Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2.26.2018 WRAB Packet - Agenda 4-5 Background Materials for Engagement Discussion
1 CITY OF BOULDER CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: Nov. 21, 2017 AGENDA TITLE: Consideration of a motion to accept City of Boulder’s Engagement Strategic Framework, near-term action items and proposed measures of progress PRESENTER/S Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager Tanya Ange, Deputy City Manager Patrick von Keyserling, Director of Communications Sarah Huntley, Engagement Manager Jean Gatza, Senior Planner, Planning, Housing and Sustainability Members of the Engagement Framework Team EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The City of Boulder has long recognized that good public processes and engagement play important roles in making local government both effective and responsive to the community it serves. Over the years, the city has assigned individuals within specific departments to the task of engaging with the public. While some of these efforts have involved engagement in its broadest sense, like building relationships with community members, most opportunities have been designed around specific policy decisions or program development. There have been numerous successes, as well as efforts that have not met the expectations of the community and the decision-makers relying upon its input. In January 2016, recognizing that there was room for improvement, City Council decided to involve the community in assessing the city’s work to date and recommending ways to 2 enhance engagement. It appointed a 14-member Public Participation Working Group, supported by one council member and two city employees. The group met more than 30 times over 18 months, and in August 2017, presented a comprehensive report to City Council. Building on that process, a 10-member interdepartmental staff team was assembled to create the framework that council is being asked to consider and adopt. The proposed framework is available as Attachment A. This framework is intended to guide staff’s work, help to clarify the city’s intentions and systems so residents and other impacted individuals know what to expect, and assist other organizations that might be working to cultivate good engagement and/or public participation. The framework includes sections that explain Why, How, What, Who and Results. QUESTIONS FOR COUNCIL: 1. Does council agree that the Engagement Strategic Framework is a good way to build on the recommendations of the Public Participation Working Group and guide efforts to enhance engagement between the City of Boulder and the community moving forward? 2. Do the near-term action items in this memo reflect council’s engagement-related priorities for 2018? 3. Does council have feedback about the proposed measures of progress? STAFF RECOMMENDATION Suggested Motion Language: Staff requests council consideration of this matter and action in the form of the following motion: Motion to accept the City of Boulder’s Engagement Strategic Framework, near-term action items and proposed measures of progress COMMUNITY SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENTS AND IMPACTS • Economic – There are no direct impacts to the business community or city revenues from this work; however, the business community is likely to be among the impacted individuals or groups that benefit from enhanced engagement. • Environmental – There are no direct impacts to environmental resources or sustainability from this work. • Social – Inclusive community engagement improves decision-making and outcomes for Boulder. The framework will help Boulder be a more effectively engaged community, including diverse communities and those typically non- engaged, and will help to improve relations with neighborhood and community groups. 3 OTHER IMPACTS • Fiscal – City Council approved two positions and a non-personnel budget of $50,000 to support enhanced engagement work as part of the 2018 budget. Other resources in support of the framework and effective engagement will come from existing departmental or project budgets. • Staff time – This is being incorporated into 2018 work plans. BACKGROUND The Engagement Strategic Framework reflects two years of community, staff and council feedback and direction. At the request of City Council, the Participation Working Group (working group) was formed by City Manager Jane Brautigam in September 2016. For nearly a year, the working group reviewed the city’s public engagement process to recommend ways Boulder might improve civic engagement processes to foster success for both the city (council, boards, staff) and community members. The working group’s final report is available on the 31TUproject website.U31T The report includes analysis, core values and guiding principles, as well as two overarching recommendations for improving the ways the city and Boulder community members interact. The working group presented information and discussed the report with City Council at a 31TStudy Session on Aug. 28, 201731T. The council discussed priority areas and asked staff to come back with an implementation framework. While the working group report provides a strong foundation for the Engagement Strategic Framework, staff also considered input from other sources. These included council feedback; community and staff feedback about recent processes; information from internal initiatives such as customer experience and coordination and streamlining of volunteer service throughout the city; and International Association of Public Participation (IAP2) principles and methodology. HIGHLIGHTED COMPONENTS OF PROPOSED FRAMEWORK The following sections highlight components that address specific feedback council shared at its Aug. 28, 2017 study session. A. Staffing/Resources The City of Boulder’s enhanced engagement approach will require creativity and a commitment to continuous learning from the whole organization. To start implementation of the engagement framework, the effort will be housed under the City Manager’s Office. As mentioned above, the 2018 budget included two dedicated resources: an engagement manager and an engagement specialist. The framework details the key responsibilities of these positions. In short, these two positions will 4 serve as centralized coordinators, strategists and consultants to the rest of the organization. Due to the volume of engagement and the existing valuable expertise within many city departments, this effort will be highly collaborative. Engagement on most city projects will remain the responsibility of department-based project teams, some of which include staff members who conduct engagement and outreach as a part of their core job duties. They will be guided and supported more consistently, however, by the engagement manager and specialist, as well as the neighborhood and community liaisons, who have relationships and work areas that complement this framework. In addition, the existing internal Engagement Coordination Committee, which started in early 2017, will be leveraged. This committee includes at least one representative from every department with external interactions. These employees have been instrumental in supporting new ideas and change within the organization, including the successful “What’s Up Boulder” informational event held on Oct. 11, 2017. In 2018 and beyond, members of this group will be asked to allocate five to eight hours a month, as part of their workplan, to support the citywide engagement effort to enhance. More information about the Engagement Coordination Committee can be found in the framework. B. An Approach Rooted in Best Practices As part of the working group report, it was recommended that the city adopt a nine- step process to support good public engagement. This process, in the form of a wheel, is illustrated in the framework. The city plans to use this wheel as a core component of its work moving forward. In addition to this, the city will draw heavily from well-established philosophies and practices advocated and taught by the International Association of Public Participation. IAP2 was founded in 1990 and emphasizes the importance of program design and goals identification for developing effective and meaningful public participation. IAP2 views public participation as any process that involves the public in problem-solving or decision-making and uses public input to make decisions. Public participation includes all aspects of identifying problems and opportunities, developing alternatives and making decisions. It uses tools and techniques that are common to a variety of well-accepted dispute resolution and communications fields. IAP2 lays out practical guidance and adaptable materials for identifying problems and opportunities, developing alternatives and making decisions. It uses skills, knowledge and processes common to other fields that require interactions with people, such as public relations, communications, and mediation. One of the most compelling features of this system is its five-step process for planning for engagement. These steps build consistency and compel the process designer to develop a practice of 1) gaining internal commitment, 2) assessing impacted individuals and groups and their corresponding perceptions, 3) selecting an appropriate level(s) of engagement, 4) 5 defining the decision process and engagement objective(s), and 5) designing an engagement plan. Another key component of the IAP2 structure is a spectrum of participation that assists with the selection of appropriately scaled participation. The spectrum shows that differing levels of participation based on the goals, timeframes, resources, and levels of concern in the decision to be made. It also defines “the promise” being made to the community at each level. In 2016, a core group of approximately 25 city staff received IAP2 Planning and Techniques training. Some departments have begun to implement components of this training and system with success. For example, staff overseeing the Prairie Dog Working Group process implemented many of the steps noted above. As an outcome of this application, a clear and credible process is being followed, and relationships between stakeholders and staff remain respectful and productive. There is solid alignment between the working group’s Core Principles and Values of 6 Good Public Engagement and 31TIAP2's Code of Ethics and Core Values31T. Additionally, IAP2 provides an established, tested set of practices that other governments, some in our region as well as those around the world, are leveraging. This means Boulder can readily access trainers, facilitators and a network of related practitioners. Attachment B includes a summary of a few Colorado cities and government entities located elsewhere that are using core principles and practices of IAP2. C. Objective and Six Strategies for Success The Public Participation Working Group made two core recommendations: change the culture of engagement in Boulder and implement/utilize a comprehensive decision-making process (the nine-step wheel). While the group provided some suggestions for action items that support these recommendations, it also recognized the importance of the city organization taking ownership of a path forward. The proposed framework has one over-arching objective: To adopt and sustain a culture and practice of meaningful civic engagement in the City of Boulder to achieve outcomes that reflect our community’s concerns, aspirations and shared values. Six strategies for success have been identified to support this: 1. Learn together. Build skills and a shared understanding of core principles, practices and processes associated with high-quality engagement. 2. Help people know what to expect. Implement consistent processes to support the creation and use of effective and appropriately-scaled engagement plans. Communicate clearly about opportunities for timely and meaningful public input and engagement. Follow set meeting schedules as much as possible. Define roles. 3. Cultivate respectful relationships. Enhance existing relationships with those affected by city decisions and programs through positive and constructive dialogue. Pilot new approaches to invite and encourage all impacted individuals and groups to participate in ways that are welcoming and comfortable to them. 4. Be transparent. Develop and implement techniques that increase transparency into decision- making and democratic processes. Help everyone understand constraints and the variety of perspectives on any given issue and explain how the feedback received during a process shaped the outcome. 5. Use the right tools. Assess our current and existing engagement tools and techniques and choose those that most effectively allow us to reach desired audiences. Recognize the 7 value of a mix of digital platforms, printed materials and in-person methods. 6. Evaluate and evolve. Demonstrate a commitment to innovation and continuous improvement through honest evaluation of clearly defined metrics as well as ongoing creativity in the pursuit of new ideas. Make Boulder an international model of meaningful participation. These strategies will be key as specific workplan items are proposed and evaluated. They will also serve as valuable touchstones as the organization, and City Council, seeks to assess whether the organization’s work is effective in enhancing engagement. D. Key Workplan Items The proposed framework outlines some of the near-term areas of work aligned with the objective and strategies. This information is detailed further in Attachment C. The following is additional information about key areas of work council suggested previously as high priorities. a. Pilot Projects Several key projects were discussed as potential opportunities to pilot the nine- step engagement wheel proposed by the working group. As pilots, the following projects listed below will have the engagement manager or specialist and/or skilled members of the Engagement Coordination Committee assigned to the project team for ongoing partnership throughout their process. Alpine-Balsam Area Plan The Alpine-Balsam Area Plan will be a high-profile project with a range of engagement opportunities throughout 2018. It will be conducted in coordination with all the Central Broadway Planning efforts (i.e. Civic Area East Bookend planning and the City Facilities Assessment). The area plan will help ensure redevelopment is consistent with a clear community vision and all necessary public improvements will be in place to support the changes to that area. Pre-engagement planning has identified several engagement objectives that are important to community members and will be of particular focus as engagement planning moves forward. These include: • Demonstrate a clear decision-making process and engagement opportunities • Articulate a clear rationale for decisions that inform each phase, as well as the final plan 8 • Invite a broad range of impacted groups (both those in close proximity to the site and citywide) and seek a diversity of opinions in both in-person and online engagement • Communicate how decisions nest within other plans and projects (from the Alpine-Balsam Vision Plan, BVCP policies, master plans, and relationship with Central Broadway projects) Draft engagement plans for the Alpine-Balsam Area Plan (and other Central Broadway projects) will be shared with the community, advisory boards and City Council in the next few months. Accessory Dwelling Unit Code Changes (ADUs) The process to revise regulations pertaining to Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) is underway and is expected to conclude in the second quarter of 2018. Building on previous feedback from the community in multiple projects over the past few years (ADU Study 2012, Housing Boulder, BVCP Update), the intent of the project is to bring forward incremental changes to city regulations that better allow accessory units while still addressing potential neighborhood impacts. Engagement planning has identified several objectives including: • Ensure the project scope, schedule, engagement opportunities and decision-making processes are clear and understandable • Provide background information in advance to facilitate meaningful participation • Be clear about how the public’s input influences analysis and potential code changes • Commit to transparency around options and decision-making The draft engagement plan includes many opportunities for individuals and interested groups to be consulted on the purpose and goals of the project that will inform additional consultation of a discussion draft, analysis and a final list of recommended changes. Open Space and Mountain Parks (OSMP) Master Plan The Open Space and Mountain Parks Master Plan will be a high-profile project with a range of engagement opportunities throughout 2018 and 2019. The master plan will establish an integrated, strategic approach to OSMP management over the next decade and beyond. Pre-engagement planning has identified several engagement objectives that are important to community members and will be of particular focus as engagement planning moves forward. These include: 9 • Demonstrating a clear decision-making process and windows of engagement that are planned and communicated (as well as periods with less engagement when staff and the consultant are focusing on analysis and drafting options to then be shared with those impacted) • Engaging where people are/already gather An OSMP master plan process subcommittee will actively inform the engagement plan and ongoing process. Community Broadband and Fire-Rescue Master Plan Two other projects, Community Broadband and the Fire-Rescue Master Plan, are likely to be treated as pilots as well, although engagement planning for these is not as far along as for the other pilots. Additional information about these will be included in a First Quarter 2018 update to council. b. Enhancing Digital Assets City Council and the working group have provided valuable feedback about some challenges posed by the city’s existing online engagement and communication resources. One of the strategies in this framework – Use the Right Tools – recognizes the importance of making improvements in this area. Related efforts either underway or planned for 2018 include: • City Website Refresh The 2018 budget includes funding to refresh the city website with a focus on creating a navigation system that is more intuitive and helpful to the average Boulder user (with information organized around topics, for example, rather than by the city’s internal departmental structure). This work will be performed in conjunction with the Communications and Information Technology departments and will also include recommendations about some new design elements. This is important foundational work which will lead to a future website redesign. • Digital Engagement Platform The city has not had a digital engagement platform since the end of 2016 when the contract with MindMixer, the vendor supporting the city’s Inspire Boulder tool, was discontinued. Over the past 10 months, a city staff team has been evaluating possible replacement options. In late summer, the city issued an informal bid request, pursuant to purchasing guidelines, and received proposals from six vendors. Three have been identified as finalists. The goal is to select a vendor by the end of the year and implementation to being in early 2018, with an emphasis on the pilot engagement projects. 10 • Council Correspondence Process Improvements Both the council and the working group have expressed a desire to make community member emails sent to council more accessible to the public. While efforts have been taken to achieve this in recent months, there is room for improvement, both to the process by which the emails are collected and the technical elements of how they are shared. A staff committee that includes representatives from Information Technology, Communications and the City Manager’s Office (engagement and data/innovation) has been assembled to assess problem areas and develop possible solutions for future consideration by council. c. Civic Education/City 101 Program Development Both the working group and council have recognized more civic education could have value in driving engagement, as well as making input more meaningful and creating or reinforcing positive relationships. Under the umbrella of City 101, staff is working to develop modules to help the community understand, access and engage with city departments and processes. Because the application of these are likely in a variety of settings, it is anticipated that a few different approaches will be necessary. These approaches could include: • Boulder Bingo – a game-show inspired activity that can be layered into other engagement events illuminating information such as, but not limited to: o Facts and history of Boulder o Differences in city and county governance o City of Boulder mission, vision and values o City Council initiatives o Sample project timelines o Other information as determined by the accompanying event . • A CU-specific civic education effort, geared toward college students to help them understand how their local government works and how to engage in policy-making processes that could impact them during their time in Boulder • Video series – In collaboration with the Communication Department, city engagement staff will develop a series of short videos designed to educate community, such as: o The council/city manager form of government o The roles of boards and commissions 11 o How to participate at City Council or board/commission meetings o Applying to be a member of a board or commission o Explaining Boulder’s community engagement spectrum and how to get involved d. Training for Decision-Makers One of the key responsibilities of the engagement manager and specialist will be to develop, in consultation with the Engagement Coordination Committee, other colleagues throughout the organization and outside practitioners, the necessary training and supporting materials to build capacity and a shared understanding of what makes engagement effective. It is anticipated that there will be a variety of training modules for city staff, for community members, and for key decision-makers. IAP2 strongly recommends that those tasked with making the decisions be well versed in the principles and the vocabulary of effective engagement. In best-case scenarios, decision-makers are consulted as engagement plans are being developed and asked what type of information they will need from the public and where on the engagement spectrum they feel the effort should fall. These sessions are typically facilitated by a non-staff member. City staff is planning to work with IAP2 to refine its existing course for decision-makers to see if it can be condensed from four hours to two hours, to more realistically accommodate council members’ schedules. Additional details, including a scheduling request, will be provided as they become available. Council has already recognized that it is not the only decision-maker or influencer in Boulder’s current governance structure. Boards and commissions play an important role as policies and programs are being developed and evaluated. In 2018, city staff plans to work with boards and commissions to better define their roles in engagement. It is important to note current boards and commissions perform a variety of functions, and some are better positioned than others to interact with community members in more creative ways than public hearings. (Quasi-judicial boards, for example, may have more of a challenge with this). As this re-evaluation of roles is conducted, staff will ensure that boards and commissions are oriented to the strategies and best practices of engagement the city is implementing. Additional training for some boards and commissions, similar to the training council receives, may be made available in late 2018 or early 2019. e. Civil Discourse Guidelines Earlier this month, city staff took a first step toward implementation by acting upon one of the working group’s more specific recommendations: Set clear expectations for a new culture of engagement by co-developing guidelines for 12 civil and constructive conduct in meetings, dialogue, and decision-making processes. In conjunction with independent facilitators, the city hosted a community workshop on Nov. 13 to begin the process of developing shared guidelines. After evaluation of this method, additional workshops will follow with a goal of engaging 300 diverse participants. The resulting collective work will be shared with the community at large under the consult spectrum level to gain feedback before finalizing and enacting the guidelines. City staff will provide an update on progress in a First Quarter 2018 report. f. Town Halls At council’s Aug. 28, 2017 Study Session, generally all councilmembers expressed an interest in testing Town Hall-type events as an engagement tool to: • Offer a venue for community members to have meaningful two-way conversations with councilmembers before issues get polarized; and • Hear from people other than those who usually come to meetings. Council appointed a subcommittee to work on developing specific workplan items related to this goal. The subcommittee members are Suzanne Jones, Jan Burton and Aaron Brockett. The subcommittee has not yet met. As part of the engagement workplan, staff is proposing that it develop some key objectives, possible dates and session formats to pilot two in-person Town Hall meetings and one virtual meeting, either utilizing Facebook Live and/or telephone town hall technology in 2018. Staff would then consult with the council subcommittee for feedback and appropriate revisions to the plan. Once the subcommittee is comfortable with the proposal, details will be shared with council as a whole. E. Measurement and Evaluation Staff has created a set of outcomes, outputs and methods of measurement, matched to the six strategies defined above, to evaluate work through the end of 2018. A chart outlining these in detail is available as Attachment D. As the working group noted, culture change takes time and it is important to manage expectations about how much progress can be made in one to three years. With this in mind, staff also developed three proposed metrics that will not be used: • Existence of continued disagreement or dissatisfaction with outcomes, especially for more controversial issues While it is reasonable to assume that general relations between the city 13 and the Boulder community will improve through this program, there will continue to be a variety of viewpoints about specific policy decisions and outcomes in Boulder. This diversity of thought is an important part of any democracy. When the city measures its progress, it will look at levels of process satisfaction rather than outcome satisfaction. There may be some individuals who find it difficult to distinguish between the two, but city staff will do its best to provide clear data about its processes and its success or failure at achieving the best practice goals that have been set. • Amount of engagement or percentage of projects that fall into categories of Involve or Collaborate The City of Boulder already conducts a high volume of engagement and public processes. This framework is not intended to increase these efforts just to achieve more “points.” In fact, if done in a more coordinated and strategic way, it is likely there could be “less’ engagement. The engagement that occurs, however, will be more targeted and meaningful for decision-makers, staff and community participants. Nor will any value be placed as to where projects fall on the engagement spectrum. Some projects are appropriate in Inform or Consult, while others require more of an Involve and Collaborate approach, either in their entirety, or during some phases or with individuals who might be especially impacted. Through strategic discussions and planning, the city will endeavor to answer the question: “What is the appropriate level of engagement given the desired objectives?” • Length of time it takes to complete engagement plan The city’s decision-making process may appear to have additional steps, leading some to conclude that engagement processes will inherently take more time. This is not necessarily the case, and the length of time for a process will not be considered a “badge of honor.” Instead, the city will utilize early steps in the process, like clearly defining its why statements and including all impacted individuals, so there is clarity throughout the remaining parts of the process. This is expected to lead to efficiencies. At the same time, it is important to understand that good engagement takes time. Part of the planning process will include close coordination with larger project teams and decision-makers to ensure that those projects that need more time are scheduled appropriately. NEXT STEPS AND UPDATE SCHEDULE If the framework is approved, staff will move forward with implementation, with an initial focus on action items and areas of work prioritized for Fourth Quarter 2017. 14 Staff will present an update to council, in the form of an Information Packet memo, in the First Quarter of 2018. It will include, at a minimum, the following information: • A comprehensive list of citywide projects/initiatives/programs that will likely require some level of engagement with the community in 2018 • More information about the five pilots, with particular emphasis on those council has not already had a chance to discuss and consider • A status update and next steps related to the creation by community members of civil discourse guidelines • Additional information about town hall recommendations that have been prepared by staff and vetted by the three council subcommittee members ATTACHMENTS Attachment A: Proposed Engagement Strategic Framework Attachment B: Summary information from other IAP2-based communities Attachment C: Work areas chart, categorized by strategy and timeframe Attachment D: Metrics chart, categorized by strategy Attachment A: Proposed Engagement Strategic Framework City of Boulder ENGAGEMENT STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK Proposal to Boulder City Council Nov. 21, 2017 What is engagement? What is public participation? Public participation is a type of engagement that usually occurs in decision-making processes. It can define minimum standards, such as public hearings, comment periods and open records. It also can indicate a range of public involvement approaches from informing to partnering and collaboration. The City of Boulder recognizes that good public processes and engagement play important roles in making local government both effective and responsive to the community it serves. In previous years, the city has assigned individuals within specific departments to planning and facilitating engagement opportunities with the community. Most public processes in Boulder have been designed around specific policy decisions or program development. There have been numerous successes, as well as efforts that have not met the expectations of the community and the decision-makers relying upon its input. In January 2016, Boulder City Council recognized improvements were needed in how the city engages, informs and includes the public. Council directed staff to involve the community in developing recommendatios to enhance engagement. This led to the creation of a 14-member Public Participation Working Group, which was supported by one council member and two city employees. The group met more than 30 times over 18 months. This working group presented a comprehensive report to City Council in August 2017. This can be found at www. bouldercolorado.gov/city-council/public-par- ticipation-working-group. The report identified what the group called problem statements, defined five core principles of ‘best in class’ engagement and made a series of recommendations for improvement. While the report provided additional details and strategic counsel, the group landed on two over-arching recommendations: change the culture of public engagement and utilize a comprehensive decision-making process. WHY An active, expansive relationship between the city and the community that includes any level of public participation; this typically encourages two-way dialogue. FRAMEWORK GUIDE: Section 1: WHY Explains the purpose of this framework and the city’s engagement mission Section 2: HOW Outlines the strategic objectives and the timeline of the activities to meet those objectives Section 3: WHAT Describes engagement methods and best practices to follow when pursuing engagement efforts Section 4: WHO Lists the city employees and groups who will collaborate to enhance engagement efforts Section 5: RESULTS Demonstrates the process the city will follow to measure progress p. 2 p. 4 p. 8 p. 12 p. 14 What is public participation?CORE PRINCIPLES & VALUES The problem is clearly defined. Public engagement is thoughtfully planned. All voices are encouraged and included. Public contribution and civil participation are fostered. The process is trustworthy and transparent. IDENTIFYING WHAT GOOD ENGAGEMENT IS City Council supported the working group’s findings and provided some additional input at a study session on Aug. 28, 2017. Based on this, city staff developed a plan to implement the recommendations and introduce a more comprehensive, consistent and strategic approach to civic engagement in Boulder. The result is this Engagement Strategic Framework. This document incorporates valuable contributions and specific recommendations made by the working group. It also draws upon the experiences and expertise of staff and best practices that are supported by an organization recognized globally for its commitment to meaningful engagement. That organization is the International Association of Public Participation (IAP2). This framework is intended to guide staff’s work, help to clarify the city’s intentions and systems so residents and other impacted individuals know what to expect, and support other organizations working to cultivate good engagement and/or public participation. It starts here – with this “why” statement: The City of Boulder is working to improve its engagement culture and processes because it recognizes that local government makes better decisions and creates more responsive programs and services when the community it serves has a meaningful voice. The best engagement is appropriately scaled, consistent and reliable, inclusive and respectful of all participants. This framework represents the City of Boulder’s commitment to building on the lessons of its past by creating engagement opportunities that support high performance and the industry’s gold standard, while also encouraging the innovation and creativity that are hallmarks of our community. 3 HOW The Public Participation Working Group made two core recommendations: change the culture of engagement in Boulder and implement/utilize a clear decision-making process. While the group provided some suggestions for action items that support these recommendations, it also recognized the importance of the city organization taking ownership of a path forward. This framework is designed to achieve the following objective: To sustain a culture and practice of meaningful civic engagement in the City of Boulder to achieve outcomes that reflect our community’s concerns, aspirations and shared values. Six strategies were identified to support this. These will serve as important touchstones for evaluating possible work plan items and progress. WE ARE STRATEGIC To adopt and sustain a culture and practice of meaningful civic engagement in the City of Boulder to achieve outcomes that reflect our community’s concerns, aspirations and shared values. SIX STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESS LEARN TOGETHER Build skills and a shared understanding of core principles, practices and processes associated with high-quality community engagement. HELP PEOPLE KNOW WHAT TO EXPECT Implement consistent processes to support the creation and use of effective and appropriately-scaled engagement plans. Communicate clearly about opportunities for timely and meaningful public input and engagement. Follow set meeting schedules as much as possible. Define roles. CULTIVATE RESPECTFUL RELATIONSHIPS Enhance existing relationships with those affected by city decisions and programs through positive and constructive dialogue. Pilot new approaches to invite and encourage all impacted individuals and groups to participate in ways that are welcoming and comfortable to them. BE TRANSPARENT Develop and implement techniques that increase transparency into decision-making and democratic processes. Help everyone understand constraints and the variety of perspectives on any given issue and explain how the feedback received during a process shaped the outcome. USE THE RIGHT TOOLS Assess our current and existing engagement tools and techniques and choose those that most effectively allow us to reach desired audiences. Recognize the value of a mix of digital platforms, printed materials and in-person methods. EVALUATE AND EVOLVE Demonstrate a commitment to innovation and continuous improvement through honest evaluation of clearly defined metrics as well as ongoing creativity in the pursuit of new ideas. Make Boulder an international model of meaningful participation. Boulder’s Engagement Strategic Framework 5 WHAT IAP2 PRINCIPLES & BEST PRACTICES SERVE AS A GUIDE The International Association for Public Participation (IAP2) was founded in 1990 and emphasizes the importance of identifying clear goals and designing programs that support effective and meaningful public participation. IAP2 views public participation as any process that involves the public in problem-solving or decision-making and uses public input to make decisions. Public participation includes all aspects of identifying problems and opportunities, developing alternatives and making decisions. It uses tools and techniques that are common to a number of dispute resolution and communications fields. IAP2 lays out practical guidance and adaptable materials to support organizations that are committed to best practices methodology and learning. One of the hallmark offerings of IAP2 is a tried and tested five-step process for creating strategic engagement plans. These steps build consistency and compel the process designer to develop a practice of 1) gaining internal commitment, 2) assessing impacted individuals and groups and their corresponding perceptions, 3) selecting an appropriate level(s) of engagement, 4) defining the decision-making process and engagement objective(s), and 5) designing an engagement plan. In 2016, a core group of about 25 city staff members received IAP2 Planning and Techniques training. Several departments have begun to implement components of this system and have already experienced successful relationship-building outcomes. “I am excited to build on the city’s history of engagement and public participation with new ideas and strategies. There’s a lot to be achieved by helping those of us on staff and community members know what our standards are and what they can expect.” Brenda Ritenour, Boulder’s neighborhood liaison As an example, staff overseeing the Prairie Dog Working Group process in 2016 and 2017 began implementing many of the IAP2 steps as part of its efforts. As an outcome of this application, a clear and credible process is being followed, and relationships between stakeholders and staff remain respectful and productive. The staff team preparing for the 2018 Open Space and Mountain Parks Master Plan update is also working hard to develop its engagement plan around these best practices, making it much easier for community members to see when key points of engagement will occur. There is solid alignment between the Core Principles outlined on page 3 of this framework and IAP2’s Code of Ethics and Core Values. Additionally, IAP2 provides an established set of practices that other governments, some in our region as well as others around the world, are leveraging. This means Boulder can readily access trainers, facilitators and a network of skilled practitioners. Our community can both learn from — and contribute to — this body of work. To provide the public with balanced and objective information to assist them in understanding a problem, alternatives, opportunities and/or solutions. To obtain public feedback on public analysis, alternatives and/or decisions. To work directly with the public throughout a process to ensure that public concerns and aspirations are consistently understood and considered. To partner with the public in each aspect of the decision including the development of alternatives and identification of a preferred solution. We will keep you informed.We will keep you informed, listen to and acknowledge your concerns and aspirations, and share feedback on how public input influenced the decision. We will seek your feedback on drafts and proposals. We will work with you to ensure that your concerns and aspirations are reflected in any alternatives and share feedback on how the public input influenced the decision. We will work together with you to formulate solutions and to incorporate your advice and recommendations into the decisions to the maximum extent possible. INFORM CONSULT INVOLVE COLLABORATE PARTICIPATION GOALPROMISE TO THE PUBLICAdApted from ©IAp2 InternAtIonAl federAtIon 2014. INCREASING IMPACT ON THE DECISION Putting IAP2 Into Practice BOULDER’S ENGAGEMENT SPECTRUM 7 The city will follow a modified version of IAP2’s engagement spectrum to help identify the role of the community in project planning and decision-making processes. USING A DEFINED NINE-STEP PROCESS Developed by the Public Participation Working Group and supported by city staff, the city will implement a nine-step decision-making process that is structured to be comprehensive, scalable and easy to follow for both city staff and community members. Staff will enact and follow these steps for identified projects, solidifying consistency in engagement across the city. This structure will give community members the ability to participate in decision-making processes in a more informed and predictable way, and in closer partnership with city staff and decision-makers. STEP 1 Define the issue before embarking STEP 2 Determine who is affected STEP 3 Create a public engagement plan STEP 4 Share a foundation of information and inquiry STEP 5 Identify options STEP 6 Evaluate issues STEP 7 Make a decision STEP 8 Communicate decision & rationale STEP 9 Reflect & evaluate 9 STEPS TO GOOD ENGAGEMENT 9 LEARN TOGETHER 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 Create base materials to explain IAP2 principles, spectrum and new city processes Survey and choose five to six pilots to test the nine-step engagement wheel Develop a civic education program Understand engagement best practices for high-conflict issues Create and share full toolkit of handouts, templates and cheat sheets Launch pilot projects Implement civic education program Train leadership team and council members Train Engagement Coordination Committee Assess and address areas of additional learning and innovation Start community conversation about civil discourse guidelines Gather follow-up feedback from recent Perceptions Assessment on Boulder as an inclusive and welcoming community Develop and ratify civil discourse guidelines Study and begin to develop more culturally sensitive engagement processes Explore partnerships with ambassadors to underrepresented groups In-person town hall concept development and pilots Further gaps assessment to identify those who are not participating and why Quality of life and engagement study for a group not typically involved in city issues CULTIVATE RESPECTFUL RELATIONSHIPS 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 HELP PEOPLE KNOW WHAT TO EXPECT 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 Create and present framework to council for feedback Define roles and write charter for Engagement Coordination Committee Digital depiction of decision-making timelines and engagement opportunities Re-evaluate role of boards and commissions in engagement and plan appropriate training to support this Educate community members about city’s new approach, the levels of engagement and the promise that accompanies each Create an empirical resource estimate tool NEAR-TERM ACTION ITEMS As is standard practice, the city will create annual work plans that prioritize tasks and techniques to support the six engagement strategies defined in this framework. The following pages offer a sneak peak at a few key near-term action items that are anticipated within the first 36 months of implementation. Establish format for, and culture of, debriefs after engagement efforts Define base outputs for pilot projects and other engagement efforts Creation of initial metrics for overall engagement program Creation and use of ongoing surveys to evaluate engagement satisfaction and performance Re-evaluate strategies and work focus areas based on what has been learned EVALUATE & EVOLVE 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 Creation and use of consistent feedback reports, including “if not, why not” explanations Process improvements to how community members contact council and how this correspondence is shared with the public Creation of an online resource that shows how council members vote on specific topics Explore innovative approaches other cities and organizations are using to increase transparency through video, websites and other communication platforms BE TRANSPARENT 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 11 Assess responses to RFP and select digital engagement platform Develop consistent questions that help evaluate process, rather than outcome, satisfaction Share toolkits and engagement approach online with public Implement digital engagement platform, work processes and strategic understanding of best uses Explore telephone town hall technology and best practices Web refresh/new navigation approach (in partnership with IT and Communication) Explore FB Live Q and A sessions with council members and key staff Assess companion digital engagement tools Develop clear project process guidelines for subcommittees Establish consistent criteria for working group participation USE THE RIGHT TOOLS 2017 (4TH QUARTER) 2018 2019 WHO The city has created two dedicated positions — an engagement manager and an engagement specialist — with the responsibility of improving and strengthening the culture of civic engagement. This team’s success will require a balance of leadership, increased coordination, thoughtful prioritization, shared learning and collaboration with fellow city employees and with the Boulder community. In collaboration with others, these individuals will support effective engagement by: ENGAGEMENT RESOURCE TEAM Promoting innovation in the design of engagement opportunities and tools; ensuring that community members receive feedback about how their input is used Identifying potential pilot projects; assisting project teams to identify an appropriate level of engagement and related techniques Coaching and consulting with departmental project teams as they create and implement effective engagement plans Creating and maintaining training programs and tool kits to support decision-makers, internal staff and community members Expanding the city’s engagement commitment beyond a project- specific focus to more general relationship-building and listening Identifying opportunities to include more voices in city processes and developing approaches that make all feel welcome and invited to participate Serving as skilled facilitators for select projects – and deepening the bench of trained facilitators across the organization Creating a vision for success in the short- and longer-term as well as processes that support continual evaluation and learning Networking and cultivating positive relationships with other public participation practitioners, key stakeholders and community influencers ENGAGEMENT COORDINATION COMMITTEE This is an existing committee of approximately 25 members from a cross-section of city departments. These employees share an interest in improving engagement in the organization and community. This committee will continue as a core element of this framework. Under the guidance of the engagement manager, members will allocate five to eight hours a month to tasks that contribute to the city’s integrated engagement efforts. Possible areas of contribution include: Researching best practices and recommending potential new strategies and innovative ideas Brainstorming process improvements to increase communication and shared learning Serving as liaisons between the engagement team and their departments Planning and facilitating integrated and strategic engagement events Assisting in the creation of effective training programs and toolkit materials Serving as peer support for other work groups as they develop more meaningful and inclusive engagement plans Helping to evaluate the program, consistent with agreed upon metrics Several city departments have designated employees who plan and conduct outreach for specific projects or work groups. These individuals will continue to be responsible for outreach and engagement efforts assigned to them. Because the individuals in the two centralized positions cannot design, conduct and evaluate every engagement effort the city is planning in any given year, these department partners will coordinate with the engagement resource team to strategize activities, aiming for consistent engagement across the city. Department-level engagement staff members bring a tremendous amount of expertise, often have existing relationships and channels of communication. Furthermore, the budgets for their outreach and engagement work come from their departments, so they should be making the decisions about how these resources are spent. ENGAGEMENT & OUTREACH STAF F IN DEPARTMENTS The city employs two liaisons — one who works with residents and neighborhoods and another who works with the University of Colorado as well as other local institutions and groups — to identify potential partnerships, maintain positive relationships and resolve issues. Another employee is working with city departments to enhance the experiences of volunteers who engage with local government by donating their skills and time. These work areas support engagement in its broadest sense and are designed to have a positive impact on city and community interactions of all kinds. Each of these employees also have some work plan items that specifically support this framework’s six strategy areas. NEIGHBORHOOD & COMMUNITY LIAISONS All hands on deck! 13 RESULTS STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES SUCCESS OUTCOMES HOW OUTCOMES WILL BE MEASURED Learn together The city achieves a high level of staff, decision-maker and community clarity around engagement levels/promise to the public. End of class surveys for all students Help people know what to expect The city communicates clearly with the community about levels and processes of engagement, resulting in increased understanding and satisfaction by those who choose to participate. Survey of community members with a consistent set of process-related questions Cultivate respectful relationships The city has made comprehensive stakeholder assessment part of its routine engagement planning process. It also has gained an increased understanding of its inclusivity gaps and has developed strategies for addressing them. Development of baseline data through demographic analysis, identification of relationships that need nurturing, barri- ers, and observations about tone and tenor of participation in correspondence and in meetings Be transparent The city consistently demonstrates the connection between feedback/input and criteria and decisions. It improves access to council correspondence and council member voting information, modeling transparency around key decisions. Survey of community members with a consistent set of transparency questions Use the right tools The city offers a more diverse array of easy-to-use options for individuals to learn about processes and programs, give input and see how that input is used. It balances in-person and online engagement opportunities to meet diverse needs. Online analytics tracking number of visits and bounce rate to site/platform, survey of community members with consistent set of questions about venue choice and design of sessions Evaluate and evolve Evaluating effectiveness of work during and after processes has become standard practice in the city, and this information is consistently shared with the public. Analysis of process improvements, compilation of evaluations and existence of 2019 strategies based on assessment MEASURING THE CITY’S PROGRESS To ensure that the strategies are making a positive difference and the city’s efforts are having a meaningful impact, staff has identified a set of measurable and informational indicators for the first year of implementation. The following desired outcomes will be evaluated based on the methods outlined below. RESULTS FACTORS THAT WILL NOT BE CONSIDERED Culture change takes time, and the Public Participation Working Group advised the city to be transparent and clear about expectations and any limitations. In keeping with this, staff has identified three proposed indicators that will not be a part of its ongoing evaluation. Existence of continued disagreement or dissatisfaction with outcomes, especially for more controversial issues While it is expected that general relations between the city and the Boulder community will improve through this program, there will continue to be a wide variety of viewpoints about specific policy decisions and outcomes in Boulder. This diversity of thought is an important part of any democracy. When the city measures its progress, it will look at levels of process satisfaction rather than outcome satisfaction. Amount of engagement or percentage of projects that fall into categories of Involve or Collaborate The City of Boulder already conducts a high volume of engagement and public processes. This framework is not intended to increase these efforts just to achieve more “points.” In fact, if done in a more coordinated and strategic way, it is likely there could be “less’ engagement — but the engagement that occurs will be more targeted and meaningful for decision-makers, staff and community participants. No value will be placed as to where projects fall on the city’s engagement level chart (see page 9). Some projects are appropriate at levels of Inform or Consult, while others require more of an Involve and Collaborate approach, either in their entirety, or during some phases, or with individuals who might be especially impacted. Through strategic planning, the city will endeavor to answer the question: “What is the appropriate level of engagement given the desired objectives?” Length of time it takes to complete engagement plan The city’s decision-making process may appear to have additional steps, leading some to conclude that quality engagement will inherently take more time. This is not necessarily the case, and the length of time for a process will not be considered a “badge of honor.” Instead, the city will utilize early steps in the process, like clearly defining its why statements and including all impacted individuals, so there is clarity throughout the remaining parts of the process. This is expected to lead to efficiencies. At the same time, it is important to understand that for some projects, especially those that are more complex, it will be important to build in an adequate and realistic timeline to engage the community in a meaningful way. 15 For more information, please contact: Sarah Huntley Engagement Manager City of Boulder huntleys@bouldercolorado.gov 720-564-2111 Printed on 100% recycled paper Attachment B: Examples of other cities or governmental agencies using IAP2 principles and practices in their community engagement work Fort Collins, Colorado: Intention and goal: “The City of Fort Collins places a high value on the involvement and engagement of our citizens . . . The city has a variety of avenues that residents use for requests, inquiries, complaints and input. This flow of information is most effective when it works both ways and is fostered at each step. Our processes need to provide opportunities for citizens to take part in the conversation, to learn, and to work with others, not just provide inputs. They are an extension of our efforts and should take part as collaborative problem solvers.” Approach: The City of Fort Collins serves as a convener seeking to address the growing public desire for a meaningful role in decision-making, expand connections with hard-to-reach populations and explore and test new technologies to enhance public engagement efforts, such as Telephone Town Halls, online engagement platforms and translation equipment for use at public meetings. Resources: The city has a civic engagement liaison who supports and helps direct citywide public engagement efforts. Some of the methods of support include employee training based on the International Association for Public Participation (IAP2) curriculum, online engagement tools and technology. The city has created a useful Public Engagement Guide for employees to help ensure quality and consistency across its organization. Longmont, Colorado: Intention and goal: The City of Longmont’s community involvement process invites residents, elected officials and individuals from public agencies, private enterprise, nonprofit organizations and voluntary associations to come together to think collectively and act cooperatively to identify issues and to find solutions to them. The City believes that building relationships between City officials and community members is an important part of community involvement so that all partners share responsibility for sustaining solutions that are developed and implemented. Approach: In 2001, a staff committee, with community and City Council input, created a community involvement approach for the City of Longmont. This approach formalized the process for how the city determines what types of community involvement will be most effective and how to achieve involvement that is meaningful and productive for our entire community. A plan was developed to recognize and build upon the community involvement efforts that staff was already using, while creating new opportunities and approaches based on the work of the International Association of Public Participation (IAP2) and the Jefferson Center. The city's approach is to provide resources and training to community members. The City of Longmont has developed a framework of varying levels for involving the community. They range from simply distributing information to listening to residents’ ideas for, and opinions on, specific projects, to forming partnerships with individuals and organizations. Resources: The City of Longmont has developed online resources and a training manual for city staff and community members; a centralized team provides ongoing training to both staff and community and leverages a larger staff engagement team to provide consulting and support to city departments in their engagement efforts. Austin, Texas: Intention and goal: The City of Austin community engagement program strives to take into consideration the needs of the community and facilitate meaningful conversations between city officials and the community. Collaboration and diversity of thought are key ingredients to a successful engagement so it is important to find pockets of the community that usually are not part of the decision-making process and look for creative ways to bring them into the process. Approach: Austin espouses several core values in its engagement efforts: • Accountability and Transparency - enable the public to participate in decision- making processes by providing clear information on the issues, the ways to participate, and how their participation contributes to the decision. • Fairness & Respect - maintain a safe environment that cultivates and supports respectful public engagement and will expect participants to do so in turn. • Accessibility - respect and encourage participation by providing ample public notice of opportunities and resources and accommodations that enable all to participate. • Predictability & Consistency - prepare the public to participate by providing meeting agendas, discussion guidelines, notes, and information on next steps. • Creativity & Community Collaboration - use innovative, proven, and customized engagement solutions that are appropriate to the needs of the projects and the participants. • Stewards of Resources - balance its commitment to provide ample opportunities for public involvement with its commitment to delivering government services efficiently and using city resources wisely. Resources: The city has an engagement manager and an engagement specialist who focuses largely on strategies that support inclusivity and multicultural audience participation. They are both members of the Communication Department. These individuals work directly with department- and project-level staff in a consulting role. They also leverage a variety of tools accessible to the community including social media, SpeakUpAustin.org, and online surveys to make collaboration easy, relevant and worthwhile. San Francisco Municipal Transportation Authority: Intention and goal: The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Authority (SFMTA) recently declared a meaningful commitment to public outreach and engagement on all SFMTA projects that affect customers and its broader community. The agency’s goals for public outreach and engagement are to: • Build trust and relationships by better managing public and stakeholder expectations • Create a consistent model for public outreach and engagement that can be leveraged across all divisions • Identify and delivery useful tools and resources to support public outreach and engagement Approach: The agency created a Public Outreach and Engagement Team (POET) Strategy, as well as Public Outreach Notification Standards that set consistent minimums for engaging with the public for all SFMTA projects. The team educates other colleagues about the benefits of utilizing best practices in engagement and strives for innovation and inclusivity in all its processes. A key aspect of the agency’s approach is to recognize and reward individuals throughout the organization who are implementing good engagement techniques. The agency offers training for interested employees, who can receive certification at three levels of engagement expertise depending on the completion of coursework and implementation of practices. Resources: The agency has a POEM (Public Outreach and Engagement Manager) who coordinates the overall efforts and consults with project teams as they develop their engagement plans. The manager receives some support from a group of about 50 other colleagues in the agency who have participated in the coordinated training and recognition program. Calgary, Canada: Intention and goal: The City of Calgary recognizes that decisions are improved by engaging citizens and stakeholders in a purposeful dialogue to gather information to influence decision making. Approach: The city adopted an engagement policy, which is intended to apply to engagement in specific planning, policy, and project initiatives that directly or indirectly impact citizens and stakeholders. The policy incorporates the following five principles for guiding engagement initiatives: • Accountability – The city upholds the commitments it makes to citizens and stakeholders and demonstrates that results and outcomes of the engagement processes are consistent with the approved plans for engagement. • Inclusiveness – The city makes its best efforts to reach, involve and hear from those who are impacted directly or indirectly. • Transparency – The city provides clear, timely and complete information, and endeavors to ensure decision processes, procedures and constraints are understood and followed. • Commitment – The city, within its ability and work plans, allocates sufficient resources for effective engagement. • Responsiveness – The city of Calgary endeavors to understand citizen and stakeholder claims. When the city embarks on an engagement process, the purpose and promise is clarified at the beginning and at a minimum includes Inform-level communication tasks. Resources: The city has an Engage Resource Unit of staff that will work with a project’s manager and communications staff to assess the engagement need and develop and implement an appropriate plan and report back on what was heard and how the input will be used. Online resources include dedicated engagement webpage featuring current projects from all departments seeking community feedback. Attachment D: How the City Will Measure Its Progress Proposed metrics for Year One work (4Q 2017 through 2018) Learn together Help people know what to expect Cultivate respectful relationships Be transparent Use the right tools Evaluate and evolve Success Outcomes The city achieves a high level of staff, decision- maker and community clarity around engagement levels/promise to the public. Knowledge about engagement best practices is showing signs of being applied. The city communicates clearly with the community about levels and processes of engagement, resulting in increased understanding and satisfaction by those who choose to participate. The city has made comprehensive stakeholder assessment part of its routine engagement planning process. The city has gained an increased understanding of its inclusivity gaps and has developed strategies for addressing them. The city consistently demonstrates the connection between feedback/input and criteria and decision. The city improves access to council correspondence and member voting information, modeling transparency around key decisions. The city offers a more diverse array of easy- to-use options for individuals to learn about processes and programs, give input and see how that input is used. The city balances in- person and online engagement opportunities to meet diverse needs. Evaluating effectiveness of work during and after processes is standard practice in the city, and this information is consistently shared with the public. Base-Level Outputs Number of classes: • At least three for city staff; at least one for decision-makers; at least two for community members Reach: • A minimum of 200 people attended a training by the end of first full year of program implementation. Use of spectrum: • Every city engagement effort planned chooses a level on the spectrum Use of project timelines: • All decision-making processes in the city create and share timelines that show phases, with clear indicators of when input will be requested and meaningful. Engagement planning: • 50 percent of all work groups conducting engagement in the city create and implement an engagement plan Demographics: • Every city survey collects consistent demographics and a yearly analysis is done to see who is/isn’t participating Identify “ambassadors” • City holds discussions about engagement and current barriers with potential population liaisons Discourse guidelines • City facilitates a successful process to co-create guidelines for civil discourse with the community Stakeholder analysis: • Fifty percent of all efforts conduct comprehensive stakeholder analysis Feedback loops: • The city establishes a consistent system and format for reporting feedback and its impact Council email process: • City develops and implements council correspondence processes that address recent feedback and recog nize new expectations Website refresh: • Engagement team partners well with IT and Communication to remap website to be more user- oriented Digital platform: • City chooses and implements an online engagement platform Venue/session design: • Spaces for engagement events are appropriate and the session design/format achieves objectives Data collection • Quantitative and qualitative data is collected regularly Analysis: • City utilizes a debrief process at key milestones for all engagement processes How Outcomes Will Be Measured End of class surveys for all students Survey of community members, with consistent set of process-related questions Development of baseline data through demographic analysis Identification of relationships that need nurturing and barriers Observations about tone and tenor of participation in correspondence and in meetings Survey of community members, with consistent set of transparency questions Online analytics tracking number of visits to site/platform, as well as bounce rate Survey of community members with consistent set of questions about venue choice and design of sessions Analysis of process improvements, compilation of evaluations, existence of 2019 strategies based on assessment Factors that will not be a part of how the city evaluates its progress • Existence of continued disagreement or dissatisfaction with outcomes, especially for more controversial issues While it is reasonable to assume that general relations between the city and the Boulder community will improve through this program, there will continue to be a wide variety of viewpoints about specific policy decisions and outcomes in Boulder. This diversity of thought is an important part of any democracy. When the city measures its progress, it will look at levels of process satisfaction rather than outcome satisfaction. There may be some individuals who find it difficult to distinguish between the two, but city staff will do its best to provide clear data about its processes and its success or failure at achieving the best practice goals that have been set. • Amount of engagement or percentage of projects that fall into categories of Involve or Collaborate The City of Boulder already conducts a high volume of engagement and public processes. This framework is not intended to increase these efforts just to achieve more “points.” In fact, if done in a more coordinated and strategic way, it is likely there could be “less’ engagement – but the engagement that occurs will be more targeted and meaningful for decision-makers, staff and community participants. No value will be placed as to where projects fall on the city’s engagement level chart. Some projects are appropriate in Inform or Consult, while others require more of an Involve and Collaborate approach, either in their entirety, or during some phases or with individuals who might be especially impacted. Through strategic discussions and planning, the city will endeavor to answer the question: “What is the appropriate level of engagement given the desired objectives?” Length of time it takes to complete engagement plan The city’s decision-making process may appear to have additional steps, leading some to conclude that engagement processes will inherently take more time. This is not necessarily the case, and the length of time for a process will not be considered a “badge of honor.” Instead, the city will utilize early steps in the process, like clearly defining its why statements and including all impacted individuals, so there is clarity throughout the remaining parts of the process. This is expected to lead to efficiencies. At the same time, it is important to understand that for some projects, especially those that are more complex, it will be important to build in an adequate and realistic timeline to engage the community in a meaningful way.