HomeMy WebLinkAbout12.04.19 LB Minutes CITY OF BOULDER
LANDMARKS BOARD MEETING
ACTION MINUTES
December 4,2019 at 6:00 p.m.
1777 Broadway, Municipal Building, Council Chambers
The following are the action minutes of the December 4, 2019 City of Boulder Landmarks Board meeting.
A digital recording and a permanent set of these minutes (maintained for a period of seven years) are
retained in Central Records at 303-441-3043. You may also listen to the recording on-line at
www.boulderhistoricpreservation.net.
BOARD MEMBERS:
Abby Daniels, acting Vice Chair-present
John Decker, acting Chair- present
William Jellick- present
Fran Sheets, Chair- absent
Ronnie Pelusio -present
Sarah Silver, Planning Board representative without a vote- present
STAFF MEMBERS:
Lucas Markley, Assistant City Attorney II- present
James Hewat, Senior Historic Preservation Planner-present
Marcy Cameron, Historic Preservation Planner II- present
Michelle Mikoni, Historic Preservation Intern -present
Clare Brandt, Administrative Specialist-present
1. CALL TO ORDER[00:00.00 audio minutes]
The roll having been called,acting Chair J.Decker declared a quorum at 6:03 p.m. and the following
business was conducted.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES[00:00.14 audio minutes]
On a motion by W.Jellick, seconded by R.Pelusio, the Landmarks Board approved(4-0,F.Sheets
absent) the minutes from the November 6, 2019 Landmarks Board meetings.
3. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION FOR NON-PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS [00:00.56 audio minutes]
1. Kathryn Barth Asked the Landmarks Board to consider requesting that the Landmarks
294020 th St. Board meetings be televised.
80304
4. DISCUSSION OF LANDMARK ALTERATION AND DEMOLITION APPLICATIONS
ISSUED AND PENDING[00:02.43 audio minutes]
• Statistical Report for November
• 2250 Bluebell Ave. —Stay-of-Demolition expires Feb. 15, 2019
On a motion by R.Pelusio, seconded by W.Jellick, the Landmarks Board agreed (4-0,F.
Sheets absent) to hold a hearing at the next scheduled Landmarks Board meeting to consider
lifting the stay-of-demolition placed on the demolition application for the buildings at 2250
Bluebell Ave.
5. PUBLIC HEARING [00:15.04 audio minutes]
A. [00:15.37 audio minutes]Public hearing and consideration of an application to designate the
property at 891 12th St. as an individual landmark, pursuant to Section 9-11-5 of the Boulder
Revised Code 1981 (HIS2019-00227). Owner: 891 12th Street LLC/Applicant: Historic Boulder,
Inc.
Ex Parte Contacts
A. Daniels: none
J. Decker: none
W. Jellick: none
F. Sheets: absent
R. Pelusio: none
Staff Presentation
M. Cameron presented the case recommending individual landmark designation of the property.
Owner's Presentation
John Kirkland, owner and developer of 891 12th Street, LLC, expressed his opposition to
landmark designation of the property as the building is not threatened by demolition or significant
change. He related there has been a lack of communication between city staff and the seller/buyer
of the property but that his own interests align with those of the Landmarks Board, in that he has
full intention of preserving the historic character of the property.
Applicant's Presentation
Jamie Boyle, Interim Executive Director of Historic Boulder presented a letter from Cheri Belz
stating that Historic Boulder supports the designation of 819 12th St., stating that landmarking the
property would help maintain the architectural integrity as well as provide the opportunity to take
advantage of tax incentives to offset rehabilitation costs.
Public Comment
1. Sue-Ellen Harrison Spoke in favor of landmarking 819 12th St., stating that the
84012 1h St. property clearly meets the criteria for designation
80302
2. Jim Scarboro Pooling time with Ann Scarboro. Stated that landmarking of
735 12th Street 819 12th St. would help clearly establish guidelines for moving
80302 forward with development of the property.
3. Doug Burdin Spoke in support of staff's recommendation to landmark the
87012 th Street property.
80302
4. Jay Madtson Spoke in favor of landmarking 819 12th St., stating that it is a
1101 Aurora Ave culturally important building.
80302
5. Leslie Hays Spoke in opposition to landmarking 819 12th St. as a result of
6500 Arapahoe Ave recent negative events associated with the property.
80303
6. Ginger Wolff Supported Mr. Kirkland's intentions of preserving the property
3005 Vh St. and spoke against landmarking 819 12th St.
80301
7. Waylon Lewis Expressed sympathy about the negative events associated with
838 University Ave property but that 819 12th St. is historically important. Stated
80302 that if the owners's intentions of preserving the historic quality
of the property are true, the landmark designation of 819 12th
St. should not pose an issue.
8. Stephen van der Mersch Pooling time with Joe Stepaneck, David Rodriguez, Stacy
90712 Ih Street Silverstein. Expressed support for the designation of the
80302 property and discussed the quality of historic stewardship
exhibited by Mr. Kirkland.
9. Lisa Spalding Spoke in favor of landmarking 819 12th St., quoting the benefits
1135 Jay Street of local landmarking from the National Trust from Historic
80302 Preservation.
10. Jyotsna Raj Spoke in favor of landmarking 819 12th St., stating that the
86314 th Street architecture it reflects the history of the university and it is
80302 important presence on University Hill.
11. Rob O'Dea Spoke against designation over the owner's objection against
891 12th Street the will of a private property owner.
80302
12. Steve Kelton Spoke in favor of landmarking 819 12th St. to preserve the
80012 Ih St. exterior of the property.
80302
13. Anna Schissler Recited a letter from Justin Rezzonico, a longtime resident of
Marpa House. The letter expressed opposition against
landmarking 891 12th St. stating that the designation would give
recognition to a corrupt organization.
Motion
On a motion by R.Pelusio, seconded by W.Jellick,the Landmarks Board voted(4-0,F. Sheets
absent), to recommend to the City Council that it approve the application to designate property at
891 12th St. as a local landmark, to be known as the SAE-ZBT-Marpa House,finding that it meets
the standards for individual landmark designation in Sections 9-11-1 and 9-11-2, B.R.C. 1981, and
adopt the staff memorandum dated Dec. 4, 2019, as the findings of the board.
[Break]
B. [02:02.52 audio minutes]Public hearing and consideration of a proposal to construct a patio
enclosure at the Boulder Jaycees Train Depot at 2366 Junction Place, an individual landmark,
pursuant to Section 9-11-18 B.R.C. 1981 (HIS2019-00133). Owner: City of Boulder/Applicant:
Depot Square Owners Association LLC and John Matthews, M.A. Architects
Staff Presentation
J. Hewat read a letter from the applicant,John Matthews, MA Architects requesting to withdraw
the application and to work with the Landmark Design Review Committee.
Motion
None. Application withdrawn by applicant.
6. MATTERS [02:05.00 audio minutes]
• Update Memo
- Council adoption of the 2019 Historic Preservation Plan
- Chautauqua Sustainability &Resilience Strategy
• Annual letter to City Council
7. DEBRIEF MEETING/CALENDAR CHECK
8. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 09:23 p.m.
Approved on , 2019
Respectfully 1m^itted,
d , Chairperson