Item 4 - Statistical Report for March 2020Historic Preservation Reviews
Between March 01, 2020 and March 31, 2020
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 1 of 8
This report shows all historic preservation cases on which the application was approved, denied or withdrawn within the stated date range.
Landmark Alteration Certificate Reviews Case Count : 15
HIS2019-00203 10 CHAUTAUQUA PARK Individual Landmark
Alteration review to excavate for a new basement with new exterior staircase, replacement doors and windows, replacement siding, and replacement of existing
exterior stairs and landing. Cottage built in 1920.
Decision : Application Approved by City Council Date : 03/20/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2019-00277 1127 12th ST Individual Landmark
[Withdrawn] Construction of addition linking two pending landmarks. LDRC referred application HIS2019-00184 to the full Landmarks Board for review 6.19.2019
(application withdrawn at meeting). Reapplied as HIS209-00277. Reviewed by the Landmarks Board on Nov 6, 2019. Application withdrawn at meeting.
Decision : Application Withdrawn Date : 03/02/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00042 2621 5TH ST Individual Landmark
Proposed construction of an attached two car garage. Refer to HIS2020-00014 for proposed deck stair. See HIS2020-00026 for window and siding replacement
and the construction of a dormer and expansion of a door opening on the west side, approved by the LDRC 1.15.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Landmarks Board Date : 03/09/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00057 1021 PEARL ST Downtown
[Approved] LAC issued for installation of externally lit (34" x 24") sign, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate application dated 02.19.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/02/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00059 1421 SPRUCE ST Individual Landmark
[Approved] LAC issued for rehabilitation of doors to include refinishing, staining and lacquering the exterior of three original entrances (6 doors and casings), to
historic condition.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/02/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00066 827 MAXWELL AVE Individual Landmark
[Approved] LAC issued for the installation of ductless mini-split air source heat pump to exterior of building, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate
application dated 02.24.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/02/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 2 of 8
Landmark Alteration Certificate Reviews Case Count : 15
HIS2020-00071 705 MAXWELL AVE Individual Landmark
LAC issued for the construction of 8'x10' storage shed in back yard as detailed on landmark alteration certificate application dated 02.27.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by LDRC Date : 03/12/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00072 2014 8TH ST Individual Landmark
{Approved] LAC issued for replacement of roof with "Legacy Malarkey Weathered Wood" asphalt shingle and replacement of damaged bubble skylight with flat
panel, low-profile sky-light as detailed on landmark alteration certificate plans dated 03.02.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/02/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00073 934 PEARL ST Individual Landmark
LAC issued for the reroof of building with Owens Corning Duration in Onyx Black asphalt shingle, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate dated 03.03.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/12/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00076 970 AURORA AVE Individual Landmark
LAC issued for the addition of roof cover above existing refuse enclosure and replacement of existing access doors, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate
application dated 03.04.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/12/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00079 1109 PINE ST Mapleton Hill
LAC issued for replacement of side gate with iron gate, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate application dated 03.05.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/12/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00089 900 BASELINE RD Chautauqua Park
LAC issued for the temporary placement of four portalets near the Ranger Cottage to help offset the heavy traffic using the permanent bathrooms during the busy
season at Chautauqua, as detailed on landmark alteration certificate application dated 03.10.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/20/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00093 900 BASELINE RD Individual Landmark
LAC issued for the reconstruction of the playground at Chautauqua Park, as detailed on landmark alteration application dated 03.12.2020 and reviewed by the
Landmarks Board 03.18.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by LDRC Date : 03/18/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
HIS2020-00097 808 CHAUTAUQUA PARK Chautauqua Park
LAC issued for removal and replacement of stone column at northeast corner of house, using existing stone and mortar to match physical properties, color, and
texture of historic; shore building with micropiles and add exposed steel posts painted to match color or adjacent screening, as detailed on landmark alteration
certificate application dated 03.13.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/24/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 3 of 8
Landmark Alteration Certificate Reviews Case Count : 15
HIS2020-00098 35 KINNIKINIC RD Chautauqua Park
LAC issued for the selective repair and/or replacement of deteriorated siding on west wall of non-contributing porch - material and paint color to be matched, as
detailed on landmark alteration certificate application dated 03.13.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/24/2020 Case Manager : James Hewat
Non-Designated Accessory Demolition Reviews Case Count : 1
HIS2020-00100 1835 COLUMBINE AVE Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of an accessory building constructed in 1947. Approval expires 9.26.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/30/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
Non-Designated Post-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Reviews Case Count : 10
HIS2020-00074 1831 NORWOOD AVE Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of a house and accessory building constructed in 1954. Previously approved HIS2014-00208 and HIS2019-00014. Current approval
expires 9.5.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/09/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00083 1409 NORTH ST Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of house and accessory building constructed in 1952. Approval expires 9.5.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/09/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00086 1254 BEAR MOUNTAIN CT Non-Designated
Partial demolition (removal of a portion of a street-facing wall - siding replacement) of a building constructed in 1970 proposed. Building not eligible for
designation; full demolition approved. Approval expires 9.5.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/09/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00087 1575 KENDALL DR Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition (removal of more than 50% of the roof; removal of more than 50% of the exterior walls) of a building constructed in 1967 proposed.
Full demolition approved. Approval expires 9.12.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/16/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00088 333 18TH ST Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition (removal of more than 50% of the roof; removal of more than 50% of the exterior walls; removal of a portion of a street-facing wall) of
a building constructed in 1956 proposed. Full demolition approved. Approval expires 9.12.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/16/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 4 of 8
Non-Designated Post-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Reviews Case Count : 10
HIS2020-00092 3655 CATALPA WAY Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition (removal of more than 50% of the roof) of a building constructed in 1963 proposed. Full demolition approved. Approval expires
9.12.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/16/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00094 1801 REDWOOD AVE Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of a house constructed in 1978. Previously approved HIS2016-00042. Approval expires 9.12.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/16/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00095 3033 9TH ST Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of a house constructed in 1950. Approval expires 9.13.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/17/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00099 1205 GEORGETOWN RD Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition (removal of a street-facing wall) of a building constructed in 1963 proposed. Building not potentially eligible for designation; full
demolition approved. Approval expires 9.13.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/17/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00101 1285 HARTFORD DR Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of a house constructed in 1963. Approval expires 9.27.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by Staff Date : 03/31/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
Non-Designated Pre-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Reviews Case Count : 3
HIS2020-00067 3076 9TH ST Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition [removal of stucco and replacement with Hardieboard lap siding on a street-facing wall) of a house constructed in 1894 and added
onto in 1997 proposed. LDRC determined building is not potentially eligible for landmark designation due to the extent of alterations and approved full demolition
of house. Approval expires 9.2.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by LDRC Date : 03/06/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00080 851 15TH ST Non-Designated
[Approved] Partial demolition (removal of a portion of a street-facing wall and extending addition south) of a building constructed in 1921. LDRC determined
building is potentially eligible for landmark designation but that the proposed scope of demolition would not be detrimental to the building's historic character.
Partial demolition approved as shown on plans dated 3.5.2020. If scope of demolition changes, a new application is required. Approval expires 9.7.2020.
Decision : Application Approved by LDRC Date : 03/11/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
HIS2020-00091 1111 CEDAR AVE Non-Designated
[Approved] Full demolition of two buildings constructed in 1925. A third building (garage) previously approved under HIS2019-00294. LDRC determined buildings
not potentially eligible for landmark designation. Approval expires 9.14.2020 and cannot be extended.
Decision : Application Approved by LDRC Date : 03/20/2020 Case Manager : Marcy Cameron
Historic Preservation Reviews Summary
Between March 01, 2020 and March 31, 2020
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 5 of 8
This summary shows all historic preservation cases on which the application was approved, denied or withdrawn within the stated date range.
The cases listed "In Review" have not yet been resolved and are not shown in relation to the start and end dates. The report shows all cases with the status of
"In Review" at the time of report creation.
Individual Landmark Designation
Application Closed (Approved, Denied or Void) 1
In Review 13
Landmark Alteration Certificate
Application Approved 2
Application Withdrawn 1
Application Closed (Approved, Denied or Void) 19
In Review 40
Non-Designated Accessory Demolition
Application Closed (Approved, Denied or Void) 1
In Review 1
Non-Designated Post-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation
Application Closed (Approved, Denied or Void) 10
In Review 2
Non-Designated Pre-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation
Application Closed (Approved, Denied or Void) 3
In Review 8
State Tax Credit
In Review 17
Historic Preservation "In Review" Case List
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 6 of 8
This is a detailed list of Historic Preservation cases that are, as of the date this report was run 04/03/2020, in a "In Review" status (have not yet been resolved).
The list shows all "In Review" cases irrespective of the date range entered when running this report.
Individual Landmark Designation Count : 13
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2015-00086 1300 CANYON BLJames Hewat 04/06/2015
HIS2017-00115 96 ARAPAHOE AVMarcy Cameron 04/17/2017
HIS2017-00114 90 ARAPAHOE AVMarcy Cameron 04/17/2017
HIS2019-00038 1836 PEARL STMarcy Cameron 02/01/2019
HIS2019-00186 311 MAPLETON AVEMarcy Cameron 06/11/2019
HIS2019-00190 1127 12TH STMarcy Cameron 06/13/2019
HIS2019-00191 1139 12TH STMarcy Cameron 06/13/2019
HIS2019-00227 891 12TH STMarcy Cameron 07/19/2019
HIS2019-00297 601 KALMIA AVEMarcy Cameron 10/01/2019
HIS2019-00306 2440 KOHLER DRMarcy Cameron 10/11/2019
HIS2019-00384 2124 PINE STMarcy Cameron 12/27/2019
HIS2020-00009 1770 13TH STMarcy Cameron 01/08/2020
HIS2020-00062 2962 11TH STMarcy Cameron 02/21/2020
Landmark Alteration Certificate Count : 40
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2018-00069 90 ARAPAHOE AVMarcy Cameron 03/16/2018
HIS2018-00221 970 AURORA AVEJames Hewat 07/25/2018
HIS2018-00258 1015 PINE STJames Hewat 08/29/2018
HIS2018-00349 2443 6TH STJames Hewat 11/08/2018
HIS2018-00368 541 SPRUCE STJames Hewat 11/29/2018
HIS2018-00374 1590 HILLSIDE RDJames Hewat 12/06/2018
HIS2018-00377 711 MAPLETON AVEJames Hewat 12/10/2018
HIS2018-00394 432 CONCORD AVEJames Hewat 12/21/2018
HIS2019-00039 1015 PINE STJames Hewat 02/01/2019
HIS2019-00046 920 MAPLETON AVEJames Hewat 02/20/2019
HIS2019-00101 15 S 35TH STJames Hewat 04/11/2019
HIS2019-00131 612 SPRUCE STJames Hewat 04/30/2019
HIS2019-00133 2366 JUNCTION PLJames Hewat 04/30/2019
HIS2019-00169 844 14TH STJames Hewat 05/31/2019
HIS2019-00208 705 MAPLETON AVEJames Hewat 06/26/2019
HIS2019-00232 2242 16TH STJames Hewat 07/24/2019
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 7 of 8
Landmark Alteration Certificate Count : 40
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2019-00256 876 14TH STJames Hewat 08/26/2019
HIS2019-00263 2029 5TH STJames Hewat 08/29/2019
HIS2019-00279 1207 PEARL STJames Hewat 09/10/2019
HIS2019-00296 745 PINE STJames Hewat 09/30/2019
HIS2019-00329 707 12TH STJames Hewat 11/06/2019
HIS2019-00330 1207 PEARL STJames Hewat 11/06/2019
HIS2019-00355 1044 MAXWELL AVEJames Hewat 11/25/2019
HIS2019-00371 623 MAXWELL AVEJames Hewat 12/11/2019
HIS2019-00374 2130 11TH STJames Hewat 12/13/2019
HIS2019-00375 745 PINE STJames Hewat 12/16/2019
HIS2020-00028 2124 PINE STJames Hewat 01/17/2020
HIS2020-00053 891 12TH STJames Hewat 02/14/2020
HIS2020-00058 956 16TH STJames Hewat 02/20/2020
HIS2020-00063 428 CONCORD AVEJames Hewat 02/21/2020
HIS2020-00061 1207 AURORA AVEJames Hewat 02/21/2020
HIS2020-00075 734 MAXWELL AVEJames Hewat 03/03/2020
HIS2020-00078 1044 MAXWELL AVEJames Hewat 03/04/2020
HIS2020-00077 1139 12TH STJames Hewat 03/04/2020
HIS2020-00082 630 PINE STJames Hewat 03/05/2020
HIS2020-00085 420 PINE STJames Hewat 03/06/2020
HIS2020-00090 745 PINE STJames Hewat 03/10/2020
HIS2020-00102 845 14TH STJames Hewat 03/31/2020
HIS2020-00103 1833 19TH STJames Hewat 04/02/2020
HIS2020-00104 2436 4TH STJames Hewat 04/02/2020
Non-Designated Accessory Demolition Count : 1
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2016-00323 861 GRANT PLMarcy Cameron 10/12/2016
Non-Designated Post-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Count : 2
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2019-00089 420 S 44TH STJames Hewat 04/03/2019
HIS2019-00272 1390 ITHACA DRJames Hewat 09/05/2019
Non-Designated Pre-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Count : 8
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
Printed on 04/03/2020
Page 8 of 8
Non-Designated Pre-1940 Demo/Off Site Relocation Count : 8
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2019-00238 2250 BLUEBELL AVEMarcy Cameron 07/30/2019
HIS2019-00251 1741 WALNUT STMarcy Cameron 08/15/2019
HIS2019-00289 3236 9TH STMarcy Cameron 09/24/2019
HIS2019-00317 380 ARAPAHOE AVEMarcy Cameron 10/23/2019
HIS2019-00340 2124 PINE STMarcy Cameron 11/12/2019
HIS2019-00361 1149 12TH STMarcy Cameron 12/05/2019
HIS2019-00379 2659 DAKOTA PLMarcy Cameron 12/20/2019
HIS2020-00065 2037 MAPLETON AVEMarcy Cameron 02/24/2020
State Tax Credit Count : 17
CASE NUMBER ADDRESSDATE RECEIVEDCASE MANAGER
HIS2014-00147 427 PINE STJames Hewat 05/13/2014
HIS2014-00327 2303 MAPLETON AVJames Hewat 10/22/2014
HIS2015-00012 3015 KALMIA AVJames Hewat 01/16/2015
HIS2015-00048 2133 9TH STJames Hewat 02/20/2015
HIS2015-00089 1919 14TH STJames Hewat 04/10/2015
HIS2015-00310 601 CHAUTAUQUA PARKJames Hewat 11/12/2015
HIS2016-00077 520 MARINE STJames Hewat 03/24/2016
HIS2016-00345 1403 BASELINE RDJames Hewat 10/28/2016
HIS2016-00398 1622 9TH STJames Hewat 12/28/2016
HIS2017-00032 1630 9TH STJames Hewat 01/31/2017
HIS2017-00058 911 PINE STJames Hewat 02/17/2017
HIS2018-00029 646 PEARL STJames Hewat 02/02/2018
HIS2018-00070 1507 PINE STJames Hewat 03/16/2018
HIS2018-00386 110 CHAUTAUQUA PARKJames Hewat 12/17/2018
HIS2019-00114 12 CHAUTAUQUA PARKJames Hewat 04/19/2019
HIS2019-00338 1017 MAXWELL AVEJames Hewat 11/12/2019
HIS2020-00002 844 14TH STJames Hewat 01/02/2020