The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2 - Minutes, 1/5/05CITY OF BOULDER LANDMARKS PRESERVATION ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES January 5, 2005 Council Chambers Municipal Building ~~~~~~~ 1777 Broadway ~ #~{3~' 'R~ 6 p.m. (~;;~~}f. q ~~"~~ ~~@li~~t# The following aze the action minutes of the January ~}~~~OOS,~Cit~#~f Boulder Landmazks Preservation Advisory Board meeting. A permanent s~i of these'fT~~ tes and a tape recording (maintained for a period of seven x~a~'s)'~'s+re'tained in C~~i_ ~ Records (telephone: 303-441-3043). You may alsn~l~ten to the mirmtes via the~ ~ of Boulder website at: www.ci.boulder.co.us/planni ''=1' dmarksf ~~endas/1 5 OS.h ~~~~;~,;_' azed a quorum at 6:05 I meeting. 'HE AGENDA D DEMOLITION Demolition application stayed: 543 Marine expires January 8, 2005 The board took no action, acknowledging that the stay would expire on Januazy 8, 2005. APPLICATIONS ISSUED AND PENDING 5. ACTION ITEMS A. Public hearing and consideration of whether to initiate the process of historic district designation for the 500 block of Marine Street, Highland Lawn Historic District. „s~~i~'t1F. Board members were asked to reveal any ex parte L. Rucker and L. Egger reviewed this proposal at Committee meeting. L. Rucker, R Salance,-N. ~ on January 5, 2005. N. Kornblum also had a qt}i-a of 6`~ and Marine. =z~"' y ~, ~t=ii... ~''' Et~~.,, Public Hearing ' ,~;,i~,±,. . James McGoodwin, 576 Marine, spoke in opp4s~h~ Payson Sheets, 520 Marine, spoke in favor of tfie p Scott Dale, 504 Marine, spoke in opposition of the Thomas Rebman, 543 Marine;{s~ Melanie Tisdale, 543 Marine, spi Fran Sheets, 520 Marine, spoke i Peter Freymuth, 551 Marine and Henry Vellandi,.$42 Mazine, voi , .>,:~ ~ structures. €~'s~'s,;~~i,':-; , Gail Grey;'.646 Pearl'~treet, repr but encou ~~ Elizabeth Dido Clazk, s,=j•~~ss:,_. e f~'~; ~'z'~f s~.t~~}~' :. s°'' MOt101T'~Yr;y. ii,~ ~ '" ~II 8 TROt10T I:' lYt . ~ ~;:`1;,, Advisory B~ ~.~~ ~..-. °~::~~rocess of L `~=~~3fs4 of the : B. more cptjsensus with pld, 16Q7' ¢`h Street, sF ~. . ,.'.!.)a~.... . in opposition oi q opposition of ~'h may have had on this item. iar ~~esign Review t+ 1, ant~s~ Plass visited the site with tt~e;~~gidents at the corner proposal. favor of the proposal. l`etermination of contributing Historic Boulder, spoke in favor of the proposal, ~ owners. avor of the proposal. of historic districts. 'las'~;~'s?$c,onded by N. Kornblum, the Landmarks Preservation 3~ ` ie (3-2~y~;.'Rucker, L. Egger dissenting) a resolution to initiate the ~ric di5frict designation for the 500 block of Marine Street as per 10- Revised Code, adopting the staff inemorandum dated January 5, 2005 and consideration of a Landmark Alteration Certiticate for the ~onstruction of a two-car, approximately 500 sq. ft. detached garage at the northeast corner of the property located at 745 Mapleton Avenue in the Mapleton Hill Historic District. (HI5200400207) Applicant: Judd Kaiman Board members were asked to reveal any ex parte contacts they may have had on this item. L. Rucker and L. Egger reviewed this project at a Landmarks Design Review Committee meeting. R Salance, N. Kornblum and T. Plass reviewed the project at a Landmazks Design Review Committee meeting, and visited the site. Public Hearing No one from the public addressed the boazd. Motion ~;~? On a motion by L. Rucker, seconded by R. Salance, t e x;di Boazd approved (5-0) the request of a Landmark Alt ~ion ~E of a new two-car detached garage, approximately SO~~q. ft., property located at 745 Mapleton Avenue, ado~~~~;the~staff 5, 2005 as findings ofthe board, and subject,ts~ the fo~lowing The final design of the new consfix'~ib~ shall Landmazks Design Review Commrtt~~ §„ sh including, resolution of roofing materia ;~,~~`tAi~} regazding doors and windows. ~j~ ~ ; Preservation Advisory e for the construction irtheast comer of the ~~lum dated January d and app~i~ti by fhe all final d~ign details color, and final specifications C. Public Hearing and co ~~~;"~ ~on of a requesf~~Y~raut a Landmark Alteration Certificate ~d~- the"~'~'"" ~~~on of an e~rsting accessory building and, in its place, to construct`~.one a,nt ~#~} ~~f stoty detac6ed garage building a r~ ;,4,,., with a fpptprint of approx~tna~gly 450 s.~'~' nt 437 Highland Avenue in the ~,~.,: - Ma~t~l~foh;~~Il,Historic Dis~'f~~~ct (HIS2004~~0108) This item was continued from tjh~'il ugust ~~;g~,~r004 Landma'r`ks Board Meeting. ilJ~i~~:!3 'i~lt' '~4: ' kiY,~,., ^ i _ 3i..~e~f' e~l~`tiny ez parte contacts they may have had on this item. N. Kornblum and T. Plass reviewed the project at ttee meetings and visited the site. _~ Hand, 486~f°1~arwin Ct, architect, spoke in favor of the proposal. On a mtSt~on,b~ L,. Egger, seconded by L. Rucker, the Landmarks Preservation Advisory Board apptvved (3-2, T. Plass and N. Kornblum dissenting) the request for a Landmark Alteration"Certificate for demolition of the existing garage and replacement with a new single-car garage, adopting the staff inemorandum dated January 5, 2005, as findings of the board and subject to the following conditions: 3 1. Existing driveway and curb cut from Highland Avenue to be closed in accordance with city standards and replaced with landscapigg consistent with the chazacter of the site and district. Plans to be submitted for review and approval by the Landmarks Design Review Committee. _ . 2. Applicant to submit detailed plans at Y~" scale for new construction to the design review committee for final review and approval. 3. All reasonable precautions shall be taken to assure that t~e mature maple on the site is not damaged during the construction of the new str}tet'ui`~., D. Public Hearing and consideration of a Alteration Certificate for an approxim house, the demolition of an accessory 1 car garage, all at 2424 6`" Street in tl~~' (HIS2004-00208) ;~J'•3 Applicant: Ashley Pitts, Board members were asked to reveal any e~c pd~'fie~ L. Rucker, L. Egger and T. Plass reviewed the pi'~ Committee meeting. L. Ruckei~''~R..Salance and T ~'f t3°{ Kornblum received an email fi'"tiiii~aiiheiQhborinQ x k r.ant a Landmark €~:4 t. addition to the main ad ~~Sonstruction of a one- Hill ~~~ric District. `~~~3's~ ;t,.,f: ' ,, ~f } * !x,, ;1~~=~ ts they may have had on this item. at a Landmarks Design Review ;visited the site, and N. The demolition and new constructiQn of the:ga~~~~.were ct~emed to be incomplete on the j .t lv~:-(3 application, and therefore were not i~viewed duniig~ : proposal. 5':i~li`~.'i.t, f3f~ Public Hg9~"ring , ', !#;r_ ` . Ashlex PittS;.architecf;,s~ioke in favor of,~he,proposal. Robert Lelat~i~;:2424 6~';street, owner, spoke in favor of the proposal. { ; ~,r~>>'; ,z ,-., ~. ~ ~~` ' ~',~:,:~ "`sdgiij;"~>°i,;;;... ..~ ?: ' ~ 4t!~'.~. ~:.3E~;;== i " ,. .s?~@,~I4~':?:~ '3`ii~',, +?i~~'.' ~-•:{a,-,.- . :,~,it ~it~i, ~i.:,;~. ;3'~'' On a ii38~ic~t;by L. Ru~,~~ ,er, seconded by L. Egger, the Landmarks Preservation Advisory ;;3i'`~ Board appro'v~i~ ~4-1, ~;;~~~ance dissenting) the request for the remodel of and additions to ''' the house at ~~,'e.4~6`h Stre `''''~$o hn the staff inemorandum dated 7anuaz 5, 2005 as '~ ''` '' P ~ S Y ~, ~~,,.:, ~ ~; ~,><: •,c;;s°findings oFthe boatd, and.GUbject to the following conditions of approval, which address =ij$`:, '~~"`~ t~e,addition and exclude the garage construction: '.fS;a~, :;Ei- 1. `';.'--#'j#~The final design of the new construction be reviewed and approved by the ": sL~ndmatks Design Review Committee. 2. ~ ~; .,:, TL}~~zial design should address all design details including porch and window design, as well as details such as roofing, decorative details, and color. 6. MATTERS FROM THE LANDMARKS BOARD, PLANNING DEPARTMENT, AND CITY ATTORNEY A. Preliminary discussion regarding the relocation of the landmarked Depot Building to the Transit Village property at 30~h and Pearl Streets. 4 7. DEBRIEF MEETING/CALENDAR CHECK 8. ADJOURNMENT The ~eeti~g was adjourned at 10:18 p.m. ~;, 5