2 - Minutes, 2/2/05CITY OF BOULDER
LANDMARKS PRESERVATION ADVISORY BOARD
MINUTES
February 2, 2005
Council Chambers
Municipai Building ~°_;
rSOj~;a"
1777 Broadway
6 p.m ~;:; ::
_ £ii'i:'.'i~
;;,3i
't:;y_'.
The following aze the action minutes of the February~~;~2005; G'}`~.c
Preservation Advisory Boazd meeting. A permapent s`~t of these iiu
recording (maintained for a period of seven yeais)'is refained in Ce
(telephone: 303-441-3043). You may also;lis~en to the minutes via
website at: www ci boulcier.co.us/plani~iit~[andmarks)a~endas/2 2
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT:
Nancy Komblum
Lisa Egger
Leland Rucker ;f =:# ,' ,Y i. ,
Tim Plass °~~;~;~;t: '
Rory Salance, Chairperson ~ -
,. .
:~~~'~= v3xi~~,
t:,
STAFF MEMBE~z~RESENT: ~ ~: ;:~~ ~'
.' :'`i)~~n'. .F3 :3•.•
Sue ~llen Hamson;`~}ty,Attorney = ~
Bohdy Hei~gcock, Pre's~ation Planner;:
James T~e`~k+at;:~'reserva~jdn Planner ~,'~ ~
Chris Meschii~l~° P;ese~~~~ot~ Intern , ~
ulder Landmarks
and a tape
Records
~ty, of Boulder
~~~': y.
; ",g;rs, ~ ,; ~ ,;
£,. ;,1 Ct~LI-. TO ORDER
Th~~ol~ havingilieeri called, Chairperson R. Salance declared a quorum at 6:03
`~~~s~ p.m ~~~id'the follo~ingbusiness was conducted:
,,;;:'-.;;.
~ <x:°i;, 3??: ~ `~`;i:
"=;~t37~t: '.~~,~} t,'
':? ~. APPRO~?'~I. OFIVIINUTES
,:,.
#'i~ '' , The boazd' approved the minutes of the January 5, 2004 meeting.
,
3. 1~UBL~C PARTICIPATION FOR ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA
IVo~i~ne`~from the public addressed the board.
4. DISCUSSION OF LANDMARK ALTERATION AND DEMOLITION
APPLICATIONS ISSUED AND PENDING
There was no discussion of Landmark Alteration and Demolition applications
issued and pending.
1
5. ACTION ITEMS
A. Public hearing and consideration of a Landmark Alteration Certitcate for the
demolition of an accessory building, and the construction of a one-car garage
at 2424 6`h Street in the Mapleton Hill Historic District. (HIS2005-00015)
~.
Owner: Robert Leland ~
Applicant: Ashley Pitts, Architect -'~~`~ r
~#;; ';'s;
Board members were asked to reveal any ex parte co ~acts 1H~y may have had on this item.
T. Plass, L. Rucker, R Salance and N. Kornblumt~viewed Ehisproposal at a Landmarks
Design Review Committee meeting and a site,yisifs";,L.'Egger revi~`~5ed the proposal at a
Landmarks Design Review Committee meeting. ~''
,~
t;``
;: ':,,; `;, ~; _
Public Hearing
Ashley Pitts, architect, spoke in support of the prppos,a.l'~
: ,_~
Motion ~' ' '
a;.
On a motion by L. Egger, seci#iidgd_by R. Salance, ~fFi~~;andmazks Preservation Advisory
Board conditionally approved ( 5=0; ~~the, request for the`deinalirion of the existing garage
on the property, and the constmcti,on of`tlie.ttew garage, adijpfi"ing the revised staff
memorandum dated February 2, 2UQ5 as findings af,the board, and subject to the following
F:.i .F.~}.1~ ~:j.:
conditions of appcoyal: "~ '
'`l~;~~,
~, 3 ~
1. The Board of Z~ning Adjustment and Building Appeal's approva] of the variance
frotp the required;6' setback between buildings.
`i "-E:
2. The finaLdesign o~'~fi~`new construction be reviewed and approved by the
' ; Landmarks Desigi Review ~oriimittee.
fi; ~
,:~ `', ~'~~{,:!r:ij:~ ~~ "t:t~iis~
3. The ~;al3design'sTiot~~d address all design details such as roofing, decorative
"-+`;;;g, details,°;'~rid color. ~'~~'~'~
~3~1S:;S: ~' ~;+
j~:; 'jz,: •
~e~ .a
'i4'~ The existing garage should be photographically documented by the applicant prior
#.; ,
~x : to its remo'val.
.].i,k '.
. .,~ ! .,x~:~
B. Publ~c hearing and consideration of a demolition permit application for a
building over 50 years in age (coastructed in 1954), and located at 2805 6`n
Street. (HIS2004-00204)
Owner: Kirk Peck
Board members were asked to reveal any ex parte contacts they may have had on this item.
T P~ass, L Rucker, aad R. Salance reviewed this proposal at a Landmarks Design Review
Committee meeting. R. Salance also lived in the house for a short period years ago.
Public Hearing
Bill Kolbe, 2800 5`h Street, s~oke in opposition of the proposal.
Shazon Sickels-Roy, 2765 6` Street, spoke in'opposition of the proposal.
Angela McCormick, 2855 7`h Street, spoke neither in support or opposition, but suggested
that the board look at the larger neighborhood as there have been lots of changes.
Motion ~';~"~°~_.
On a motion by T. Plass, seconded by L. Egger, the Landmiaiks Pre`servation Advisory
Board approved (5-0) the demolition permit application;for'A;huilding over 50 years in
age (constructed in 1954), and located at 2805 6`h Str,eeY'(HI~~', 'Q,4-00204), adopting the
staff memorandum dated February 2, 20005 as findings of the ~i'O~yr~i,
6.
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
MATTERS FROM THE LANDM
DEPARTMENT, AND CITY A;$~
s
Discussion of the ca. 1876 Hannah E
=r;~ ~;ai::
3 B4bARD, PLA1v1YI~G
YI,~
EY ,, `'#;;` -,:a::
„?:;
7.
HoUSe~at 800 Arapahoe Avenue.
Update on Highland Lawn district design~f c3
~,:;.
Update on 1802 Canyon `'`' 3
t,~:
Update on Code Chang~.s;,,,;.
Update on BVCP 2005 Ivf~joi;',Update
U date on Valmont Butte:a '~ i''' ~t ' J
P t=~;
"i~'i~°;; , .
EBRIEF,MEETING/CAL~NI)j~R CHEG~`;''"~
nV?~?I11l~..e.. .- .. .
8. ADJOURNMELV;I~
,x,., ~{s! .
Tfiertieeting was~_~ci~oumed at 8:27,p.m.
~4;
i~3'
gt 3 { ;
£i~ ~ ~ ' +~f~
; d~esjiectfully subini~te~~d~,
`z Approvedfoii`,l~Iarch 2, 2045
r;:'`=,.
. 2_ :,. "v!'.i„_
'ta.~•' :.i,f~i ..
-~ .,~ ~~.23. +
~i
''Y~ix:~I'.