Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout06.24.24 PRAB Packet - UPDATEDAGENDA All agenda times are approximate I.APPROVAL OF AGENDA (2 minutes) II.FUTURE BOARD ITEMS AND TOURS (2 minutes) III.PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (15-30 minutes) A.This portion of the meeting is for members of the public to communicate ideas or concerns to the Board regarding parks and recreation issues for which a public hearing is not scheduled later in the meeting (this includes consent agenda). The public is encouraged to comment on the need for parks and recreation programs and facilities as they perceive them. All speakers are limited to three minutes. Depending on the nature of your matter, you may or may not receive a response from the Board after you deliver your comments. The Board is always listening to and appreciative of community feedback. IV.CONSENT AGENDA (5 minutes) A.Approval of Minutes from May 20, 2024 B.Updates from the Director of Parks and Recreation C.Parks and Recreation Operations Updates D.Parks and Recreation Planning, Design and Construction Updates V.ACTION ITEMS A.Public Hearing and Consideration of a Motion to Name the Neighborhood Park on Violet Avenue ‘Primos Park’ (15 min) VI.MATTERS FOR DISCUSSION/INFORMATION A.2025 Budget Strategy, Fee Policy & CIP Workplan (60 min) VII.MATTERS FROM THE DEPARTMENT A.Violet Park Draft Concept Plan (30 min) B.Court System Plan: Final Plan (45 min) C.2022 BPR Plan Implementation Update (verbal presentation) VIII.MATTERS FROM THE BOARD A.Final Review: Board Liaison’s to BPR Projects B.PRAB Matters (verbal) IX.NEXT BOARD MEETING: A.July 22, 2024, fully hybrid X.ADJOURN Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Fully Hybrid Meeting 6:00 p.m., June 24, 2024 Boulder Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Members 2023 Andrew Bernstein Elliott Hood Waylon Lewis Eric Raffini Jennifer Robins Anna Segur Sarah van der Star Mission Statement BPRD will promote the health and well- being of the entire Boulder community by collaboratively providing high-quality parks, facilities and programs. Vision Statement We envision a community where every member’s health and well- being is founded on unparalleled parks, facilities and programs. Goals of the Master Plan 1.Community Health and Wellness 2.Taking Care of What We Have 3.Financial Sustainability 4.Building Community 5.Youth Engagement 6.Organizational Readiness 1 1 PRAB Future Board Items Agenda June 24 July 22 August 26 Fully hybrid for members, staff, and community. Fully hybrid for members, staff, and community. CIP Field Trip Regular Mtg (c) •BPR Service Areas •Community Wildfire Protection Plan •Bill Bower Park – Interpretive Garden Donation •Community Forestry Corps Update •Crestview close out Regular Mtg (a) •Public Hearing and Consideration of a Motion to Name the Neighborhood Park on Violet Avenue ‘Primos Park’ (15 min) •Approve: 2025 PPRF Expenditures and CIP, Recommend Operating Budget (15 min) •Wonderland Lake Encroachment Remedies (15 min) Regular Mtg (d/i) •2025 Budget Strategy, Fee Policy & CIP Workplan (60 min) •Wonderland Lake Encroachment Remedies (20 min) Regular Mtg (md) •Tennis and Pickleball Court System Plan: BPR’s role in indoor courts (45 min) •Park on Violet: Concept Plan Update (30 min) •2022 BPR Plan implementation update (10 minutes) •Civic Area: Planning Analysis and Park Perceptions Summary (30 min) •Reservoir ANS/EWM Management Plan Update (15 min •Aug 26 Field Trip reminder •The Future of Recreation Centers: Project Kick-off •CIP Annual Field Trip Regular Mtg (mb) •Final review: Board Liaison’s to BPR Projects •Fall Study Session date planning •PRAB Process check-in with new board members •Aug 26 Field Trip reminder Other Mtgs or Topics •June 26: Flatirons Liquor License hearing Dept Events & Items of Interest •June 1 & 2: Arts in the Park – Boulder Ballet •July 4: Arts in the Park – Boulder Symphony •August 3: Arts in the Park – Boulder Opera •August 10-18: NBRC Shut Down •August 24: Arts in the Park – Boulder Philharmonic AGENDA SETTING The PRAB Chair, PRAB Vice Chair and BPR staff set the agenda for the next month on Thursday directly following the regular PRAB meeting. PRAB members can submit agenda requests to the Chair and Vice Chair by Wednesday following the PRAB regular meeting for consideration. If time-sensitive matters arise, PRAB Chair and Vice Chair may amend the agenda as needed. LEGEND Action Item (a): A public hearing item to be voted on by the Board (public comment period provided). Procedural Item: (p): An item requiring procedural attention. Consent Item (c): An item provided in written form for consent, not discussion by the Board; any consent item may be called up by any Board member for discussion following the consent agenda. Discussion/Information Item(d/i): An item likely to be a future action item (or council item) and/or that benefits from an in-depth discussion. Matters from the Department (md): Items that will be reviewed and discussed during the meeting but not requiring as much in-depth analysis. Matters from the Board (mb): Items initiated by the Board that will be reviewed and discussed during the meeting but not requiring as much in-depth analysis. City Council Item (cc) Other Boards and Commissions (obc) Community Engagement and/or Events (e) Holiday/Closure (h/c) Italics indicate a tentative date or plan. 2 2 TO: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board FROM: Alison Rhodes, Director of Parks and Recreation Bryan Beary, Senior Manager, Community Building and Partnerships Mark Davison, Senior Manager, Planning Denise Dawson, Senior Manager, Urban Parks Regina Elsner, Senior Manager, Natural Resources Jackson Hite, Senior Manager, Business Services Megann Lohman, Senior Manager, Recreation Stephanie Munro, Senior Manager, Regional Facilities Scott Schuttenberg, Deputy Director SUBJECT: Consent Agenda DATE: June 24, 2024 A.Approval of Minutes May 20, 2024 3 3 CITY OF BOULDER BOULDER, COLORADO BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS MEETING MINUTES To listen to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meetings in their entirety, please go to the following link: www.boulderparks-rec.org Name of Board/Commission: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Date of Meeting: May 20, 2024 Contact Information Preparing Summary: Rosa Kougl; 303-413-7223 Board Members Present: Elliott Hood, Waylon Lewis, Jennifer Robins, Anna Segur, Sarah van der Star Board Members Absent: Andrew Bernstein, Eric Raffini Staff Present: Ali Rhodes, Scott Schuttenberg, Rosa Kougl, Bryan Beary, Stephanie Munro, Regina Elsner, Jonathan Thornton, Jackson Hite, Stacie Hoffmann, Deryn Wagner, Charlotte O’Donnell, Mark Davison Guests Present: Type of Meeting: Regular Agenda Item 1: Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 6:01 p.m. A quorum was present for the conduct of business. Motion to approve agenda. First motion by van der Star, second by Robins. The motion passed 5-0. Agenda Item 2: Future Board Items: Rhodes, Director of Parks and Recreation, reviewed upcoming agenda items and events. No PRAB follow up questions or comments. Agenda Item 3: Public participation: •Community Connectors instrumental in the engagement and naming process of the city's new park offered personal insight as to why Primos Park was chosen for the name. o Community Connector Sarah Malin o Community Connector Bernardo Padilla o Community Connector Paras Lamsal Agenda Item 4: Consent Agenda A.Approval of Minutes from April 22, 2024, Business Meeting Motion to approve the minutes from the April 22, 2024, Regular PRAB meeting. First motion by Robins, second by Segur. The motion passed 5-0. B, C, D. Updates from the Director, Project Updates, Operations & Development PRAB had the following questions/comments: •What is the process of identifying and approving supplemental appropriations? •How is the new drop-in schedule being marketed to the community’s teens? •What percent of BPR Rangers are bilingual? •Questions about drowning prevention program participation and learnings. Agenda Item 5: Items for Action •No items 4 4 Agenda Item 6: Matters for Discussion • Recommendation to name the park on Violet Avenue “Primos Park” Wagner and O’Donnell presented this item. PRAB had the following questions/comments: • Is there a connection plan to the library? • How can Boulder Meadows neighbors connect to the new park? • What is the history of the parkland? • How will the name be explained on-site? • Does Council also have to approve or does final authority on park naming live with PRAB? Agenda Item 7: Matters from the Department A. 2024 City-wide Planning Rhodes presented this item. PRAB had the following questions/comments: • Questions about process for receiving donations. B. Financial Strategy Update Hite, Hoffmann, and Davison presented this item. PRAB had the following questions/comments: • Comments about BPR’s marketing strategy? • Are there alternate funding or nontraditional funding sources to tap into? • What is the 3-to-5-year ballot measure strategy? Agenda Item 8: Matters from the Board Members A. PRAB Onboarding PRAB had the following questions or comment: • Board Liaison’s to BPR Projects: Will revisit adding liaisons at June meeting when the rest of the members are present. • Protocol for Community Response. Specific members will not be assigned to particular topics. Members may respond on an individual basis. B. PRAB Matters • PRAB follow up questions or comments. • Disappointment that city council did not elevate the PRAB’s Universal Swim Initiative as one of PRAB’s focus areas for the coming year. • Request for a survey or an aquatic proficiency map to show community need around swim knowledge. Agenda Item 9: Next Board Meeting Next Board meeting: Monday, June 24, 2024, Hybrid Agenda Item 10: Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 8:51 p.m. Approved by: Attested: ___________________ _____________________ Elliott Hood Rosa Kougl Board Member BPR Staff Date: ______________ Date: _________________ 5 5 B. Updates from the Director of Parks and Recreation BPR Service Areas To support board understanding of BPR’s structure and functions, the below chart outlines the seven service areas and key responsibilities for each. Each service area is led by a Senior Manager who reports to the Director’s Office. •Budget Stewardship •Human Resources •Systems Admin •Process Improvement Business Services: Jackson Hite •Capital Improvement Program • Long-term Planning and Park Design •Asset Management and GIS •Construction Planning, Design and Construction: Mark Davison •Park Maintenance •Irrigation •Horticulture •Asset Management Urban Parks: Denise Dawson •Forestry •Natural Lands •Urban Park Rangers Natural Resources: Regina Elsner •Boulder Reservoir •Flatirons Golf Course •Valmont City Park Regional Facilities: Stephanie Munro •EXPAND and Camps •YSI •Events •Volunteers and Partnerships Community Services: Bryan Beary •Recreation Centers •Aquatics •Health & Wellness •Gymnastics Recreation: Megann Lohman 6 6 Digital Accessibility Digital accessibility is a 2024 citywide workplan priority and includes making sure that information available on the City of Boulder’s website and other digital services are accessible to all. The city’s goal is to deliver a web experience that achieves “Level A” and “Level AA” conformance according to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines v2.2 (WCAG 2.2). Boulder Parks and Recreation is working to improve the readability of its content. All BPR employees have completed training in understanding Digital Accessibility and are working to improve online content. This includes transitioning away from linking to PDFs, which do not have interactivity or functionality like websites that allow for the use of screen readers and other assistive technology. It also includes increasing the use of plain language, how pages are written, and fonts used. Historically, the PRAB packet has been developed using a Times New Roman font. This font makes for difficult reading. The Center for People With Disabilities recommends that characters should be sans-serif, not italic, oblique, script, highly decorative, or unusually shaped. A sans serif font is easier and faster to read than one without serifs. For readers with low vision, the serifs significantly degrade legibility. The importance of using a sans serif typeface is especially important for digital content since it is typically read on-screen and not in hardcopy print. Sans Serif is most important for body text and fluid reading. Starting with the June packet, all PRAB materials will be published using the Arial font. Annual Field Trip The annual field trip is scheduled for August 26 and will begin from the Municipal Penfield Tate Building. The intent of the tour is to build board awareness and understanding of upcoming major capital projects. At each site, the team will provide a brief project overview and allow time for questions and discussion. We will begin at the future site of Primos Park (Violet Park). We will then travel to the Boulder Junction and Mapleton site to tour the development site of Boulder’s vision of a lively, mixed-use, pedestrian-oriented location. We will finish at East Boulder Community Center where Project Manager Deryn Wegner will provide an update on the Future of Recreation Centers. This tour is a special meeting to facilitate the updates and there is no public comment or participation; however, members of the community are welcome to join the tour. C. Parks and Recreation Operations Updates Community Wildfire Protection Plan On May 23, 2024, City Council held a study session on the update to the city’s Community Wildfire Protection Plan (CWPP). This is a city staff-initiated, consultant- supported, community-centered, cross-departmental planning effort to enhance the city’s holistic and strategic approach to wildfire risk mitigation. Funded by Boulder’s Climate Tax passed by voters in November 2022, the CWPP update serves as a guiding document that will assist the city and community members in making informed decisions with respect to wildfire preparation and management. Implementing the recommendations in the plan is a priority action supporting strategy #2 of the Citywide 7 7 Strategic Plan to: Advance efforts to enhance regional disaster prevention, preparedness, and response that leverage existing partnerships and prioritize city investments. The purpose of the 2024 CWPP update is to: • facilitate a cohesive wildfire risk assessment to identify preparedness and risk reduction actions at a citywide scale; • provide a framework for future planning and implementation of necessary mitigation measures; • provide information to inform future land-use planning, building codes, and wildfire mitigation and prevention-related ordinances; • enable local communities, civic groups, businesses, and governments to improve their wildfire-mitigation capabilities and capacity, while working with fire protection agencies to identify high fire risk areas and prioritize regions for structure hardening, mitigation, fire suppression, and emergency preparedness projects; • enhance public awareness by helping residents, visitors, and homeowners better understand and mitigate the natural and human-caused risks of wildland fires that threaten lives, safety, and the local economy; • define the Wildland Urban Interface (WUI) and conduct a risk assessment that encompasses fuel hazards, fire history, structure vulnerability, and protective community values; and • to meet the minimum standards of the Healthy Forests Restoration Act of 2003 and Colorado State Forest Service (CSFS) by being developed collaboratively between local, state, and federal agencies, as well as other interested parties; including priority areas for hazardous fuel reduction treatments; and recommending measures that homeowners and communities can take to reduce structural ignitability. The CWPP is not a regulatory document. It is a risk assessment with accompanying recommendations (predominately operational in nature) to mitigate those risks. The CWPP contains nearly 40 operational recommendations. City staff estimates about 60% are already in motion and will be enhanced based on this plan update. Ongoing work that aligns with the recommendations include: • implementing the ecological and wildfire mitigation strategies of past planning efforts (Current CWPP, Open Space and Mountain Parks Master Plan, Fire Master Plan, etc.); • developing and implement hazardous fuels reduction in strategic locations targeting timber and shrub fuel models at the landscape level; • developing and implementing a wildfire resilience public education program; • establishing a defensible space grant program to incentivize homeowner mitigation actions; • conducting detailed home assessments to advise on methods to reduce structural ignitability; 8 8 • working with HOAs and neighborhoods to facilitate educational events and home assessments to improve wildfire preparedness and resilience building efforts; • supporting research efforts regarding urban conflagration risk modeling and mitigation; • enhancing emergency response and coordination during wildfire events through the integration of dispatch centers; and • continuing to update and implement the structure protection plan. At the May Study Session, council members generally expressed appreciation and support for the plan. Several council members expressed understanding and appreciation for the level of detail the plan contained. A recording of the council study session can be accessed here starting at approximately 1:43:00. A written summary of the study session is included in council’s packet for the June 20, 2024, meeting. BPR has been involved throughout the process to update the CWPP and has taken advantage of the opportunity to build stronger relationships with colleagues in other departments, including but not limited to Open Space and Mountain Parks (OSMP), Utilities, and Boulder Fire-Rescue. Since work began on the CWPP, BPR has engaged in several projects to address and mitigate wildfire risk in the community. In the fall of 2023, BPR collaborated with Climate Initiatives, Boulder Fire-Rescue, Mile High Youth Corps, and the Boulder Watershed Collective on the pilot removal of juniper bushes on city parkland directly adjacent to private property at Wonderland Lake Park. This spring, Park Operations staff are working to replant the area with water-wise and fire resilient plants to demonstrate a successful juniper removal and restoration. Similarly, BPR has collaborated with OSMP on a pilot mowing program to address grassland fuels in the WUI on public lands. Future efforts with BPR could include supporting actions identified from home hazard assessments that impact public lands and working with partners (such as OSMP, BFRD, Utilities) to address wildland fuel mitigation in high-risk areas of the community as identified within the CWPP. Wonderland Lake Park before juniper removal Wonderland Lake Park after juniper removal 9 9 Community Forestry Corps The Community Forestry Corps (CFC) is a new program launched this year to engage youth to participate in nature-based climate action. PLAY Boulder is leading this effort to employ young people to maintain trees and collect data on heat impacts and climate change. The CFC is supported by the City of Boulder Climate Initiatives and Forestry, Boulder County and other local and national organizations. The CFC is currently working to care for 100+ trees recently planted in Aurora 7 Park, Valmont City Park, Boulder Community School, and Harlow Platts Community Park. They recently helped imbed over 3 tons of CO2 equivalent carbon through a biochar injection at Pineview Park. The biochar injection is a pilot to determine the impacts on water usage after injection in turf grass. The CFC will be working over the summer to collect heat data throughout the city to inform forestry and extreme heat management efforts. 4th of July Holiday Events BPR has several activities on tap for the 4th of July holiday in Boulder. In the evening at the Glen Huntington Bandshell, the Boulder Symphony will play symphonic classics celebrating music across the Americas, featuring cinematic classics and patriotic tunes. This event is part of the Arts in the Park performing arts series. The Boulder Reservoir will be open 6 a.m. to 4 p.m. Popular recreation activities at the Reservoir include boating, swimming, sun bathing, water skiing, fishing, picnicking, walking, running, cycling and wildlife viewing. The East Boulder Community Center will be open until 1:30 p.m. Scott Carpenter Pool, Spruce Pool and the Flatirons Golf Course will be open normal hours. The city’s parks will be open normal hours 5 a.m. to 11 p.m. Please follow the city’s parks rules and regulations. Biochar application at Pineview Park CFC participant gathering heat data 10 10 D. Parks and Recreation Planning, Design and Construction Updates The following information is intended to provide the PRAB with relevant updates on specific projects as they reach major milestones. This section is not all inclusive of all current projects and only illustrates major project updates. For a complete list of all current projects and details, please visit www.BoulderParkNews.org. Overview of Major Projects Staff continue to work on the following projects and will update the PRAB as major milestones are achieved: Project Status Child-friendly City Initiative / Youth Action Plan Planning Civic Area – Phase 2 Planning Court System Plan Final Future of Recreation Centers Scoping North Boulder Park Design Flatirons Golf Course Facility Construction Pleasantview Access Design Park on Violet Design Boulder Creek Safety Plan Design East Boulder Community Park Court Enhancement Anticipated Start 2024 Q3 Pearl Street Place Making Anticipated Start 2025 Boulder Creek Management Plan Anticipated Start 2025 Bill Bower Park – Interpretive Garden Donation The staff has been working with the Military Officers Association of America, Boulder Chapter (MOAA) to bring their proposal for an interpretive garden to life. MOAA would like to donate funds, materials, and labor to create an inviting space for all to recognize Bill Bower. DIG Studio has been chosen as the consultant to support the project through construction. While finalizing the agreements with the donor as recommended in the External Funding Strategy, staff will develop a community engagement process to ensure the community is aware and supportive of this project. Once all agreements are in place, staff will facilitate community engagement in partnership with MOAA and DIG concurrent with the department’s standard design development process. The design development phase can begin as soon as a donor agreement between the City and MOAA is complete. Staff will share an updated timeline upon completion of the donor agreement. 11 11 AGENDA ITEM #___V-A___PAGE___1____ C I T Y O F B O U L D E R PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: June 24, 2024 AGENDA TITLE: Public Hearing and Consideration of a Motion to Name the Neighborhood Park on Violet Avenue ‘Primos Park’. PRESENTERS: Alison Rhodes, Director, Parks and Recreation Department Mark Davison, Planning Manager, Parks and Recreation Department Deryn Wagner, Senior Landscape Architect, Parks and Recreation Department Charlotte O’Donnell, City Planner, Parks and Recreation Department EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This item supports formal action by the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (PRAB) regarding the North Boulder community’s recommendation to name the park on Violet Avenue ‘Primos Park’. According to city policy, the PRAB has final authority in this naming process because it does not involve naming the park after a particular individual or donor. BACKGROUND: According to the city’s 2007 Park and Plaza Naming and Dedication Policy, the PRAB has authority over park naming, following a thorough public process. In naming Primos Park, staff and Community Connectors carried out a robust public process in collaboration with middle- and high-school youth living in Boulder Meadows who are part of BPR’s Youth Services Initiative (YSI) Get Fit Program. These young people brainstormed park names, interviewed older family members for additional ideas, and presented the top recommendations to their neighbors at a community gathering in March 2024. At the March gathering, Primos Park emerged as the neighbors’ preferred name. In accordance with the naming policy, staff mailed a postcard to every residence within roughly a half mile of the park, notifying them of the proposed name. This included all homes within the Boulder Meadows and Ponderosa manufactured home communities, as well as homes and businesses in the adjacent areas. An email notification also went out to the project email list. Staff did not receive any further feedback on the proposed name following these notifications. PRAB discussed the recommended name during the May meeting (starting on page 13). ANALYSIS: The name Primos Park gathered the most excitement and relevance to the community throughout this engagement process and emerged as the recommended name for the site for the following primary reasons. • Valuing family and community: Primos means ‘cousins’ in Spanish and reflects neighbors’ hopes of gathering with family and friends in the future park. YSI youth 12 12 AGENDA ITEM #___V-A___PAGE___2____ participants shared many stories of how living in a tight-knit community and near many extended family members shapes their lives, especially the joy of getting to play with their cousins and close friends who are like family. One YSI participant wrote, “my favorite name for the new park is Primos Park because everyone is family there.” • Celebrating diversity and belonging through Spanglish: Many neighbors of the park speak Spanish, English, and other languages. The combination of the Spanish word ‘Primos’ and the English word ‘Park’ resonated with youth and community members’ multi-lingual experiences. One community member shared, “"I love that the name is in Spanglish. To me this is unifying my culture and my kids' culture, I get to explain to them why Primos Park is such a big step towards a better future, and they get to be a part of it." At the May meeting, PRAB shared positive feedback for the name Primos Park and the engagement process thus far. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that PRAB approve the name Primos Park. Suggested Motion Language: Staff requests the PRAB’s consideration of this matter and action in the form of the following motion: Motion to Name the Neighborhood Park on Violet Avenue ‘Primos Park’. NEXT STEPS: The city will host a community event in the next several months to celebrate the new park name and all those who contributed to this name and the park process thus far. Staff are co-designing this celebration with community connectors and neighborhood youth in the Youth Services Initiative and will share details with the board as they’re confirmed. 13 13 C I T Y O F B O U L D E R PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: June 24, 2025 AGENDA TITLE: 2025 Budget Strategy, Fee Policy & CIP Workplan PRESENTERS: Alison Rhodes, Director of Parks and Recreation Scott Schuttenberg, Deputy Director Jackson Hite, Senior Manager, Business Services Stacie Hoffmann, Senior Budget Analyst Bryan Beary, Senior Manager, Community Building and Partnerships Mark Davison, Senior Manager, Planning Denise Dawson, Senior Manager, Urban Parks Regina Elsner, Senior Manager, Natural Resources Megann Lohman, Senior Manager, Recreation Stephanie Munro, Senior Manager, Regional Facilities EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This item continues the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (PRAB) discussion related to the Parks and Recreation Department (the department) 2025 Budget Strategy including the operating and capital budget. At the July PRAB meeting, the PRAB will be asked to 1) approve the 2025 recommended operating budget; 2) approve the recommended capital expenditures from the Permanent Park and Recreation Fund to City Council for appropriation; 3) recommend the 2025-2030 Parks and Recreation Department Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) to Planning Board and City Council for approval and appropriation. The intent of this item is to provide background and analysis to support th e July actions. BACKGROUND: At the March 18, April 22, and May 20 PRAB meetings, staff have provided updates on the 2025 Budget Strategy. The 2025 budget development was guided by the themes, goals and initiatives outlined in the 2022 BPR Plan as the guiding document. The entire budget development process aligned with the citywide budget process that incorporates feedback from the City’s Finance Department, City Manager’s Office, the department staff, and the PRAB. The PRAB has continually heard of the fiscally constrained budget based on flattening sales and use tax along with expected legislative changes to property tax revenue. As a result, the department has prepared a fiscally constrained budget that aligns with the reality of slower revenue growth, while maintaining current levels of service. Recognizing the fiscally constrained environment, the proposed budget has accomplished the following: 14 14 1) Realigned existing budget dollars to maintain service levels, largely from areas that have not fully spent the previously budgeted funding. Recognizing significant investments performed in recent years, realignment of dollars serve as the key opportunity for change. 2) Identified base cost increases for existing city contracts and services due to inflation 2025 Budget Proposal: The internal budget development process will continue through August, as the City’s Finance Department and Executive Budget Team will review all department’s budget submissions in the context of the city’s overall budget. The City Manager’s final budget will be shared for City Council review at the end of August. As a result, the PRAB will see two scenarios of the proposed 2025 budget. Scenario 1, summarized in Table 1, maintains all 2024 service levels by realigning dollars and funding cost increases associated with existing contracts and services . Under Scenario 1, there are 4 fixed term positions anticipated to expire at the end of 2024 that would not be renewed. Scenario 1: Budget by Fund and Category Fund 2024 Approved Budget 2025 Budget Proposal Total $ Change Total % Change General Fund $ 6.4m 6.3m (0.1)m -2% .25 Cent ST 14.5m 13.1m (1.4)m -10% Recreation Activity Fund 14.7m 14.8m 0.1m 1% Perm Parks 5.0m 3.0m (2.0)m -40% Lottery 1.6m 1.4m (0.1)m -7% Capital Other 2.5m 2.5m 0m 0% Total $ 44.7m 41.1m (3.6)m -8% CCRS 4.5m 2.2m (2.4)m -52% Total $ 49.2m 43.3m (5.9)m -12% Table 1: 2025 Scenario 1 Proposed Spending by Fund and Category Scenario 2, outlined in Table 2 is the department’s recommended option. It includes everything in Scenario 1 and proposes the following: • Convert to ongoing 6 positions, which includes the conversion of 4 fixed term positions into ongoing positions, and converts 3 temporary 9 -month positions into 2 regular, year-round positions. These positions include those that make up the Urban Ranger Program along with a Sr. Landscape Architect. • To address anticipated minimum wage and compression that is expected in 2025 through either state adjustments to minimum wage, or a regional minimum wage in Boulder County. 15 15 • Maintain current level of service through minor increases to the operating budget, primarily tied to recreation programs . • Decrease anticipated CIP spend to align with current staff capacity and financial resources, while maintaining the most funding for Asset Management program. Currently funded Community, Culture, Resilience and Safety projects at Civic Area Phase II, Pearl Street Mall, and East Boulder Community Center would remain as priority projects due to this one-time funding. Scenario 2: Budget by Fund and Category Fund 2024 Approved Budget 2025 Budget Proposal Total $ Change Total % Change General Fund $ 6.4m 6.5m 0.1m 1% .25 Cent ST 14.5m 12.9m (1.5)m -11% Recreation Activity Fund 14.7m 15.1m 0.3m 2% Perm Parks 5.0m 3.3m (1.7)m -33% Lottery 1.6m 1.4m (0.1)m -7% Capital Other 2.5m 2.5m 0m 0% Total $ 44.7m 41.8m (2.9)m -7% CCRS 4.5m 2.2m (2.4)m -52% Total $ 49.2m 43.9m (5.3)m -11% Table 2: 2025 Scenario 2 Proposed Spending by Fund and Category Under both scenarios, the department has aligned the budget proposals with the city’s Budgeting for Resilience and Equity. The city is currently in the third and final year of implementing Budgeting for Resilience and Equity , a budgeting process that places a greater focus on desired outcomes of investments, increases transparency to the community and is centered on racial equity and other citywide goals articulated in the Sustainability, Equity, and Resilience (SER) Framework objectives. The SER framework includes objectives necessary for Boulder’s vision of a great community, organized around seven goal areas: Safe, Healthy and Socially Thriving, Livable, Accessible and Connected, Environmentally Sustainable, Economically Vital, and Responsibly Governed. The following are included in the department’s 2025 proposal: • To demonstrate connections to broad city goals, all programs and capital projects are linked to specific SER objectives. • To demonstrate connections to SER objectives, outcomes (short, medium, and long-term) are documented for all budget programs and projects. • To demonstrate effectiveness and changes over time, m easurements, data sources, and preliminary key performance indicators (KPIs) are identified. • To demonstrate alignment with Citywide Strategic Plan, each budget program area aligns with strategies identified in the Citywide Strategic Plan. 16 16 With the 2025 Budget adoption, the implementation of the Budgeting for Resilience and Equity will be complete, with 2026 Budget years beginning to track budget results. There will be annual performance tracking associated with each budget program area to compare to expected targets and actual performance. Fee Schedule: With the PRAB’s adoption of the Fee Policy, the city has set cost recovery targets by revenue type and will be updating fees in 2025.The anticipated areas of fee adjustments will be tied to Facility Entry, Golf Course, Commercial Use and Special Events. These fee increases have been factored into the proposed revenue targets. The proposed 2025 Fee Schedule will return to the PRAB later this year for review and approval. The BPR fees are not codified (meaning they do not require City Council approval and code change to be effective); however, they will go through a public noticing period prior to taking effect, with a planned implementation on January 1, 2025. There will be advanced communication to individuals and user groups regarding any planned fee increases. As BPR continues to implement the 2022 Plan and without additional funding, the community can expect to see fees continuing to increase as the cost of services rises. The Fee Policy will be used to identify where and when fee increases need to occur. Long-Term Financial Strategy & Outlook: The department has balanced the budget in 2025 and 2026 in the three dedicated BPR funds (.25 Cent Sales Tax Fund, Permanent Park and Recreation Fund, and Recreation Activity Fund). Fund Financials relying on Scenario 2 are included as Attachment A for all three dedicated funds. Due to the increasing costs and slowing revenue, the department expects to be unable to balance all three funds by 202 7 through 2030 and is not the only city department facing this dilemma. Much of the imbalance between revenues and expenses can be attributed to the cost escalation experienced over the past 5 years for labor, materials, and capital projects; this growth has exceeded the pace of revenue growth . In the short term, BPR is relying on fund balan ce (savings) to fund the difference between revenues and expenses. As outlined in May, City Council has prioritized the Long-Term Financial Strategy on their workplan. This effort will be led by the City Manager’s Office and Finance Department as it impacts multiple city departments and include several elements, including but not limited to: a comprehensive fee study, an evaluation of service levels, an exploration of additional funding mechanisms, refinement of financial policies, community engagement, and a 3 -5 year ballot strategy. Without additional funding and by 2027, BPR will need to identify what services, facilities and programs to decrease or eliminate to balance spending with funding. Aligned with the Long-Term Financial Strategy, the department will begin exploring options following the summer 2024 season to begin aligning revenues and expenses. In addition, the implementation of a new Recreation Management Software (RMS) in the fall of 2025 will provide better data on cost allocation and cost recovery to support this work. Capital Investment Program (CIP) Workplan: 2025 through 2030 Background Annual CIP work planning is one of the most meaningful efforts the department undertakes every year. BPR’s investments are guided by four main inputs: • The 2022 BPR Plan, • The city’s Sustainability, Equity, and Resilience Framework 17 17 • Priorities emerging from the asset management program, and • Existing park and system plans Every year, BPR focuses on a two-year CIP and updates the six-year program. The four inputs provide invaluable guidance in helping to identify and prioritize the projects, plans, and services BPR delivers with an eye to the next six-year’s and a focus on a two-year detailed workplan. The three main category types that organize the framework for the BPR CIP are: • Asset Management - appropriate annual investment to take care of what we have • Parks and Recreation Facilities - a six-year outlook for design, development and renovation of specific parks or facilities • System Planning – identifying and evaluating future projects and providing policy guidance for parks and facilities This comprehensive approach to BPR’s CIP workplan is founded on prioritizing and implementing the key themes of community-informed 2022 BPR Plan described in the graphic below. 18 18 All six themes provide guidance to the CIP. Of critical importance to maintaining our assets is Taking Care of What We Have. Staff look to the themes of Community Health and Wellness, and Youth Engagement & Activity in order to ensure the department is providing the best facilities, amenities, and infrastructure to retain or expand upon our service levels. In addition, staff will consider the most efficient, sustainable, and robust approach to managing assets across the system and implement the policy as it applies in the Financial Sustainability and Organizational Readiness themes. As staff look to improve levels of service, BPR will continue in our approach to Building Community & Relationships, especially as staff work with recreation groups to consider ways to fund and manage facilities that can help achieve our ‘Action’, and ‘Vision’ levels of investment. In addition to being guided by the themes from a policy perspective, the department plan also provides clear direction on community identified needs for facilities, parks, and major asset categories across the system including courts, athletic fields, aquatics, parking, and accessibility. Balancing the community’s desires with BPR’s financial reality requires that the department prioritize what can be accomplished over the next six years. This framework also integrates the City of Boulder’s budgeting strategy built into the 2022 BPR Plan, which projects three scenarios based upon available funding. These scenarios are enable departments to proactively plan for outcomes based upon revenue projections and funding. There are three scenarios:: Fiscally Constrained plans for prioritized spending within existing budget targets. The intention of this alternative is to refocus and make the most of existing resources with the primary goal being for the department to maintain services. The fiscally constrained 19 19 scenario reflects BPR’s commitment to the community over the next six years, focusing on core services and those that benefit the greater community. Action describes the extra services or capital improvements that could be undertaken when additional funding is available. This includes making strategic changes that would lead to additional operational or capital funding. In coordination with the Finance Department, PRAB, and City Council, BPR would evaluate and analyze potential sources of additional revenue, including but not limited to capital bond funding, program income, grants and existing or new taxes. Vision represents the complete set of services and facilities desired by the community, without regard to resources or viability. While the Vision plan is fiscally unconstrained and unfunded, the intent is to provide high-level policy guidance by illustrating the ultimate goals of the community. Attachment B outlines the Financial Scenarios included in the 2022 BPR Plan, and includes a summary of levels of service based upon current funding levels in the Fiscally Constrained Scenario. Analysis Overall, the projected Budget for the CIP is predicted to decrease through 2030, compared to the 2024 – 2029 CIP. Despite this, the department is mostly maintain ing levels of funding for the CIP Asset Management Program focused on “Taking Care of What We Have. The department is continuing to fund three major projects that are underway; Civic Area Phase 2, North Boulder Park renovation and, the new Primos Park as well as funding at a reduced amount, two other park renovations: Pearl Street and Reservoir South Shore. With the latter two projects having major unfunded needs, basic renovation work will move ahead to take care of basic needs for key assets. The full Civic Area project is also underfunded based upon the size of the park, though major work will be completed in Phase 2 with $18 million in CCRS funding. As mentioned above, the department will focus funds on maintaining current parks and amenities over the next six years, including replacing assets past their life cycle, such as play areas. The Asset Management Program (AMP) provides the focus for this work and there is a major effort underway to better understand the condition, cost and life cycle stages of the major assets in parks. Once this work is completed over the next 12 months, BPR will have a greater understanding of where the underfunded needs are. Initial asset management program findings indicate that while BPR can maintain assets in fair to good condition, funding is not sufficient to replace amenities past their life cycle. Older amenities lead to decreased activity and increased maintenance costs. For example, as play areas age, children lose interest in dated equipment and repairs become costly as the infrastructure ages and can even be impossible to replace as parts are discontinued. The current maintenance backlog stands at approximately $230 million dollars and will likely increase as BPR further develops the AMP for parks and facilities. System planning occurring 2024 through 2026 will allow the city to better understand overall needs for recreation centers and parkland. This work will inform parks and recreation levels of service as well as inform funding needs for the long-term and help guide important decisions around the CIP program over the next decade. Identifying in more detail the work needed for the future will enable the Department to get ahead of planning and design efforts including preparing more robust project management plans. 20 20 To summarize, the CIP budget for the current workplan are identified below, providing information on the total CIP budget and where the funding comes from: • Total recommended 2025 – 2030 CIP includes $103 million o $68.2 million of this funding is tied to Community, Culture, Resilience and Safety Tax o $2.5 million of this funding is tied to other capital soures: Boulder Junction Improvement Fund and Capital Development Fund o $32.3 million of this funding is tied to BPR capital funds from the .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund, Permanent Park and Recreation Fund and Lottery Fund o This averages out to $5.4 million per year; o The 2024 – 2029 approved CIP for these three funds was $36.5 million, or an average of $6.0 million per year, resulting in a 10% decrease in CIP spend. • The total 2025 CIP recommended appropriation of $9.3 million includes funding from the following sources: o Ongoing BPR Capital Funds: o $1.8 million from .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund o $1.4 million from Permanent Park and Recreation Fund o $1.5 million from Lottery Fund o Other Capital Funds (project specific): o $2.2 million from Community, Culture, Resilience & Safety Fund o $2.0 million from Capital Development Fund o $0.5 million from Boulder Junction Improvement Fund • 2025 CIP recommended funding by project type o $2.5 million - Asset Management o $6.8 million - Park and Recreation Facilities o $0.1 million - System Planning NEXT STEPS: July 2024 PRAB Meeting: At the July PRAB meeting, the PRAB will be asked to 1) approve the 2025 recommended operating budget; 2) approve the recommended capital expenditures from the Permanent Park and Recreation Fund to City Council for appropriation; 3) recommend the 2025-2030 Parks and Recreation Department Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) to Planning Board and City Council for approval and appropriation. Budget Approval Process Following PRAB approval, the budget will go through the internal city review process which includes the Budget Office, Capital Review Team and Executive Budget Team. The department expects to have preliminary decisions on which budget requests will be included in the City Manager’s proposed budget by early August, with the recommended budget being shared with the community and City Council by late August . As the budget moves through the city-wide coordination and council review in the fall, staff will provide updates to the board. City Council will discuss the recommended 2025 budget at a Study Session on September 12, 2024. They will consider it for approval at 1 st Reading and Public Hearing 21 21 on October 3, 2024, and a 2 nd Reading and Public Hearing on October 17, 2024. The approved budget will take effect on January 1, 2025. QUESTIONS FOR THE PRAB: 1. Does the PRAB have any questions or input on the proposed 2025 Operating Budget? 2. Does the PRAB have any additional questions or input on the proposed 2025 – 2030 CIP? Attachment A: BPR Fund Financials (aligned with Scenario 2) - A-1: Recreation Activity Fund - A-2: .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund - A-3: Permanent Park and Recreation Fund Attachment B: 2022 BPR Plan Alternatives Attachment C: Draft 2025 – 2030 CIP by Project Attachment D: List of 2025 – 2030 CIP in Permanent Park and Recreation Fund 22 22 Recreation Activity Fund - 2300 *Fund Financial Data - OpenGov Report 2023 2024 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Actuals Adopted Revised Recommended Projected Projected Projected Projected Projected Beginning Fund Balance 3,360,613.02 3,364,279$ 3,364,279$ 3,434,090$ 2,951,606$ 2,815,562$ 2,451,880$ 1,610,268$ (108,083)$ Sources of Funds Use 3 years to calculate AAGR/Guidelines where appropriate Charges for Services 7,240,508 7,498,631 7,574,131 8,046,756 8,304,252 8,569,988 8,835,658 9,109,563 9,391,960 Leases, Rents & Royalties 1,965,148 2,171,863 2,171,863 2,168,800 2,238,202 2,309,824 2,383,738 2,460,018 2,538,739 Other Revenues 416,860 205,081 205,081 415,081 427,118 439,505 452,250 465,366 478,861 Misc. Sales of Materials & Goods 238,699 246,567 246,567 191,743 197,304 203,025 208,913 214,972 221,206 Investment Earnings & Bonds 67,570 - 105,638 134,616 120,130 113,749 99,056 65,055 (4,367) Transfers In General Fund Subsidy 2,107,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 1,607,713 Transfer Transportation Fund 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 Transfers In .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund (Ongoing)1,231,984 1,231,984 1,270,176 1,309,551 1,350,147 1,392,002 1,435,154 1,435,154 Transfers In .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund (Conditional)311,000 1,984,715 1,984,715 850,000 800,000 700,000 400,000 Implementation of Fee Policy/Business Plans - - - 750,000 1,000,000 1,250,000 1,250,000 1,250,000 Total Sources of Funds 12,360,498$ 14,959,554$ 15,140,692$ 14,697,885$ 15,767,270$ 16,306,951$ 16,642,330$ 16,620,840$ 16,932,265$ Uses of Funds Can use 2025 CPI as a basis for projections Community Building & Partnerships 632,029 880,507 882,947 967,294 997,280 1,028,196 1,060,070 1,092,932 1,126,813 Recreation Operations 11,724,803 13,866,336 14,187,934 14,213,076 14,451,281 14,899,271 15,361,148 15,837,344 16,328,301 Debt Service - - - - - - - - - Transfers & Cost Allocation - - - - - - - - - Wage Compression 454,753 743,166 1,062,725 1,408,915 1,783,636 Capital Improvement Program - - - - - - - - Total Uses of Funds 12,356,832$ 14,746,843$ 15,070,881$ 15,180,370$ 15,903,314$ 16,670,633$ 17,483,943$ 18,339,191$ 19,238,750$ Ending Fund Balance Before Reserves 3,364,279$ 3,576,990$ 3,434,090$ 2,951,606$ 2,815,562$ 2,451,880$ 1,610,268$ (108,083)$ (2,414,568)$ Reserves Operating Reserve 1,235,683$ 2,212,026$ 2,516,837$ 2,535,122$ 2,655,853$ 2,783,996$ 2,919,818$ 3,062,645$ 3,212,871$ Other reserves, if applicable Pay Period 27 Reserve 135,251 Sick/Vacation Reserve 16,129 16,613 28,300 29,149 30,024 30,924 31,852 32,808 33,792 Total Reserves 1,387,063$ 2,228,639$ 2,545,137$ 2,564,271$ 2,685,877$ 2,814,920$ 2,951,670$ 3,095,453$ 3,246,663$ Ending Fund Balance After Reserves 1,977,216$ 1,348,351$ 888,953$ 387,335$ 129,684$ (363,039)$ (1,341,403)$ (3,203,536)$ (5,661,231)$ Attachment A-1: Draft Proposed Recreation Activity Fund Financial23 23 .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund - 2180 *Fund Financial Data - OpenGov Report 2023 2024 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Actuals Adopted Revised Recommended Projected Projected Projected Projected Projected Beginning Fund Balance 11,925,775 14,341,033$ 14,341,033$ 6,275,815$ 5,249,620$ 4,298,119$ 3,422,811$ 2,724,817$ 2,137,854$ Sources of Funds Use 3 years to calculate AAGR/Guidelines where appropriate Sales and Use Tax 11,277,793 11,369,343 11,292,861 11,594,711 11,831,487 12,116,090 12,410,684 12,715,783 13,031,958 Investment Earnings & Bonds 335,412 55,000 450,308 246,012 213,660 173,644 138,282 110,083 86,369 Other Revenues 113,800 65,000 65,000 65,000 67,015 69,092 71,234 73,443 75,719 Charges for Services 113,297 - 16,100 - - - - - - Grant Revenues 90,452 - - - - - - - - Intergovernmental Revenues - - - - - - - - - Leases, Rents & Royalties - - - - - - - - - Transfers In - - - - - - - - - Total Sources of Funds 11,930,754$ 11,489,343$ 11,824,269$ 11,905,723$ 12,112,162$ 12,358,826$ 12,620,200$ 12,899,308$ 13,194,047$ Uses of Funds Can use 2025 CPI as a basis for projections Administration 1,012,940 1,513,654 1,561,282 1,334,379 1,254,021 1,292,895 1,332,975 1,374,297 1,416,900 Community Building & Partnerships 531,495 631,694 631,694 617,471 636,613 656,348 676,694 697,672 719,300 Natural Resources 1,088,910 1,066,464 1,196,051 1,137,599 1,172,865 1,209,223 1,246,709 1,285,357 1,325,203 Park Operations 3,278,000 2,958,598 3,097,594 3,115,865 3,212,457 3,312,043 3,414,716 3,520,573 3,629,710 Planning & Construction 614,044 948,430 1,000,354 993,219 1,024,009 1,055,753 1,088,481 1,122,224 1,157,013 Urban Rangers Program 351,217 362,105 373,330 384,903 396,835 409,137 Facility Operations 505,691 527,944 588,736 549,938 566,986 584,563 602,684 621,367 640,630 Transfers Out .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund (Ongoing)1,231,984 1,231,984 1,270,176 1,309,551 1,350,147 1,392,002 1,435,154 1,435,154 Transfers Out .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund (Conditional)311,000 1,984,715 1,984,715 850,000 800,000 700,000 400,000 Debt Service - - - - - - - - - Transfers & Cost Allocation 686,525 706,859 706,859 902,054 1,172,058 1,230,175 1,291,198 1,355,272 1,422,550 Wage Compression 27,999 44,658 62,831 82,519 103,829 Capital Improvement Program 1,486,891 2,903,000 7,890,218 1,810,000 1,525,000 1,425,000 1,425,000 1,595,000 1,325,000 Total Uses of Funds 9,515,496$ 14,473,342$ 19,889,487$ 12,931,918$ 13,063,662$ 13,234,135$ 13,318,194$ 13,486,271$ 13,584,427$ Ending Fund Balance Before Reserves 14,341,033$ 11,357,034$ 6,275,815$ 5,249,620$ 4,298,119$ 3,422,811$ 2,724,817$ 2,137,854$ 1,747,474$ Reserves Operating Reserve 1,340,777$ 1,932,247$ 2,003,878$ 1,352,648$ 1,378,933$ 1,424,317$ 1,471,274$ 1,519,846$ 1,570,093$ Other reserves, if applicable Pay Period 27 Reserve 135,251 Sick/Vacation Reserve 16,129 16,613 14,098 14,521 14,956 15,405 15,867 16,343 16,833 Total Reserves 1,492,157$ 1,948,860$ 2,017,976$ 1,367,169$ 1,393,889$ 1,439,722$ 1,487,141$ 1,536,189$ 1,586,926$ Ending Fund Balance After Reserves 12,848,876$ 9,408,173$ 4,257,839$ 3,882,451$ 2,904,230$ 1,983,089$ 1,237,675$ 601,665$ 160,548$ Attachment A-2: Draft Proposed .25 Cent Sales Tax Fund Financial 24 24 Permanent Park & Recreaton Fund - 3300 *Fund Financial Data - OpenGov Report 2023 2024 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 Actuals Adopted Revised Recommended Projected Projected Projected Projected Projected Beginning Fund Balance 6,563,851.07 4,693,659$ 4,693,659$ 963,592$ 2,071,385$ 1,715,629$ 1,636,836$ 959,116$ 781,675$ Sources of Funds Use 3 years to calculate AAGR/Guidelines where appropriate Property Tax 3,753,683 4,538,966 4,493,933 4,413,466 4,973,367 4,772,092 5,146,036 5,146,036 5,625,271 Investment Earnings & Bonds 154,497 55,000 147,381 37,773 84,305 69,826 66,619 39,036 31,814 Other Revenues 20,811 - - - - - - - - Leases, Rents & Royalties 23,535 - 13,200 - - - - - - Transfers In - - - - - - - - - Total Sources of Funds 3,952,526$ 4,593,966$ 4,654,514$ 4,451,239$ 5,057,672$ 4,841,918$ 5,212,655$ 5,185,072$ 5,657,085$ Uses of Funds Can use 2025 CPI as a basis for projections Planning & Construction 1,576,117 1,815,798 1,846,766 1,615,178 1,665,249 1,716,871 1,770,094 1,824,967 1,881,541 Debt Service Transfers & Cost Allocation 192,050 197,812 197,812 298,267 313,180 328,839 345,281 362,545 380,673 Capital Improvement Program 4,054,551 3,000,000 6,340,003 1,430,000 3,435,000 2,875,000 3,775,000 3,175,000 2,875,000 Total Uses of Funds 5,822,718$ 5,013,610$ 8,384,581$ 3,343,445$ 5,413,429$ 4,920,711$ 5,890,376$ 5,362,513$ 5,137,214$ Ending Fund Balance Before Reserves 4,693,659$ 4,274,015$ 963,592$ 2,071,385$ 1,715,629$ 1,636,836$ 959,116$ 781,675$ 1,301,547$ Reserves Operating Reserve 295,284$ 336,273$ 341,445$ 269,735$ 278,097$ 286,717$ 295,606$ 304,770$ 314,217$ Other reserves, if applicable Pay Period 27 Reserve 40,734 Sick/Vacation Reserve 3,162 3,257 5,086 5,238 5,396 5,558 5,724 5,896 6,073 Total Reserves 339,180$ 339,530$ 346,531$ 274,973$ 283,493$ 292,275$ 301,330$ 310,666$ 320,290$ Ending Fund Balance After Reserves 4,354,479$ 3,934,485$ 617,061$ 1,796,413$ 1,432,136$ 1,344,561$ 657,786$ 471,010$ 981,256$ Attachment A-3: Draft Proposed Permanent Park and Recreation Fund Financial25 25 88 | Where We Are Going FINANCIAL FRAMEWORK Through the master planning process BPR has gathered feedback on desired facility and programming improvements from both individual members of the community and specific user groups. Balancing the community’s desires with BPR’s financial reality requires that the department prioritize what can be accomplished over the next five years. Adopted in 2006, the City of Boulder’s budgeting strategy requires each department to acknowledge and plan for multiple revenue scenarios. These scenarios are intended to enable departments to proactively plan for outcomes in which revenues remain flat or increase. The following section summarizes the three budgeting scenarios in which future projects and programs are assigned. plan alternatives Using the city’s budgeting strategy of defining outcomes for the Fiscally Constrained, Action, and Vision budgeting scenarios, BPR has developed three plan alternatives based on variable levels of funding. fiscally constrained The Fiscally Constrained alternative plans for prioritized spending within existing budget targets. The intention of this alternative is to refocus and make the most of existing resources with the primary goal being for the department to maintain services. The actions associated with the Fiscally Constrained alternative require limited or no funding to accomplish and are focused on providing or enhancing core and/or existing services. The fiscally constrained scenario reflects BPR’s commitment to the community over the next five years, focusing on core services and those that benefit the greater community. action The Action alternative describes the extra services or capital improvements that could be undertaken when additional funding is available. This includes strategically enhancing existing programs, beginning new alternative programs, adding new positions, or making other strategic changes that would require additional operational or capital funding. In coordination with the Central Budget Department, PRAB, and City Council, BPR would evaluate and analyze potential sources of additional revenue, including but not limited to capital bond funding, program income, grants and existing or new taxes. vision The Vision alternative represents the complete set of services and facilities desired by the community, without regard to resources or viability. While the Vision plan is fiscally unconstrained and unfunded, the intent is to provide high-level policy guidance by illustrating the ultimate goals of the community and by providing an aspirational look to the parks and recreation system, without considering feasibility. Plan Alternatives Using the City of Boulder’s budgeting strategy of defining outcomes for the Fiscally Contrained, Action and Vision budgeting scenarios, BPR has developed three plan alternatives based on variable levels of funding. »Fiscally Constrained BPR’s commitment to the community over the next five years »Action Aspirational projects and programs that may be accomplished if additional funding becomes available »Vision An unfunded wishlist of projects and programs Attachment B: 2022 BPR Plan Alternatives 26 26 Where We Are Going | 89 PLAN ALTERNATIVES PROJECTS FISCALLY CONSTRAINED ACTION VISION Park Maintenance -BPR Asset Management Program Maintain Well at FCI .07, Develop Violet Park Enhance and add trending amenities Full concept plan implementation for all planned parks Playgrounds 1-2 Parks/Playgrounds per year refurbished (25-30 year) Playground enhancement accelerated (20 year)N/A Restrooms - Pending LOS Evaluation Maintain current LOS, transitioning to universal restrooms as facilities are built or replaced Add more to appropriate parks, accelerate transition to universal restrooms N/A Valmont Park - 2015 Concept Plan Phase 1 development of adventure and nature play elements Phase II development, including disc golf, athletic fields Full concept plan implementation, including infrastructure for community recreation facilities Urban Canopy - Urban Forest Strategic Plan Focus on health of current canopy through IPM, Tree Safety, EAB response, and public tree protection— Some canopy growth through tax investment, philanthropy and partnership Improved rotation for street trees, increased planting to support 16% canopy cover by 2027. Carbon credits could create additional funding source. Industry standard rotation for all public trees, sufficient planting to achieve urban canopy goals. Civic Area Activation w/ Operations Focus Phase II development N/A Area III Complete Baseline Urban Service Plan and develop concept plan, but nothing is developed Build core elements Full park development PARKS Could the Summer Olympics skateboarding competition be in this skater’s future? If he keeps practicing his skills at Valmont City Park, it just might become a reality. Attachment B: 2022 BPR Plan Alternatives 27 27 90 | Where We Are Going PLAN ALTERNATIVES PROJECTS FISCALLY CONSTRAINED ACTION VISION Athletic Fields - 2015 Athletic Field Study Optimize usage through partnerships, maintenance and conversion to artificial turf 8th Field at Stazio, Redevelopment at Mapleton and Tom Watson to optimize usage Build fields at Valmont City Park Recreation Centers - 2022 Facility Needs Assessment EBCC & NBRC - Maintain Well SBRC - Retire past useful life facility but not replace; citywide facility feasibility study for SOBO area facilities Enhance Facilities Modernize EBCC & NBRC; Design/Build South Boulder facility Courts - Study pending Maintain Well. Court study to identify LOS—Seek opportunities to maximize community benefit through Joint Use Agreements/ partnerships Enhance for increased durability, some additional facilities Additional new facilities may be developed Aquatics -2015 Aquatics Feasibility Study Maintain current service levels and pools Enhance Spruce Pool Build aquatic training facility at Valmont City Park Reservoir -2018 South Shore Capital Strategy Improve existing site connections and ciruclation Additional shade structures and group picnic areas, children’s play and outdoor education Marina facility includes meeting/event space, boat storage/maintenance facilities FACILITIES Balancing is key to success when taking the BoulderLift class at East Boulder Community Center. Attachment B: 2022 BPR Plan Alternatives 28 28 Where We Are Going | 91 PLAN ALTERNATIVES PROJECTS FISCALLY CONSTRAINED ACTION VISION Facility Access Fees Continued increases to base fees to keep up with cost escalation, maintaining discounts for youth and seniors Increase base fees and increase discounts for youth and seniors Free for target populations (youth & seniors) Financial Aid Maintaining Financial Aid LOS reliant upon grants and philanthropy Funding supports increased aid and sliding scale for maximum access Sliding scale supports full participation EXPAND Core Services for Target Population funded by GF subsidy and grants Service levels increase N/A Youth / Teens Additional programming only possible through discontinuation of other services or market based programs Programming for youth and teens grows with additional donations, grants or subsidy N/A Young explorers taking advantage of nature play opportunities during an annual BPR summer camp program. PROGRAMS & SERVICES Attachment B: 2022 BPR Plan Alternatives 29 29 Attachment C: Draft 2025 - 2030 CIP by Project Project Title 2025 CIP Budget 2026 CIP Budget 2027 CIP Budget 2028 CIP Budget 2029 CIP Budget 2030 CIP Budget 2025-2030 Total Asset Management- Aquatics Facilities 100,000 - 1,000,000 - - - 1,100,000 Asset Management- Courts 400,000 400,000 400,000 400,000 400,000 400,000 2,400,000 Asset Management- General Maintenance 200,000 200,000 250,000 250,000 200,000 200,000 1,300,000 Asset Management- Historic Property 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 300,000 Asset Management- Irrigation 210,000 125,000 125,000 125,000 125,000 125,000 835,000 Asset Management- Parking Lots/Access & Mobility 300,000 300,000 200,000 200,000 200,000 200,000 1,400,000 Asset Management- Play Areas - 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 2,500,000 Asset Management- Regional Facilities 300,000 300,000 300,000 300,000 300,000 300,000 1,800,000 Asset Management- Restrooms and Picnic Shelter 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 1,500,000 Asset Management- Sports Fields 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 600,000 Asset Management-Natural Lands 50,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 425,000 Asset Management-Urban Forest Management 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 500,000 3,000,000 Boulder Junction Park 500,000 - - - - - 500,000 Boulder Reservoir South Shore Capital Enhancements - 400,000 1,500,000 600,000 - - 2,500,000 Civic Area Phase II 2,000,000 10,000,000 5,500,000 - - - 17,500,000 EBCC Refresh -40,000,000 - - 7,500,000 -47,500,000 Operational Planning 200,000 - - - 270,000 - 470,000 Park Refresh 540,000 2,200,000 3,100,000 2,300,000 2,000,000 10,140,000 Pearl Street Mall Refresh 150,000 3,000,000 - - - - 3,150,000 Pleasant View Park 448,000 - - - - - 448,000 System Planning 120,000 60,000 50,000 50,000 400,000 - 680,000 Violet Park 2,920,000 - - - - - 2,920,000 Grand Total 9,338,000 58,460,000 10,800,000 6,500,000 13,170,000 4,700,000 102,968,000 30 30 Attachment D: Draft 2025 - 2030 CIP in Permanent Park and Recreation Fund Project Title 2025 CIP Budget 2026 CIP Budget 2027 CIP Budget 2028 CIP Budget 2029 CIP Budget 2030 CIP Budget 2025-2030 Total Asset Management- Aquatics Facilities - - 500,000 - - - 500,000 Asset Management- General Maintenance 200,000 200,000 250,000 250,000 200,000 200,000 1,300,000 Asset Management- Historic Property 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 50,000 300,000 Asset Management- Regional Facilities 200,000 200,000 200,000 300,000 300,000 1,200,000 Asset Management- Restrooms and Picnic Shelter 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 1,500,000 Asset Management-Natural Lands 50,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 75,000 425,000 Boulder Reservoir South Shore Capital Enhancements - 400,000 1,500,000 600,000 - - 2,500,000 Operational Planning 200,000 - - - - - 200,000 Park Refresh 112,000 2,200,000 2,300,000 1,900,000 2,000,000 8,512,000 Pleasant View Park 448,000 - - - - - 448,000 System Planning 120,000 60,000 50,000 50,000 400,000 - 680,000 Grand Total 1,430,000 3,435,000 2,875,000 3,775,000 3,175,000 2,875,000 17,565,000 31 31 TO: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board FROM: Alison Rhodes, Director of Parks and Recreation Bryan Beary, Senior Manager, Community Building and Partnerships Mark Davison, Senior Manager, Planning Denise Dawson, Senior Manager, Urban Parks Regina Elsner, Senior Manager, Natural Resources Jackson Hite, Senior Manager, Business Services Megann Lohman, Senior Manager, Recreation Stephanie Munro, Senior Manager, Regional Facilities Scott Schuttenberg, Deputy Director SUBJECT: Matters from the Department DATE: June 24, 2024 A. Tennis and Pickleball Court System Plan: BPR’s role in indoor courts The intent of this item is to provide PRAB with an overview of analysis for potential indoor court service delivery. PRAB last discussed the Court System Plan at the March business meeting. Background The Court System Plan evaluates the growing demand for both pickleball and tennis in the community and the city’s contributing role in providing designated courts for both sports. In addition, the plan evaluates the changing court supply – including the closure of a private tennis facility at the Millenium site and pending development of CU South - impacts to the Boulder racket playing community. The Court System Plan provides recommendations utilizing a three-pronged approach that blends input from the community, analysis of data and research, and policy guidance. Background information on the court system is available on the project webpage. Process and Timeline A detailed project timeline is available online. The PRAB has been engaged at various points in the process of developing this plan: • May 2023 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 17) • July 2023 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 12) • September 2023 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 7) • October 2023 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 14) • November 2023 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 229) • January 2024 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 63) • March 2024 PRAB meeting (starts on pg. 15) The scope of the Court System Plan includes an analysis of BPR’s role in indoor tennis. The plan evaluates various models for delivering indoor tennis and outlines the benefits and impacts of three service delivery models. With this information, BPR can consider possible partnerships for facilities. There may be a short-term option as courts are developed at East Boulder Community Park in 2025 and BPR is aware of potential community partnerships to make building and operating a temporary indoor structure feasible. Long-term and 32 32 permanent facility investment will be explored with the Future of Recreation Centers project and Long-Term Financial Strategy to determine what the community wants, then understand what it would cost to build and operate any desired new amenities, and finally, to explore with the community if it is interested in paying for a new facility. As previously noted, any new facility is a 50-year decision and requires major planning work to support the policy conversation responsibly and well. Any proposal for an indoor facility is currently unfunded. The purpose of the analysis is to explore scenarios for an indoor facility to help inform how this concept could move from vision to reality. An indoor racquet facility should be viewed as a complex aspirational project given the length of time and the capital cost to construct upon undeveloped vacant property. The complexity however goes beyond the time and cost and can be summarized to two questions: • Can the city leverage current public and/or private assets that exist within the community to create an indoor racquet facility for Boulder community? • What delivery model is the most viable way to achieve the objective of providing indoor racquet facility while balancing other factors of risk, cost, time-to-market, and control? There are three indoor racquet facility options for the City to consider and they are as follows: • City Owned and Operated. • Public-Private Partnership. • Ground Lease and Management Agreement. All three are used widely throughout the country in the parks and recreation industry for different types of facilities. The staff presentation on this topic will explore the three scenarios described above walking through the pros and cons of each as well as the process for exploring potential future partnership opportunities that could make an indoor facility viable. Discussion Question: Do board members have any questions or input regarding the analysis for indoor court service delivery and partnership opportunities? Next Steps The PRAB’s input will inform a final draft of the plan, which will be shared at the July business meeting. Upon completion, the plan will be shared with the community and guide BPR investments and operations. 33 33 B. Park on Violet: Concept Plan Update The intent of this item is to gather input from the PRAB on the preferred concept plan for a new neighborhood park in North Boulder. Until a name is designated, the park has been referred to as the Park on Violet. The community has proposed a name, Primos Park, which is the topic of proposed PRAB action at this business meeting. Comments from the PRAB will inform next steps, which include further design, engineering and initial permitting. The timeline below lays out the overall project approach, schedule, and status. Timeframe Task Status Summer-Fall 2023 Engagement Window #1 (Vision & Values) Planning analysis Complete Early 2024 Preliminary concept plan alternatives Complete Spring 2024 Engagement Window #2 (Design concepts, park naming, safe routes to the park; nature play picnics) Refining a preferred concept plan Complete May 20, 2024 PRAB hears recommendation to rename park Complete June 24, 2024 PRAB votes on new name PRAB discusses concept plan to inform next phase In progress Late Summer 2024 PRAB’s CIP tour visits park site Engagement Window #3 (Early action on safe routes; continued space activation; naming celebration; design character; project phasing) Initial permitting/concept review by City Planning & Development Services Initial grant application to Great Outdoors Colorado Next phase Fall 2024 Planning Board review Schematic Design PRAB update on schematic design Next phase Late 2024 - Early 2025 Design development Engagement Window #4 (Continued space activation; design details; maintenance and operations planning) PRAB update on design development Next phase Mid- to Late-2025 Final construction documents, specifications, and Park Operations Plan Federal and local permitting PRAB update Next phase Late 2025-28 Continued space activation Phased construction Next phase 34 34 Community Input During Engagement Window 2, youth and community members affirmed the vision and values defined in the first window and weighed in on how to demonstrate those values in the name, design and activation of the new park. Through a variety of community-led engagement opportunities, individuals, families, and partners evaluated three separate, preliminary site plans that explored ways to emphasize different combinations of community values: Concept 1: Community & culture Concept 2: Nature & play Concept 3: Food & friends Figure 1: Participants in BPR's Youth Services Initiative evaluate design concepts at Crest View Elementary School meeting Impactful input emerged during a community gathering at Crest View Elementary School, a virtual focus group on how the park can advance mental health, an in-person and community audit of existing routes to and from the park, as well as free nature play picnics with preschoolers and their caregivers (hosted by Growing Up Boulder). After analyzing comments from all engagements, staff shared initial conclusions with the three community connectors for the project, who affirmed these general themes: - Overall preference for Concept 2: Nature & Play. - Appreciation for climate-forward approaches in Concept 2, such as improved flood capacity and regeneration of riparian forest and prairie landscapes. - Continued interest in water play, unstructured play in nature, and opportunities for youth leadership and teen employment. - Excitement for iconic, sensory-rich opportunities to climb into the trees and/or appreciate views. - Strong support for food trucks, a community food forest, and community gathering spaces in Concepts 1 and 3. 35 35 - Desire for a range of accessible spaces that support mindfulness and mental health, including a reservable outdoor wellness room for individuals, groups or therapists. - Need for improved routes to and from the park, especially along Violet and 19th and for people with disabilities (see information here regarding the Safe Routes to Parks grant award). Preferred Concept Plan Community voices directly informed the development of a preferred concept plan that merges preferred elements from all three concepts. Still conceptual at this point in the process, this site plan suggests general layout and scaling for program elements across the 9-acre site. The graphic below also includes example photographs or precedent images that may inform further design as community conversations continue about preferences for colors, materials, and other qualities of built features in the park. Highlights of this concept plan include: - Ecosystem enhancements to address flooding, increase biodiversity, and support pollinator pathways and wildlife movement. - Dispersed nature play pods throughout the site that advance gross-motor skills, fine- motor skills, creativity, and social interaction among people with and without disabilities. - An outdoor pavilion with an adjacent play plaza and food truck staging. - A small-scale amphitheater for community gathering, outdoor learning, and dramatic play. - A small-scale “Kids Kiosk” (gear library and restroom) to support youth- and community-led programming. 36 36 - A community food forest and sensory gardens. - Reservable outdoor spaces for gathering, wellness, and other activities. - Interpretive signs and art Currently, the BPR Capital Improvement Program (CIP) includes $4.7million for design and construction of this site, with an additional $750,000 grant from the National Park Service. In addition, the city is determining available funding for associated Utilities and Transportation and Mobility elements. Based upon current cost estimating, staff anticipate a funding gap to develop the entire site. Additional design, planning, and engineering will result in updated cost estimates that will then help determine feasibility, phasing, funding plan, and future park operations. For example, it is possible that not all elements of this preferred concept plan will advance, based on available funding, staffing, and other considerations. As the project progresses, staff will also develop a park operations plan that addresses space activation and maintenance strategies, as well as rules, regulations, and partnerships necessary to sustain park health long into the future. It is also important to note that this concept plan would require earthwork and other adjustments to accommodate additional floodwaters, capture sediment and reduce the high hazard zone. In partnership with the City of Boulder’s Utilities and Transportation and Mobility departments, this aspect of the project requires significant investment to replace and expand the bridge and culvert where Fourmile Canyon Creek passes under Violet Avenue. Floodplain modeling will test the feasibility of these interventions and result in future updates to design. Significant permitting through the Federal Emergency Management Agency and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers will also affect project approach and schedule. Construction activities are anticipated to begin in early 2026. Members of the PRAB are encouraged to consider the following questions while reviewing the preferred concept plan: 1. What clarifying questions do you have regarding the preferred concept plan? 2. Which elements of the proposed layout are most important or effective in advancing the community’s vision and values? 3. Are there any red flags that concern you or improvements you would suggest? Next Steps The project team will incorporate feedback from the PRAB into the next phase of schematic design, which includes an initial development review application through the city’s Planning and Development Services and subsequent review by the Planning Board. Later this summer, members of the PRAB will have a chance to visit the site as part of the CIP tour and to attend or support community events during engagement window 3, such as a youth- led ceremony to celebrate the new park name. As part of the Safe Routes to Parks grant process with the Play Boulder Foundation, Transportation and Mobility staff are also expected to install traffic calming measures along Violet Avenue and 19th St in early August. The PRAB will receive project updates in July’s consent agenda. C. 2022 BPR Plan Implementation Update (verbal presentation) 37 37 3198 Broadway, Boulder, CO 80304 | www.boulderparks-rec.org | O: 303-413-7200 TO: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board SUBJECT: Matters from the Board DATE: June 24, 2024 A. Final Review: Board Liaison’s to BPR Projects (Attachment A) a. The Role of Board Liaisons is to provide input on process and community engagement, provide a deeper level of knowledge on a project in support of addressing community questions to the board and to support board conversations on the topic at business meetings and study session. B. PRAB Matters (Verbal) 38 38 Attachment A 2024-2025 Opportunities Board Liaisons to BPR Projects The Role of Board Liaisons is to provide input on process and community engagement, provide a deeper level of knowledge on a project in support of addressing community questions to the board and to support board conversations on the topic at business meetings and study session. Park Plans Violet Park Development, Design through Q3-2024 Civic Area Phase II, Design through 2025 Bernie Bernstein Waylon Lewis Public Private Partnerships: Q3-2024 • Boulder Reservoir Sunny van der Star System Plans and Initiatives Courts System Plan, Q3 2023 – Q3 2024 Bernie Bernstein Budget Development, Q2 2024 – Q3 2024 Elliott Hood Recreation Centers Future, Q3 2024 – Q2 2026 –Deryn Wagner PM Sunny van der Star Bernie Bernstein Regional Facility Business Plans, Q3 2024 - Q2 2025 Elliott Hood PLAY Boulder**, Ongoing Anna Segur Option exists to serve as an informal liaison or as a board member of PLAY *Jennifer Robbins and (Waylon Lewis) interested RMS System Evaluation, Q3 2024 – Q3 2025 1. The Board’s functions are: 1. To approve or disapprove proposals concerning the disposal of park lands and forward such recommendations to the city council; 2. To approve or disapprove expenditures or appropriations from the permanent park and recreation fund and forward such recommendations to the city council; 3. To make recommendations to the council concerning the grant or denial of any license or permit in or on park lands; 4. To make recommendations to the council concerning protection and maintenance of park lands; 5. To review the city manager’s proposed annual budget relating to parks and recreation matters and submit its recommendations concerning that budget to the council; 6. At the request of council, the city manager or the department of parks and recreation matters and submit its recommendations concerning that budget to the council; 7. At the request of council, the city manager[,] or the department of parks and recreation, to prepare and submit to the council, manager[,] or department, recommendations on any additional park and recreation matters; and 8. To request information and recommendations from the department of parks and recreation pursuant to the provisions of Charter Section 155. 39 39