The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About09.03.2003 LPAB MinutesCITY OF BOULDCR LANDMARICS PRESFRVATION ADVLSORY BOARll M[NUTES SeptcmUer 3, 2003 Councd Chnmbers Municipll Building 1777 B~ o~dwny 6 p.m. The followmg ~ie the nunutcs of the September 3, 2003, Crty ofBoulder Landmaiks Preservation Aclvtsoiy Board mectntg A percnancnt set oFthese mmutcs 1nd a tape iecoidmg (mamtamed foi a peuod of l yeais) is retamed m Central Rccords (tclepllone 303-441-3043) You may also listen to the mulutes via thc CUy of Bottlder websile ~t www c~ bouldei co ~is/plannmg/landmaiks/agendas/Septembcr 3_03 htm BOARD MEMBI:RS PRESI;NT: Lcslic Duigin, Vice-Chairperson, acrived 6 20 pm Ltsa Egger Lelaud Rttclcer Rory Salancq Chaupeison BOARD MCMBERS ABSEN'1': 1Cent SCutsman (excused) STAFF MEMBERS PRESF,N1': Suc Ellen Harrison, City ACtorney Bohdy Hcdgcock, Associate Planncr Ruth McHeyser, Long Range Plannmg Managei Matt Russell, Intern 1. CALL'COORDER The roll having been called, Chairperson R Salance dedared a quor~un at 6 OS p m and the following busuicss was couducted 2. APPROVAL OI' MINUTF,S The Uoud approved the mmLiles of the August 6, 2003 meeYmg, as amended. 3. REPORT ON I.ANDIVIARIC ALTERAT[ON AND DF,MOLITION PERMITS ISSU~ll AND PENDING. Theie weie no comments 4. CI'I'I7.F,N YARTICIPATION FOR 1TEMS NOT ON THF. AGENDA No one from the p~ibhc addi essed the boatd SVPI AMdataAlongrnngAIfIST\nnnut~~~Z00i-I I'AOmmutosV09-01-03acimn Ipabnun do~ 5. ACTION ITEMS A. Public hearing and consideration of a demolition pcrmit appl~catiun for the structure located at 1719 Mapleton Avenue, pu~suant to Sectimi 10-13-23 tor buildiugs over fifty years. Owner: Chris Dor1n. (Continucd from August 6, 2003 meeting) 73oard naerr~beis we~ e ashed to reveril c~ny ex-purte con~acts they may have hnd o~~ this item J R:ecke~ L L'e2e~ and R Snlance vesited the s~te Public Ilearing Seott and Susau Allman, 1720 Bluff, Bottlder, spoke tn opposihon Findings The butldmg proposcd foi demol~hon at 1719 Mapleton Avenue may have histoncal significance based on the followmg findings 1 The builcLng may be cl~gible for mdividual landmaik designation in that a) the Uuild~ng is a ielatively unaltcred exaniple of workmg-class, vernacular wood- fiame houses Found m Bouldei m the late 19th century, and b) the biuldmg is one of the oldest contnburing elements of the potential Whrthci Nattonal Rcgister Historic Dtstrict 2 The bmlding contubules to lhe charactci oFthe neighborhood, a potenhal Naliona] Registei Histonc Dtshict 3. The condrt~on of the b~nldmg and the estimated costs o( repatr aie not umcasonable MoYion On a motion Uy L Dui am, seconded by R. Salance, the Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board recominended (3-1, L EQeer dtssent~ng, K Slutsman excused absent) that C~ty Coimeil issue a stay of demolit~on foi the building located at 1719 Mapleton Avenue, foi a period nol to exceed 180 days fiom thc day the penmt applicahon was filed, adoptmg the staff memorandum wrth the findmgs hsted above, m ordei to fiirther explore alternativcs for the bLUldmg B. Public hearing and cm~sideration of a request to grant a Landmark Alteration CertiGc~te for cm~structimi of a re~r addition for the property at 445 Pine, within the Mapleton Hill Historic District. Owner: Greg Hansen Board members were asked to reveal any ex-parte contacts they may have had on this item L Ruckei, L F,e~er and R Salance reviewed the plans at a Landmaiks Pieservation Advisoiy Board Dcsign Review Commtltee mcettng Public Hearing T~m Pl~ss, (55 Maxwell, Boulder, spoke m oppos~tion Jim Zollet, 444 Highland, Boulder, spoke m opposit~on Alau P~elds, 436 Pme, Bouldei, spoke m suppott S\PL AN\d4ia\longrnng\I IIS I\~nmulcs\2007-I,PAflmmutes\09-03-03ncuon Ipebmin do~ l+mdiugz I '1'he proposcd reai ~iddilion is compahble with thc Histonc Picservahon OCCIIl1~lI1CC, m that it does not damage archrtectuial features ofthe hisYonc buildtug, does not adveisely affect U~e spec~al cl~aiactet of the disriict, and is compattble w~th the charactci of the district m tcrms of arcliitechiral style ~nd detailiug [t also geneially conforn~s to thc Mapleton Hill Design Guidclmes 2 The ptoposed fiont poich s~~pport brackets replace modeim Uuildmg elemcnts tllat ~ie mappioptiate with app~opr~atc oncs that arc more m 1<eepmg with tUe style of the lusto~ ic home 3 Thc pioposed flagstone patio meets the Mapleton Hill Design Guidelmes and ~s appropitate Motion On a mohon by L Dui~ui, seconded by L E~eei, the Landmarlcs Picservatton Acivisory Board recommended (3-1, L Ruckei dissenCmg K Stutsman excused absent) that C~ty Comlcil approve thc request fo~ a Landmark Alteralion Certificate for Yhe constitiiction of a rear add~tion, replacemcut of the extsting fiont porch support brackcts, and the construction of a ieai yaid flagstone patio, adopting the staff tnemoranclum with the as findiugs l~sted above, Uased upon plans and other inaterials submrtted wrih this apphcahon Any change fiom lhe current plans would requtre a Landmatk Alteration Ceirificate G. MATTERS FROM THF. I.ANDMARKS BOARD, PLANNING D~PARTMENT, AND CITY A'I'TORNFY • 2003/04 Work Program Update on ge~~eral code changes ielaled to the designahon piocess Update ou 429 Sprucc 7. DEI3RIEr M~~TING/CALENDAR CHF,CK 8. ADJOURNM~NT The meeting was ad~ourned at 7 51 p m Rcsp ctfully submitted, ~/~- ~ IIetdt Sli z wsla LPAB Secretaty Ap ved on October~, 2003 Rory Salance Chaupcrson SVPLANVdataAIm~giangAFIIS fAmmulcs\L00}-~ pq~)i»ii~utesV09-0}.p;n~lmn Ipnbmin doc