, including an assault and battery charge against campus police. In 1984, after Uberoi had requested a host of documents under the state Open Records Law to buttress his suit against CU, the Colorado State Supreme Court denied his request, ruling 5-z that the state's sunshine laws did not apply to the University. Largely because of that ruling, by i98~ the Legislature passed bills placing CU and the Board of Regents within the scope of the Open Records Law, a move that allowed then-State Rep. Bill Owens to sue CU later that year for withholding information about a planned sabbatical in Cuba for Larry Mosqueda of political science at UCD. In ig86, U.S. District Court~i~adge Lae West dismissed i7ber_o suit against-the University as "frivolous" and ordered him to pay CU's court costs, which were later determined to be $9,000. In dismissing the suit, West said Uberoi had "sabotaged" the case by failing to comply with federal rules and orders of the court. West said Uberoi submitted an "absolute avalanche of procedural motions and reconsiderations" after the court had denied the same motions once, twice or three times. "The conclusion is inescapable, he does not seek a fair trial on the merits, but only to punish the defendants for disagreeing with him on any matter, important or unimportant;' West wrote. "[Uberoi's] demands, if met, would make a mockery of the court system." In i99o, after Uberoi had persisted with his litigation against CU, the Colorado Court of Appeals ruled that he must stay out of the courts unless he hires an attorney, upholding a Boulder District Court decision disallowing Uberoi from serving "pro se" as his own attorney, which he had done throughout the previous decade. During the i98os, on his annual UCB reports of scholarly, professional and university activities, Uberoi listed his litigation efforts against CU under "Public Service in a Professional Capacity." He also claimed in those reports that former engineering Dean Richard Seebass "denied Uberoi s request to teach in tJberoi s /1Qari7 Ems. e r, o...._,. Cl7 discipline, stating that there are no courses for Uberoi to teach in the College of Engineering." Uberoi also alleged in the reports that Seebass and others had packed up his teaching and research materials and put them in storage. "For years, the University has not allowed me to teach," Uberoi wrote in a letter to the editor of S&GR in 1989. "It has dismantled and destroyed my research projects. It has packed my research data and writings in 35 large boxes and moved them to unknown places." Since records indicated that he has not filed an annual report of his activities since i99o, it is unclear what i7beroi s teaching and research load has been over the past io years, although he is listed in UCB course catalogs as the instructor of several classes during the 1992-93 academic year. Aoerda Ils~ea C7', o~= i1 ~ Attachment F James Hewat -Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board/Uberoi House/819 6th Street From: To: Date: 12/30/2007 2:55 PM Subject: Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board/Uberoi House/819 6th Street To the Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board: We are writing to support the proposed demolition of the house at 819 Sixth Street in Boulder. This structure is incongruous with the surrounding neighborhood and has been regarded as an eyesore for many years. Anew home on this property would be welcome! We are residents of the immediate neighborhood, one block east of the above property, and have lived here for 35 years. We walk by the house almost daily and have watched it deteriorate over the years. We are in fawx of saving old houses whenever possible (our own house is over 100 ears old), but this house does not appear to have enough character to warrant the expense of saving it. Your positive consideration of this proposal would be appreciated. Thank you. John and Helen Whitbeck 879 Seventh Street Boulder CO 80302 303-443-2636 See AOL's top_rate_d recipes and easy_wa~s._to stay in shame for winter. ApNdaIll111# ~(GPege@~ 1/2/2008) James Hewat - 819 6th Street _ . Page 1 ' From: Robin Luff <robinluffCclyahoo.com> To: <hewatjCc?bouldercolorado.gov> Date: 12/5/2007 7:01 PM Subject: 819 6th Street ....is an eye sore. Please allow for demolition. Robin & Kevin Luff 850 6th Street - - rrs Vii' - (1/2/2008) James Hewat - Hearing on 819 6th st From: Jane Butcher <cwisdom@mac.com> To: <hewatj@bouldercolorado.gov> Date: 12/412007 9:29 AM Subject: Hearing on 819 6th st To the Landmarks Preservation Board, I live at 595 Aurora Ave just down the street from 819 6th St. I pass that property several times a day as I have for many years. It is a common structure with no outstanding features and is in a deplorable state of repair. There are many similar structures throughout Boulder and this is no prime example of any particular architecture. I urge you to allow the destruction of the building by a potential new owner. The prospect of a new green building would enhance that lot and the rest of the neighborhood. There is nothing to be gained by waiting for 6 months and the current building is not worth preserving. The neighborhood has been very patient with Mr. Uberoi knowing full well his love of suing. I would have testified but have a previous family commitment. Please let me know if I can be of any further help in this matter. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Jane W. Butcher 595 Aurora Ave Boulder, Colorado 80302 303 449-3457 ~B~rl~ ~(/Deir¦ ~~n X1/2/2008) James Hewat -hearing on 819 6th Street Page 1 From: <loumoeller@comcast.net> To: <hewatj@bouldercolorado.gov> Date: 12/3/2007 8:57 PM Subject: hearing on 819 6th Street Dear Landmarks Preservation Board, 12/3/07 We are writing as neighbors of 819 6th Street, the Uberois property. We have lived at 885 Circle Drive for 17 years, a block and a half from this property. We appreciate the importance of considering the architectural value of a house. However in our view, this property does not have sufficient architectural interest to warrant a 6 month study of the property. We would be in favor of allowing the property to immediately be sold "as is" with the ability for a future owner to either demolish the structure for future construction or remodel the existing structure. Delaying the process or declaring it architecturally significant does not seem to us to be a good idea. Thank you for considering our perspective on this property. Sincerely, Lou and Mark Moeller 885 Circle Drive Boulder • ~i• - - i.~ Page l of 1 ~ ~ James Hewat -Action under consideration for 819 - 6th Street, Boulder CO 80302 From: "Dorothea El Mallakh" To: Date: 11/24/2007 4:07 PM Subject: Action under consideration for 819 - 6th Street, Boulder CO 80302 A portion of my east lot line abuts the west boundary of 819 - 9th Street. I noticed a sign today for some t)rpe of hearing by the Landmarks Commission posted on the property. Could you tell me what that might be? Thank you. Dorothea EI Mallakh 850 Willowbrook Road Boulder CO 80302 Phone: 303-442-4014 /IpWldellem* c F'ags~