The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About07.02.2003 LPAB MinutesCITY OF BOULDI~'.R L,ANDMARI{S PRf.SERVATION ADVISORY BOARD M[NUTCS July 2, 2003 Council Cha~nbe~s M~niicipal I3uilding 1777 Bro~dw~y 6 p.m. The tollowmg are the mmutes of thc July 2, 2003, City of Bouldci Landmaiks Pieservation Advisoiy Board meeting A pcrmanent set of thcse muiutes and a tape iccoidmg (matntamed ior a pcriod of l years) ~s retamed ui Cent~ al Records (telephone 303-441-3043) You m~y a(so listen to thc mmutes via the City of Bouldei website at www ct Uoulder co us/plannmg/landmarl<s/agendas/J~ily_2_03 htm I30ARD MGMBF.RS PRESENT: Leshe Durgm, V~ce-Chan-person L,tsa rggci Lelaud Rucker Roiy Salance, Chaiiperson I~OARD MPMBERS ABSENT: Keut Stutsman (excused) S'1'AFF MEMBERS PRFSF.NT: Sue Ellen Harrison, City Attomey Bohdy FIedgcock, Associate Planuci Ruth MeHcyset, Long Range Plannmg Manager Matt Russell, Intern 1. CALL TO ORDER The roll havmg Ucen called, Chairperson R Salance declared a quorum at 6 04 p m aiid lhe followmg busmess was conducted 2. RF.PORT ON LANDMARK ALT~RATION AND llEMOLITION P~RMITS ISSUED ANll PENDING. 'Chete were no comments 3. APPROVAL OP MINUTF,S The board approvcd the ~mnutes of tbe June 4, 2003 meetmg 4. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA Kathryn Baith, 2940 20`~' Stieet, repiesentmg Histoiic Bouldei, lnc , said Historic Bouldet is mtciesled m purs~ung landmark designat~on for chgiblc schools m the Boulder Valley School District Histonc Bo~ilder iequested that histonc surveys be comple~ed for all tl~e schools m the d~stiict SVPlanAdataAlongi angVI IIS7 Ammulcs\2003-L PA13minutesV07-OZ-03acqon Iryabnun doc Geoi~e Walsie, 1825 Walnut, iequcsled the boaids' suppo~t m his effotl to have the sign at the entrance to the Whrttier Sotiith nctghboihood (and wrthm the Chlmbedam Histonc Distr~ct al 18« and Walnut) icstoted Staff waU cl~aft a lette~ of sup~ort for rtppi ovul by the board Claue Waltci, G30 Spiuce SCreet, distnbuted pllotos docmnenting the m~pact of excavat~on aud fill for a gaiage ad~acent to hei property Jan Otto, 960 Lincoln Place, encouraged llle board to conlmue revismg the H~storic Preseivatton Code He suggcsted that a stakeholder gtoup could begm meedng tn Scptembet 5. AC'CION [TEMS A. PubLc hearing ~nd consideration of a recommendntion to City Comuil concerning a request for individnal landmark status for the structures and site at 2045 Wahiut Street. Owner: Sue Mundinger Ruth McHcvset swo~ e m staff and membeis of lhe pubhc spcakiug to pubhc hea~ mg Uems on tomght's agenda Pablic Hearmg Kathrni Barth, 2929 20°i Street, icpiesentmg the ~pplicant, spoke m su~poit Yaul Sa onto spoke m sti~pport Board Motimi L Durgm made the followuig motton, seconded by L E~~er that Yhe Landmarks Preservahon Advisoiy Board recommended to Crty Co~mc~l that thc Uutldmgs and the~r stte located at 2045 Walnut be designated as an individual landmark under lhe c~ty of Bouldei's h~stoiic pieseivatia~ code, adoplmg the staCf inemoiandum detailmg the significancc cirteua as findmgs of the board TUe Laudmarl<s Prescrvation Advisory Board iecommended that lhe buildmgs be named the Gutfelder }Iouse and Mason Terrace Vote Thc Uoard vo[ed 4-0 to appiove the motton (Stutsman excused abscnt) B. Public hearing and consider~tion of ~ request to grant a I,andmark Alteration Certificate tor demolition of ~n existing detaciied two-car stnicture anct construction of a new, detached two-car garage for tlie property at 541 Maxwell, in the M~pleton Hill Historic District. Owner: Lisa Merrin Ruth McHe~ei swore m sCaff and members of the pubLc speakutg to public hearmg rtems on tomght's agenda SVPlenAAataVlongiangAI IIS7Ainmutes\2003-I PAI3minut~sV07-02-03e~uon Ipa6nun do~ Public Flenring Fiank Rc~~el, 234 Owl Cieck Road, represenYuig thc apphcant, spokc ~n suppoit Tun Plass, C55 M2xwell Ave , raised concerns about "demohtion by ucglect" and ~equested that Yhe boaid inrtiate a pro~ect to idenhfy sumlar buildmgs thal are in need of mamtena~~ce m the histoiic chstncts Yaul Saponto mentioned that the UBC and 1BC h~ve provistons Coi the mamtenance of unsafe sh uctm es Board Motion L Dm~m made the followmg motion, seca~ded by L Ruckei lhat ihe Landmail<s Preseivation Advtsory Boaid condrtionally appiove the requcst for a Landmark Alterahon Cei hficale for demolition of lhe exisYmg gai agc and construct~on of a i~ew detached, two-cai gaiagc foi the pioperty at 541 Maxwell, adoptmg Che staff inemorandum as findings of tlte boatd, ancl sub~eet to the followmg eonci~t~ons The apphcanl shall subm~t Final plans, iucluding site plan and biuldmg elevations at one qua~tei inch scale, to the Landmarks design icview comtmttee The dcsign icview committee shall teview final details, matenals, colors, wmdows aud doors Coi eomplianee wrih ihe Mapleton Hill Design Guidelmes The apphcant sh211 provide a sitc plan, photographs and scaled diawings of the existmg garagc pnoi to demolihou Tl~e applicant shall close tlie existmg curb cut on Maxwell Vote 'Clte board voted 4-0 to appiove the mot~on (K Stutsman excused absent) C. Public hearing and consideratiou of whetlier to lift the stay of demolrtion for the property at 2747 4th Street or initiate histm•ic district designation fm• the west side of the 2700 block of 4th Street. Rutli Mcllevsei swore m staff and membeis of the pubLc speakmg to public heating rtems on tomght's agenda Public He~ring Lutda Smith, 2737 4`~ Stteet, spoke in o~pos~tion to histor~c district designation Lort Hunter, 2717 4~~' Street, spoke in support of histoiic district destgnation Paul Saporito, representmg H~stoiic Boulder, fiic , spoke neilhei m suppoit or opposriion of ltistouc d~strict dcsignation Jan Otto, 960 Lmcoln Place, spoke ne~ther m supporl or oppos~hon of histoiic d~stiict desig~~atron SVPlanAdataUungi angAI I IS IAmmute~A2003-f PARminutwVU7-02-03achnn Ipebmm doc Gleun Smrth, 2737 4°' Sheet, spoke ui opposrtion to histonc d~stuct dcsignahon Len Pcttviohn, 275J 4~~' Stieet, spoke m supporC ofhisloiic distnct designation Kathryn Bai th, 2740 20'~' Stieet, spoke neither ui support or opposition ol I~isto~ ic district dcsignat~on The board took no action on this item. D. A chanQe in the agenda was ~Qreed upon by the bo~rd members to hear a presentation from Doug Aawtl~orne and Ma~ y Reilly-McNellan on restoration and repau• issues regarding headstones iu Columbia Cemetery. E. Public hearing and adoption of General Design Guidelines f'or Local Historic D~stricts and Individual Landmarks as Administrative Regulations pursuant to the rulemaking procedures set forth in Chapter 1- 4, B.R.C. 1981. Ruth McHevser swore m staff and membeis of the publ~c speakmg to p~ibhc heauug rtems on tonight's agenda Public IIearing Theie was no public comment on th~s itein Board Motion Leland Ruclcer made the followmg mot~on, seconded by Lisa EQQer that the Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board adopt the Genetal Design GutdeLnes for Local Histouc Districts ~nd Individual Landmarks as Admmistrat~ve 12egiilations pursuant to thc r~ileinakmg piocedures set fortlt m Chapter 1-4, B R C 1981 Vote Tl~e boud votcd 4-0 to appiove the mohon (Stutsinan excused absent) 6. MA'CTERS FROM THE LANDMARKS BOARD, PLANNING DEPARTM~NP, AND CITY ATTOI2NEY - Update on gener~l code cl~anges rel~ted to the designation process - National Trust for Histm•ic Preservation Conference - Colorado Preservation, Inc. applicatious for Coloradds Most End~ngered Places due in August - Discussion of possible date for Board retreat - St~ff will submit a WIP to Council rcgardmg cmitinuatiou of reports m~ permit activity in University HiII 7. DGBRI~F MEETING/CALF,NDAR CHECK SVPlanAdataAlongrangAHIS IAminut~ti\2003-I PANminmcsV07-02-Olacnon Ipabmm doc 8. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was ad~ourned at ] 0 15 p m Respectfully subm~tted, Respectfully submrttcd, _ ~ Heidi Stia e ski LPAB Sccreta~y Ap roved on Au ust 6, 2003 `=-. ~~ Roiy Salance Cha~iperson S\Plan\ddla\longiang\I IIS I\mwutcs~200J-f PA6minutes\07-02-03acUOn Ipabmm doc