HomeMy WebLinkAbout09.08.20 DMC Packet
DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT COMMISSION
September 8, 2020
4:00 – 6:00 p.m.
Virtual Meeting
AGENDA
• Roll Call
• Approval of the July 14, 2020 Meeting Minutes
• Public Participation
• Consent Items – topics will not be discussed unless there are questions posed by the
Commission. Please reference the consent agenda memo.
• BPD Update – Wyton
• DBP Update – Chip
• Matters from Commissioners
• Matters from Staff
Attachments:
• Draft DMC Meeting Minutes – July 14, 2020
• DMC Consent Agenda – September 8, 2020
• Mall Area Crime Statistics – July and August 2020
Commissioner Term Exp. DMC 2020 Priorities
Adam Knoff
Andrew Niemeyer
Susan Nuzum, Vice-chair
Jerry Shapins, Chair
Vacant
Property Owner/Rep
Citizen-at-Large
Property Owner/Rep
Citizen-at-Large
Property Owner/Rep
2023
2022
2024
2021
2025
-Continue implementation of Retail Strategy action steps
-Partner with CU and city staff to ensure strong transit
connections between downtown and University Hill to capitalize
on new hotel development on the Hill.
-Participate in the planning of the future development of the
East Book End, including improved pedestrian access between
the Civic Area and the commercial district and advocating for
effective parking policies.
-Engage with City Council.
-Advance innovative downtown access and mobility strategies.
-Maintain CAGID facilities and improve the user experience.
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 1
CITY OF BOULDER, COLORADO
BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS MEETING MINUTES
DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT COMMISSION
NAMES OF MEMBERS, STAFF, AND INVITED GUESTS PRESENT:
BOARD MEMBERS: Shapins, Niemeyer, Nuzum, Knoff
STAFF: Jones, Woulf, Bray, Wyton (BPD), Hayward
GUESTS: Chip (DBP)
PERSON PREPARING SUMMARY: Heather Hayward, (303) 441-4191
TYPE OF MEETING: Regular July 14, 2020
Roll Call: Completed. Called to order at 4:06 p.m.
Approval of the May 12, 2020 Joint Meeting Minutes
Nuzum moved to approve the May 12, 2020 minutes. Shapins seconded. All in favor. Approved.
Public Participation
None.
Consent Items
Consent Items - No questions. Consent Items stand. Shapins moved to approve. Nuzum seconded.
Approved.
Boulder Police Department Update
Sergeant Wyton reported on police activities in downtown. He discussed morning sweeps and said that
people are being cooperative. Things are improving and looking much better than when this commission
last met. The restroom hours have been modified and that seems to have worked well. The team has
increased by one officer, so they now have two officer teams on each end of the week. They are still
limited with enforcement. Eleven reports were taken yesterday on stolen bikes. Fireworks are an issue as
they are in every community right now. Fireworks have been a bigger problem this year. They’ve been
using primarily an education approach regarding mask wearing and social distancing. The Homeless
Outreach Team is providing masks. Regarding encampments, the BPD, Parks and (PW) Streets are doing
cleanups with ServPro at targeted hot spots. At night, the officers have been writing camping tickets
where they can.
DBP Update
Chip reported that Downtown Boulder Partnership has moved into stabilization mode. He discussed some
of the items from the DBP Update document, including the first virtual Band on The Bricks to take place
on July 14. This will be a fundraiser for the Downtown Boulder Foundation. Chip also stated that DBP is
in conversations with Boulder Community Health and others regarding testing/screening for downtown
employees. DBP are putting together a task force to find out how DBP can support businesses post-
summer in more challenging times to come. Chip also discussed the Intercept survey they are working on
in partnership with the Visitors Bureau and Community Vitality. The initial data is showing that there are
lots of visitors and that over 40% surveyed are coming from outside Boulder/Denver metro area.
Chip said they now have a pedestrian counter and are seeing a lot of traffic and a bit more on the West
Draft DMC Meeting Minutes – July 14, 2020
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 2
End. It will be hard to manage to how people socially distance downtown. They are encouraging the
importance of mask wearing.
Shapins talked about opportunities to retrofit the mall and discussed issues of crowding downtown. He
suggested deck structures on top of current flower beds.
Matters from Commissioners
Niemeyer commended the effort of city staff in getting outside dining process handled so expeditiously
and stated that this was a life saver to many businesses.
Niemeyer had questions regarding the DMC commissioner vacancy. Jones discussed that there had been a
second round of interviews prior to COVID, but that he would check back on the status.
Shapins discussed issues on the east side of Pearl with pedestrian congestion and that people need to walk
through areas where people are eating. Shapins suggested that too much space has been given to cars
versus pedestrians in that area. Jones said that the option was provided to businesses on the east of Pearl
to close three blocks. It was determined that the concentration of restaurants and retailers on the east end
would have generated the same amount of activity as the west end. The HOP route was moved over to
Walnut to make the east end more accommodating. The formal application process has closed but
reopening the process could be considered if there were a large number of applications.
Chip reported that there was some controversy with businesses on both ends of Pearl regarding closing
traffic. While a lot of people are excited about eating outdoors, there are still a lot of businesses that
support the desire for pickup. The momentum on the East end was against closing the street. People are
adapting and trying to make it work.
Shapins said he hopes that East Side options will be considered and that new solutions will be needed.
Matters from Staff
2021 Community Vitality Recommended Budget
Woulf reviewed the 2021 recommended budget. The overall impact of COVID on the General Fund is
significant and there’s been a 17-25% decrease in revenue. In response, Community Vitality was initially
asked to reduce their budget by 10%. Community Vitality was then asked to reduce an additional 10% of
mostly ongoing reductions in 2021 across all funds. They will have flexibility with GID’s depending on
revenue impacts. CAGID will see some revenue impacts. Based on numbers provided in the reductions,
they were asked for an additional 7% General Fund reductions.
COVID Response and Recovery
They are getting close to finalizing a portion of CARES Act funding. The cities across Boulder County
and the County had to come to an agreement as a prerequisite to access CARES Act funds. A good
portion of these funds will be used for reimbursable expenses, but it can also be used for new expenses
from now through the end of year. They are particularly interested in key areas of small business support.
Woulf discussed COVID Impacts such as a decrease in on street occupancy. Street parking is ramping up
but is still at 50% of normal. There has been a decrease in garage usage due to lots of teleworking. Trends
they are watching will include work from home policies and public transportation habits. They are also
looking at commercial vacancy rates and timing of large events and the university status.
Draft DMC Meeting Minutes – July 14, 2020
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 3
2020 and 2021 Budget Reductions
Reductions taken included furloughs, a hiring freeze and eliminations of several positions. Elimination of
positions was not taken lightly and will have a customer service impact. Eliminations resulted in a 16-
17% reduction of our entire work force. The eliminations will save about $195,000 this year and
$270,000 overall, mostly in CAGID. Reductions were also made in Capital Projects. The biggest impact
was in postponing technology enhancements. With less eyes on the ground, they will be pushing for the
technology enhancements if possible, even though they’re postponed in 2020.
Fund Balance Application
Woulf stated that it’s a best practice to apply operating reserve in a situation like this. He would not
suggest using all of the fund balance, but they are looking at using $1.5-$1.6 million for CAGID going
into 2021. That would still leave CAGID with a healthy fund balance.
2021 CV Budget Reductions
Woulf reported that the initial 10% recommended reductions included reduction of scope of Capital
Projects. In order to get to a 10% reduction, they would need to reduce Economic Vitality programming.
Among other things, this would mean no new expansion and eliminating the flex rebate program. An
additional 7% reduction would require additional service reductions. This would impact both CAGID and
UHGID. If travel habits change and this becomes an underutilized program, then they may need to look at
a larger restructuring of the EcoPass program. If they need to reach this reduction without changes to the
EcoPass program, they would need to look at staffing reductions.
CAGID Tenants and Rent Deferment
Woulf stated that they have a number of tenants in CAGID owned properties. In response to COVID, they
offered deferred rent for April through June, payable beginning in July. For some tenants, that might not
be enough. Currently the City is not open to rent abatement, but they are looking for solutions with their
property managers and tenants.
Nuzum asked if the amount requested for the EcoPass had changed. Woulf stated that for 2020, they will
receive a credit for the time that RTD did not charge. The amount of credit is unknown at this point.
Niemeyer discussed that the restaurant community has been supported by outdoor dining, PPP loans, etc.,
but the expectation from large percentage of restaurant community is that they’re going dark this winter.
They will either close permanently or until spring. It will be a lean and painful winter for retail and
restaurants and could be far worse than the current budget cuts are taking into account.
Approval of the 2021-20216 Capital Improvement Plan and the Current Staff Approach to the 2021
Community Vitality Budget
Shapins moved to approve. Niemeyer seconded, Nuzum thirds. All in favor. Approved.
AMPS
Jones reviewed the AMPS implementation proposed timeline. He reported that they are in contract
negotiations with Walker Consultants out of Denver and anticipate a Notice to Proceed by August 1st.
The timeline outlines three touches to commissions and boards and city council. The first will be at the
end of the fourth quarter of this year. The work will be largely complete by mid-year 2021. At the end of
this year they will present a parking pricing assessment. Walker will also be doing a review of the
Neighborhood Parking Program and will be presenting options to move forward.
Jones discussed that they would like to get two members of the commission as stakeholders as they
pursue this work with the consultants. Nuzum stated that she would be interested, depending on the time
Draft DMC Meeting Minutes – July 14, 2020
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 4
involved.
Shapins asked about whether the strategy is taking the COVID impact into account. Jones confirmed that
the plan is looking at the COVID impact on a variety of fronts. Public engagement is a key part of the
conversation on curbside management. The consultant team will be using an online digital hub to gain
information. They will be reviewing parking utilization because they don’t know what future demand will
look like. They will be tapping into some of the technology advancements and people’s new
comfortability with technology in this COVID environment.
Shapins moved to adjourn. Niemeyer seconded.
Meeting Adjourned: 5:48 p.m.
NEXT MEETING: September 8, 2020
APPROVED BY: DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT COMMISSION
Attest: ________________________ _________________________________
Heather Hayward, Secretary Jerry Shapins, Chairperson
Draft DMC Meeting Minutes – July 14, 2020
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 5
CITY OF BOULDER
DOWNTOWN MANAGEMENT COMMISSION
CONSENT AGENDA ITEM
September 8, 2020
The following information is intended to provide the commission with relevant updates on
specific projects as they reach major milestones.
A.Community Vitality Update
•The City of Boulder is currently under the statewide Safer at Home and in the
Vast, Great Outdoors Order . This allows for limited public gatherings with
appropriate social distancing and precautions. All City of Boulder Special Event
Applications must comply with related state and county guidance. As such, the
OUT Boulder Pride Fest will be conducted as a motorcade on Sunday,
September 13 at 10:00 a.m. December Parade of Lights has submitted a
motorcade site map for review by the SERT members.
•The City of Boulder’s Boulder Business Recovery Program (BBRP) has helped
over 100 Boulder businesses reopen this summer.
This program was created by the city in response to the COVID-19 pandemic
with the intent to support community health and safety while reopening local
businesses. This program streamlined the process for businesses to expand
outdoors while reopening under the state’s Safer at Home order.
The City of Boulder is extending the end date of the BBRP from Sept. 30 to Oct.
31, including the:
o Current street closures along Pearl Street and at the Event Street on
University Hill
o Re-routing of the HOP Bus to Walnut Street in sections of the downtown
core
o Designation of existing curbside pick-up locations
o Temporary waiver of the minimum parking requirement for businesses
citywide
•The Randolph Center garage has reopened as of September 1, 2020. Structural
reinforcements, sealant on the upper decks and new striping are among the
improvements.
DMC Consent Agenda
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 6
•AMPS Implementation work has begun on a Parking Pricing Strategy and the
Neighborhood Parking Permit Program Revitalization. Commissioners Shapins
and Nuzum will soon be receiving invites to participate in bi-monthly (every two
months) project meetings. Regular updates will be included in Commission
meetings through July 2021.
•The Customer Service team is actively reaching out to wait list applicants to offer
permits that have recently become available. Additionally, we have made good
headway on auditing garage/lot permit wait lists, which has positioned the team
well to get permits to those who need them going forward.
B.Parks and Recreation Update
•Tulip giveaway this year was distributed by downtown businesses. Parks staff
delivered the bulbs and are awaiting feedback from DBP.
•Parks is preparing for tulip bulb planting in October followed by winter pansies for
added color.
•Parks staff have been informing PD of the PETA-themed graffiti artist on the
advertising kiosks and hopefully this criminal action will be addressed soon.
•Parks staff continue to work with multiple departments on encampment cleanups
throughout the parks system and the city.
•The Pearl Street Mall truck is being outfitted with a new snow plow to better
assist in plowing efforts, we have all of our snow routes covered for this winter.
DMC Consent Agenda
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 7
2020 Downtown Mall Area Police Calls
2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020
Assault 1 5 4 6 1 5 2 4 7 5 4 5 4 4 7 7 2 4 3 2
Auto Theft
Burglary 1 2 2 3 2 1
Crim. Mischief 1 4 5 4 4 3 4 5 2 3 4 8 7 8 5 7 9 8 6 6
Crim. Tres.2 4 1 1 4 4 2 5 1 1 2
Disturbance 15 25 19 34 16 23 19 20 20 31 34 24 16 33 41 22 26 34 31 24
Domestic 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 5 1 2 1 2 2 4 3
Drunk 4 12 9 6 5 1 10 4 9 4 8 4 5 5 4 7 3 3 9 8
DUI 4 2 2 4 1 3 1 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 4 1 1
Hang Ups 10 6 9 13 6 3 4 1 4 5 8 4 6 1 3 3 2 3 4
Harassment 5 7 5 6 6 3 6 3 15 7 9 7 10 12 7 17 15 12 8 5
Indec. Exp.3 2 1 1 3 1 1
Liq. Law Vio.2 1 3 1 5 2 1 1 1 2 1
Littering
Loitering 7 16 6 10 3 16 4 11 7 16 6 11 8 10 6 20 16 15 11 12
Menacing 1 1 2 1 1 1 1
Narcotics 5 5 1 4 3 1 2 2 3 3 5 4 4 3 8 3 6 3 2 1
Noise
Open Door 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2
Party
Prowler 1 1 1
Robbery 2 1 1
Sex Assault 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1
Shoplifting
Shots
Stabbing
Suicide
Suspicious 4 5 2 3 1 4 8 3 4 3 1 1 4 4 7 3 4 4 3 1
Theft 17 16 23 21 14 10 15 6 17 2 10 14 15 15 32 14 27 27 19 17
Trespass
Weapon
DecemberJanuaryFebruaryMarchAprilMayJuneJulyAugustSeptemberOctoberNovember
Mall Area Crime Statistics – July and August 2020
09.08.20 DMC Packet Page 8