Loading...
4A - Update on the implementation of Climate Action Plan (CAP) regarding proposed changes to Commercial and Residential Green Building Codes WEEKLY INFORMA'T'ION PACKET MEMORANDUM To: Mayor McGrath and Membexs of City Council From: Stephanie A. Grainger, Interim City Manager Pau] Fetherston, Deputy City Manager Maureen Rait, Executive Director of Public Works Neil Poulson, Chief Building Official Kirk Moors, Senior Plans Examiner Jonathan Koehn,l?nvironmental Affairs Manager Date: July 24, 2008 Subject: Information Item: LJpdate on the implementation of Climate Action Plan regarding proposed changes to Commercial and Residential Green Building Codes PtiRPOSE: The implementation of the city's Climate Action Plan (CAP) involves activities across many city departments and operations and includes various strategies to reduce greenhouse gas (GIIG) emissions. A status report on the further development of regulatory options involving the city's building codes is being provided at this time. Information on other CAP related implementation efforts is planned for distribution in a July 31, 2008 Weekly Information Packet item. 1'he status of CAP programs and potential CAP tax rates, including more information on the results and program selection rationale will be presented in the July 31 W]P. Staff from the Transportation Division of the Public Works Department will t-eturn to council and appropriate boards for consideration of amendments to the Transportation Master Plan ('I'MP) to reflect the modifications suggested by the FasTracks Local Optimization (PLO) process later this year. EXk;CUTIVI+; StJMMARY: At the Jan. 25, 2008 City Council retreat, council members identified goals including enhancing the energy performance of new commercial construction in the short term and developing a comprehensive commercial code by year end. A city council study session on the Climate Action Plan (CAP), transportation and renewable energy strategies to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions was held on April 8, 2008. Council generally supported the development and implementation of a commercial green building program, and acknowledged that a commercial code should consider future International Energy Conservation Code (IECC) updates and that work should be carefully coordinated with local developers, building professionals and staff. Council also expressed a desire to include requirements for remodels and additions in the Residential Cireen Points program. In response to council feedback, staff has developed a plan for the proposed adoption of Commercial and Residential Green Building Codes in 2008. The plan addresses the goal of 1 improving commercial energy efficiency by 30 percent and also provides for other code improvements meant to align building code regulations with the goals of the Climate Action Plan (CAP). Proposed code changes are scheduled for Planning Board review on Oct. 2, 2008 and City Council consideration on Oct. 21, 2008. In order to align code adoptions with CAP priorities, the proposed plan outlines a path to achieve eventual carbon neutrality in buildings, pursuant to the 2030 Challenge (developed by Ed Mazria) to address energy consumption. COMMUNITY SUSTAINABILI'I'Y ASSESSMENTS AND IMPACTS: Economic: The adoption and consistent application of building codes and standards support all segments of the community and a sustainable economy. Proposed code changes should be evaluated to demonstrate how the economic impact and investment is offset by increasing energy efficiency and corresponding reductions in ongoing operational costs. F.nvironmenta[: Building codes play an important role in reducing energy use and carbon emissions in the city's new and existing building stock. Reducing energy use in existing buildings, especially rental housing and leased commercial space, may not be achieved sufficiently through voluntary measures. Social: Building codes address the social impacts of the Boulder community by supporting the management of potential impacts to life and property. Additionally, energy efficiency improvements benefit the community by reducing carbon emissions. Homeowners benefit with lower, more predictable utility bills as energy prices continue to increase. Requirements for existing buildings could be expected to benefit tenants. FISCAI. IiYIPACT: Costs for the implementation of these code changes, including training for customers and staff, are included within the city's operating budget. Periodic code update and maintenance is part of the normal work plan involving the use of staff resources. RACK(GROUND: Boulder periodically updates its construction codes. This effort is done in a coordinated and integrated manner in order to maintain a practical balance between safety and costs to protect life and property while advancing green building objectives pertaining to sustainable development. The 2006 International knergy Conservation Code (IECC), adopted by the city on Oct. 30, 2007 (and in effect since Jan. 2. 2008), applies to both commercial and residential construction. updates to the residential Green Points were adopted on Nov. 13, 2007 (and became effective Fcb. I, 2008). The "Green Building" components of the program involve requirements that establish: • Energy efficiency baselines above the 2006 IECC, • Consm~ction waste recycling on new construction, • An energy audit and efficient lighting for an existing house with a remodel or addition, • Deconstruction for remodels removing 50 percent or more of the exterior walls. The Green Points component remains similar to the prior program requiring a specific amount of points (determined by project type and size) which are obtained by choosing green point 2 options outlined in a menu of green practices, technologies and products in the Green Points Guidelines booklet. Since a significant portion of development activity in Boulder involves residential remodels and additions, as part of the 2007 Green Points adoption process, council requested that staff evaluate an amendment to Green Points to respond to the concern that some threshold of "additions" and "remodels" should be evaluated as "new construction" for the purpose of applying energy efficiency requirements. In this evaluation, staff was directed to review the Boulder County threshold for new construction. Council requested that the ordinance be scheduled for the Nov. 13, 2007 meeting as a public hearing (in addition to first reading). Ordinance 7570 was considered at first reading, but concerns about potential unintended consequences, such as encouraging more scrape-offs, resulted in direction to staff to evaluate alternative approaches. At the January 25, 2008 City Council retreat, council members identified goals including enhancing the energy performance of new commercial construction in the short term and developing a comprehensive commercial code by year end. A city council study session on the Climate Action Plan (CAP), and transportation and renewable energy strategies to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions was held on April 8, 2008. Council generally supported the development and implementation of a commercial green building program and acknowledged the importance of implementing an above-code energy requirement to avoid any missed opportunities. Council acknowledged that any commercial code should consider future International Energy Conservation Code (IECC) updates and that work should be carefully coordinated with local developers, building professionals and staff. Council also urged caution and sensitivity in developing a commercial green building code that might impact the business community or economic vitality. Council also expressed a desire to include requirements for remodels and additions in the Residential Green Points program. The summary of the April 8, 2008 study session was accepted by the City Council on May 2U, 2008. ANALYSIS: Tn response to council feedback., staff has developed a plan for the proposed adoption of Commercial and Residential Green Building Codes in 2008. 'hhe plan addresses the immediate goal of improving commercial energy efficiency by 30 percent and also projects other code improvements meant to align building code regulations wish the goals of the Climate Action Plan (CAP). The current city goal, Kyoto Protocol, is to reduce carbon emissions seven percent below 1990 levels by 2012. It is staff's intent to open the discussion with City Council nn goals beyond 2012, which will assist staff in understanding what the next phase is in relation to reducing energy use and carbon emissions. More aggressive greenhouse gas goals are being developed by industry and stakeholder groups across the country and throughout the world identifying the next step in creating a sustainable energy future. In order to align code adoptions with CAP priorities, the proposed plan outlines a path to achieve eventual carbon neutrality in buildings, pursuant to the 2030 Challenge (developed by Ed Mazria) to address energy consumption. 3 Aligning building regulations with the overall CAP involve complex and controversial issues. In order to facilitate working through these issues, staff has considered green building proposals for the following six categories which are also shown in Attachment C;: 1. New International Residential Code (IRC) Construction (Duplexes, Townhouses and Single Family Dwellings) 2. IRC Remodels and Additions 3. Existing IRC Buildings (No Permit Activity) 4. New International Building Code (IBC) Construction (Commercial, Industrial and Multiple-residences) 5. IBC Remodels and Additions 6. Existing IBC Commercial, Industrial and Multiple-residences (No Permit Activity) Proposed 2008 Green Building Changes: As described previously and depicted in Attachment C, code changes were implemented earlier this year for residential construction with the adoption of the updated Green Building and Green Points (GBGP) and amulti-tiered residential Home Energy Rating System (HERS) "above- code" program. Depending on the square footage of a residential structure, the percentage above the currently adopted 2006 IECC varies from a minimum of 30 to a maximum of 7,5 percent. While the GBGP is a residential program, the residential portions of mixed-use developments have also been required to attain energy efficiency compliance 30 percent better than the baseline 2006 IECC. T'he 2006 IECC was also adopted in early 2008 for commercial and industrial projects constructed within the city of Boulder. The 2006 IECC simplified the methods for designing projects but did not substantively require enhancements to the overall energy efficiency of commercial and industrial buildings from the previous code. Staff is currently developing the analysis required to amend the 2006 IF,CC to meet the 30 percent commercial energy improvement. If adopted, the commercial components of the typical mixed-use development will attain a level of energy efficiency compliance 30 percent above the IECC. Attaining this level of efficiency will eliminate the current discrepancy that exists between the energy efficiency required for commercial and residential occupancies in mixed-use buildings. As noted, the City Council previously directed staff to amend the GBGP ordinance 7565) by establishing a threshold for when a remodel and addition is extensive enough to warrant being regulated as new construction. The threshold was to be developed without increasing incentives to totally demolish existing housing to accommodate rebuilding larger structures. A first reading of the resulting Ordinance 7570 was conducted on Nov. 13, 2007, but no further action was taken due to concerns about potential unintended consequences, such as encouraging more scrape-offs. Staff' has examined alternative approaches and a second reading of the ordinance is currently scheduled for council consideration at the Oct. 21, 2008 council meeting with the intent of the ordinance being effective on Jan.S, 2009. 4 In response to council's direction to develop an above-code program for commercial construction energy efficiency, staff has been researching the requirements of other cities that are also actively developing sustainable building regulations such as Portland, Oregon; Chicago, Illinois and Albuquerque, New Mexico. Standards such as LEER, Green Globes, and the United Kingdom program BREEAM were also considered in concert with the Boulder County Consortium of Cities development of a green building code, which is meant to facilitate the consistent adoption of green building requirements far local jurisdictions. An important consideration for developing an above-code program is establishing a consistent baseline reference. Most of the above-code energy efficiency standards that have been developed reference the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) standard 90.1-2004. Z`his is also the design standard referenced by the 2006 IECC. When a percentage above code is referenced through the rest of the document the baseline considered is ASHRAE 90.1-2004. The research done by staff suggests that compliance with the commercial 30 percent above-code energy efficiency level can be attained through the criteria detailed in Chapter 5 of the 2006 IECC which includes: 1. ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1, Energy Standard for Buildings Except for Low-Rise Residential Buildinas. 2. United States Department of Energy, building energy requirements calculated through the ComCheck computerized design program, most current version, www.doe.~. 3. Staff would also accept alternate design methods that could detail 30 percent better than code such as ASHRAE standard 189.1 and the Advanced Energy Design Guides. Staff also recommends that commercial buildings over 21),000 syuare feet be required to include modeling as suggested by a stakeholder from the local design professional community. Energy modeling is also a feature of the above-code program developed by Albuquerque, New Mexico for buildings that are over 20,000 square feet. An ordinance representing council's direction will be drafted and presented to the Planning Board and City Council. The proposed code adoption schedule is outlined in Attachment A and the implementation date of Jan. 5, 2009 is planned to allow time for staff to provide public education programs prior to adoption. This code adoption time frame also allows building designers to "gear-up" wish commercial and industrial projects currently in the design phase. An alternate proposal was presented to the council from local stakeholders that suggested adopting ASIIRAE 189.1 (207 pages long) as part of the city of Boulder commercial green building code. This standard has just come out of a public comment period and wilt not be ready far adoption until early 2009. Stal'i~will include the review oi'this document in the 2009 IECC review and adoption process. When this design criteria is completed by ASHRAE, it could be used as an alternate design acceptable through the adoption of the 2006 IECC 30 percent above- code program. i Attachment B also summarizes other code change proposals planned for 2008 that would be combined with this effort in order to facilitate training and code change implementation foT• customers and staff. Proposed 2009/2010 Green Building Changes: Within the first half of 2009, the International Code Council (ICC) will publish the 2009 International Energy Conservation Code. Staff will review the 2009 IECC, the currently adopted codes and other nationally developed green building standards and provide recommendations fo council for a comprehensive Green Building Code that meets the needs of the city of Boulder. Recommendations will be provided to council relating to items #l, #2, #4 and #5 outlined in Attachment C. Work associated with upgrading to a modified 2009 IECC will begin in the second or third quarter of 2009 (depending on when the 2009 IECC is published) with an implementation date of January 2010. It is also planned that staff will include the proposed 2010/2012 requirements into the 2009 adoption process. For Green Building proposals related to residential construction, staff will review the current city GBGP program, the 2009 .IECC and other green building information before making recommendations to the council. Preliminarily, staff is considering that the 30 to 75 percent above code HERS requirements would be retained when the 2009 codes are adopted. The recent development of green building codes such as the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/ICC Green Building Code means that it is now possible to adopt a nationally developed green building code. Staff will develop recommendations for amendment and adoption of the 2009 IECC, and the NAHB/ICC Model Green Home Building Guidelines to accomplish the energy efficiency and sustainabitity goals of the GBGP program without the complications of developing and maintaining a city produced document and point system. In regard to existing residential constriction, currently an energy audit is required for remodets and additions with no requirement to upgrade the existing structure based on the audit. One recommendation is to require implementation of the energy audit findings. A feasibility threshold will be established to limit the cost of the energy audit improvements to a percentage of the project budget. For Green Building proposals related to item #4 and #5 (of Attachment C) New IBC Commercial/Residential and Commercial/Residential Remodel/Additions, staff will review the 2009 IECC, the Commercial Energy Star program, ASHRAE 189.1, Advanced Energy Design Guides and other information to formulate recommendations to the council for their consideration to modify and adopt a new above code program. The proposed program could include performance and prescriptive paths of design and renewable and sustainable components as part of the recommendations. The IBC Multi-Residential component will be transferred from the current Green Building and Green Points program to the green building program being developed for commercial construction. 'T'his would allow the green building requirements for residential units in large commercial buildings to be better suited to the needs of a commercial G site. The commercial code requirements will continue to be at least 30 percent above the 2009 IECC. The emphasis for 2009 and 2010 would be to work through the code adoption process with amendments that support the energy efficiency goals established in 2008. While energy efficiency improvements are not changed from 2008, phasing of higher energy efficiency requirements will be established for 2010 and 2011. Proposed 2010/2011 Green Building Changes: The Green Building proposal for item #1 (Attachment C) on the New IRC Residential Buildings, is to increase the energy efficiency represented by the HERS rating by at least 10 percent on BRC l U-7.5-3 Table 1. The Green Building proposal for item #2, Residential Remodels/Additions, is to include the entire structure in the HERS rating. "The Green Building proposal for item #3, Existing Residential Building (with no permit activity), is to require an energy audit and envelope remediation when an existing home is sold or the rental license is renewed. The Green Building proposal for item #4 and #5, New 1BC Commercial/Residential and IBC Commercial/Residential Remodels/Additions, will include a sustainability program that will include demolition and construction waste recycling programs. The Green Building proposal for item #6, Existing CommerciaUResidential (with no permit activity), would be to potentially require an energy audit and envelope remediation when all or some of the following occur: building sale; rental license renewal; IBC change of use; and/or zoning site plan review. It should be noted that the staff analysis for this work is not completed and that it is premature to forecast the staff recommendation. The Commercial Energy Star Program or other program could be reviewed and compliance measures proposed to council. These proposals will be further developed and presented to the council during 2009 as part of the 2009 IECC review and adoption process. An implementation date of January 2011 (one year after the January 2010 adoption date of the 2009 IECC and related city of Boulder amendments) is proposed. While not all of the answers on how to achieve the CAP goals ofcarbon-neutral constn~ction are currently known, one consideration for building codes is to increase the energy efficiency of the buildings by 50 to 60 percent and then explore implementation of renewable energy to attain carbon neutral buildings. The work in this time frame increases energy efficiency requirements as a start to the process of how to make new and existing structures contribute to attaining carbon neutrality. Proposed 2011/2012 Green Building Changes: 7 The Green Building Proposal for residential items #1, #2, #3 and #6 will include a recommendation fora 10 percent improvement in the energy efficiency requirements. Items #4 and lf5 are proposed to improve energy efficiency 50 percent or more above the baseline. ICC will publish the 2012 IF,CC during the first half of 2012. P&DS will review the document during the third quarter of 2012 to determine what course of action should be recommended to the council. for amendments and adoption in January 20 } 3. Most of the work during this time period is to develop codes that result in energy efficiency improvements in the 50 to 60 percent range. Proposed 2015/2016/2030 Greeu Building Changes: Staff will be working toward a January 2016 adoption of the 2015 IECC and necessary code updates and amendments in a continuing effort to align development requirements with meeting carbon neutral energy building goals. In addition, developing requirements for on- and off=site renewable energy generation would be incorporated in the 2016-code adoptions to attain the 2030 goal of carbon neutrality for buildings. Program Support for Commercial and Residential Code Adoption Processes: The Office of Environmental Affairs' (OEA) green building and Climate Action Plan work develops and implements programs that will continue to support evolving codes to a higher level of energy efficiency and sustainability. OEA has a successful history of developing incentives, subsidies and programs to support the Green Points program. In the last two years, program support has grown for Green Points because of the added CAP initiatives and funding. CllITCnt programs and incentives supporting energy efficient upgrades and residential green building codes consist of, but are not limited to, subsidies for construction waste material recycling infrastn.icture, free deconstruction services for building permit applicants that trigger deconstnuction mandates, subsidized energy audits, contractor and building professional technical training, workshops and conferences, insulation and high efficiency lighting rebates. As the remodel and addition component of the Green Building and Green Points Ordinance returns to council later this year, staff will be presenting options to increase requirements for these projects. Also during this timcframe, OEA is engaging in research, followed by public process to explore opportunities for energy of#iciency requirements in existing housing. OEA also plays a significant role interdepartmentally providing technical support to drive the research, evaluation and public process far emerging energy efficiency issues, technologies and practices in the market place. As the CAP work evolves from initial voluntary efforts to more aggressive initiatives, OEA, Planning and Public Works staff will work even more closely to integrate code adoption and reduction of energy and greenhouse gas emissions. 1'he city will also continue to work with other community partners such as the Governor's Energy Office, Boulder County, the Consortium of Cities and Xcel Energy on program development. These partnerships will enhance the residential and commercial sectors' ability to employ design and 8 construction energy efficiency measures, practices and renewable energy technologies. OEA wiil continue to focus on education and support in implementing Xcel's incentives and rebates for both sectors. With Boulder becoming the first SmartGrid community in the country, there will be incredible opportunities to work with residents and businesses to reduce their energy consumption. NEXT STEPS: The Aug. 12, 2008 City Council Study Session on Citywide Work Program & Priorities provides council with the opportunity to offer feedback on work plans, including this proposed schedule for the adoption of new building codes. In the interim, please contact Kirk Moors, Neil Paulsen or Maureen Rait, if additional information is needed. ATTACHMENTS: A: Short-Tenn Schedule Summary B: Minor Revisions to 2006 1BC and Adoption of the 2008 NEC C: 2008 - 2030 "Timeline J ATTACHMENT A Commercial & Residential Green Building Code Adoption Schedule Projected Date ~ Proposed Action July 24, 2008 Issue Weekly Information Packet for City Council on Commercial and Residential Green Building Code Proposals. (Include adoption of 2008 National Electric Code) Aug. 6, 2008 EAB meeting -Discuss Commercial and Residential Green Building Code Proposals. Aug.12, 2008 City Council Study Session -Citywide Work Program & Priorities Aug. 20, 2008 Public input meeting on Cornmereial Green Building proposals and 2008 National Electrical Code adoption. Aug. 13 & 27, 2008 Public input meetings on Residential Green Building proposals and 2008 National Electrical Code adoption. Sept. 3, 2008 Public input meeting on Commercial Green Building proposals and 2008 National Electrical Code adoption. Uct. 2, 2008 Present Commercial and Residential Green Building and 2008 National Electrical Code proposals to Planning Board. Oct. 21, 2008 1" Reading -Commercial and Residential Green Building and 2008 National Electrical Code proposals to City Council. Nov. 4, 2008 2"`i Reading -Commercial and Residential Green Building and 2008 National Electrical Code proposals to City Council. Jan. 5, 2009 2008 National Electrical Code, Residential and Commercial Green Building code changes become effective. June 2009 Begin the public process for adoption of 2009 model codes including: - 2009 International Building Code - 2009 International Kesideritial Code - 2009 International Plumbing code - 2009 International Mechanical Code - 2009 International Fuel Gas Code - 2009 International Existing Building Code - 2009 International Property Maintenance Code - 2009 International Energy Conservation Code with residential and commercial above code provisions with a deferred effective date. Include 10 2010 and 2011 modifications. Prepare to replace Green Building and Green Points program based on the 2009 IECC, NAHB/ICC Green Building Code and RESNI;'I'/HERS. Jan. 5, 2010 2009 model codes including the 2009 IECC with the "above code" modifications become effective. Il ATTACHMENT B Minor Revisions to 2006 International Building Code Adoption of the 2008 National Electrical Code It is proposed that the city of Boulder adopt minor changes to the previously adopted International Code Council (ICC), 2006 International Building Code (IBC) and adopt by reference the 2008 National Electrical Code (NEC) with modifieativns. The periodic adoption of new construction codes is a standard practice of the city of Boulder and other local agencies. The cvde changes and code proposed for adoption by reference is available for public use at the Planning & Development Services Center, located on the 3rd flovr of the Park Central Building at 1739 Broadway and at the Office of the City Clerk/Central Records. Local amendments, while being kept to a minimum, are proposed to address local issues related to the code. A summary of key Local amendments and changes from the codes is provided below. 2006 International Buildin Cvde IBC) Amendments IBC Section 105.32, "`l'ime Limitation of Application", the current modified code language is repealed and replaced with the original ICC text which allows the building official more flexibility in allowing extensions of plan reviews when necessary. IBC Section 105.5 "Expiration", the current modified code language is repealed and replaced with the original text with the addition of the following code language at the end of the paragraph: "Every permit issued by the building official under the provisions of this code shall expire by limitation and become null and void if the building or work authorized by such permit is not completed and approved for occupancy within three years from the date the permit was issued. T7re permit fee for renewals may be prorated based on the amount of work completed and approved under the previous permit." 2008 National Electrical Code The 2008 edition of the National Electrical Code (NEC) of the National Fire protection Association is adopted by reference as the city of Boulder Electrical Code or electrical code and has the same force and effect as though fully set forth in this chapter, except as specifically amended by the provisions of this chapter. The current modified code language in items (I), (m) and (p) is repealed and replaced with the 2008 NE;C code text. All three references were allowances for the use of NM cable (romex) in residential occupancies that need to be modified to meet minimum state of Colorado Electrical Board requirements. 12 ~~_i i n_ _ ~I srd F,=sltlen•nl Gr.=n -:.r hd rg ::._c Adu(•fior `~e9eri.le 3C, 2V0g r . . 1. New IRC Rosidentlal Bulldings Duple.., n•rcr~e, Sr R~, IEF. ieti -;:3-_n r..-: ACOpt d0a IE:: maintain HERS'a:rg 1C.~r: Inp•o.crr-r: i•i a-er~~ 70% ir~nrrve•rert an:,~~1 20151-C:C Net zero goal etfiuency energy efficren.-y aC-~%u"~ aoo.e IECC Replace mo Green Budding G•e~r, Ports ~rcy•.:~r, Adopt 20t21ECC Fsre~o:able ere~gy based on regr.i•rn~.enls cede:cp^u:^' (ette:,hca 2?G8) •2CC91ECC ,c ar. ;and aco-.^,ern al - "J 41 •.3iICC Gree? BcilCin^, Ccde J -RESNETMERS 21RC ResldenUat RamotlMslAddrucns HERS raunglGreon Fart, Secord read,ng ct on:ioance k>5 %i: i,oopt 2l7\?9 IECC HERS rase :cral ,tr_etnre ` J9I: ,r;~rc.ve-nent n Adopt 7C' S IECC Carbon Neut,•al (trigger ^•,resnolC fcr applying ner,' energy ettruency 20461ECC ccmpliance ConsVUttion standartls to remcarls a^c Eoveb:;e reT~ecia: on pa~ a..n . 1C% Ir. ~~p~over*.er; i^ ener~~ Adopt 20121ECC Renevreb c eno•av a::e.!bnsi CaLrNOV : B effiaercy requirements cove cp'TiCri (etlecliva 21C8, Rapla:z the Green Building Greer ~'ei n7s Fregra r^ iSola•, rand gee-:•-err•a. baseC on :0051ECC - FJA-~1.' . ,3ro~:r 4r,f!!ing Cede -RESNET/s7ER5 3, Exlsting IRC Resldentlal Bulldings .v1'.tn r , aem-1; pct vity,'' Envelope -er~e;l:atlo-~ peg audit 10°ro Pr~Pravement in ACOpt 2C i51ECC Cart rn Nel.tral energy orciciency -SFR - pant of sale Adopt 20f 21ECC -Rectal pcense rena•Ha! 4. New IBC CommerctaU Resldentlal 26CG IECC 3C'% bezr tha^~ ZC^.5 IECC' Adop: 20c9 IcCC - Trai~tain 30"< abova coCe Sustamabrldy Program 50°b above cotla Aaopt 1.015 IECC Carbat leutral fCommercral) (CommerUatj (et(ectr:e HOyj Modebna ~~~In^gs cve~ 2JX sgba-e `u~l Revow Eoolde: ^eu~;y cc^1metc~a! cunscrBUm .r; .~.drpt 2D12 IE(', Ryreweole e•rergy ICornmerC~aly proposal far poss.b.e 2GC9 adoph:cn. requrramenls development Cu+rtov Co Renewable components iSotar .v;-, air.-the•°rnl, Sustainable :.omponents ' S. New 18C CommerclaU Resldentlal Rer ~•~~?L!A7ririo-. 2CC6 IECC 2C;; r tFa aJ61t~:.. :,rn .-:rr.ia', Adopt 2009 trC:; -rr.ain;ain 30"~n abova sane Susta~nab hq~ Pra(~em 59'%~ acova cotle Adopt ACC Carbon Neutral fCommeraal) :affechue tlOBj Cct:7•:ov C8 Re:~ cv: f3o_tder Criurty commercial conscniw'r hdopt 2C121ECC Renewable energy proposa! `or Possible 200°. atloplion. regwrements davelopmenl Energy Star rabng (Solar. ~.vrrc, sec-the-rtal': Rera•.vable components Sustainable components 6. Existing IBC CommerctaU Residential "~'a~" "'=1iv''~+ Adopt2"vC9lnlernahcnal?rcpertyl~ta^.te°a~rce Er -I .13tio~~? a_c: 36;oabovecode Adopt?,,^.'SECC CarbonNevtral ACapl 2569 1rla•nao.onal last ng (3,i 19 rg Cc%e -Point of sale ACOpt 2:%12 1=C~C -Rernal license renewal •Change of use Sac Plan review