The URL can be used to link to this page

BPRD Master Plan update City of Boulder Parks and Recreation Department MEMORANDUM TO: Human Relations Commission FROM: Alison Rhodes, Boulder Parks and Recreation Master Plan Staff Lead SUBJECT: Parks and Recreation Master Plan Update th DATE:, 2012 November 19 The Boulder Parks and Recreation Department (BPRD) would like to update the Human Relations The 2006 Park and Commission on progress to date on the department’s Master Plan Update. Recreation Master Plan is being updated to reflect current and emerging trends including aging facilities, change in program and services needs, changing demographics, increased inactivity and connection to nature by youth, and advances in technology. The updated master plan is being structured within the context of the City’s Sustainability Framework that reflects the Boulder Valley Comprehensive Plan and the city approach to Priority Based Budgeting. The master plan is intended to guide the Boulder Parks and Recreation Department (BPRD) for the next five years in addressing the delivery of park and recreation services in a manner that meets the community’s service standards and sustainability goals. The process includes three phases of work: background research, a community needs assessment and action plan development. A detailed project timeline is included in Attachment A. Public engagement is a critical component in every phase of the process, and to date public engagement efforts have included stakeholder interviews, a community mail survey, Parks and Recreation Advisory Board engagement, public issues workshops, and online information sharing and feedback collection. More information on the methodology of the outreach can be found in Attachment B-Summary of Public Engagement. The community survey findings are included as Attachment C. BPRD is including the Human Relations Commission in our process as part of our community engagement efforts. The department is hoping to reach all levels of the community and welcomes any feedback on opportunities for involving the community as the master plan update continues. Attachment A: BPRD Master Plan Timeline Attachment B: Summaries of Research. Attachment C: Community Survey 1 Attachment B DĂƐƚĞƌWůĂŶhƉĚĂƚĞWƵďůŝĐŶŐĂŐĞŵĞŶƚ^ƵŵŵĂƌǇ /ŶƚƌŽĚƵĐƚŝŽŶ AcriticalcomponentoftheBoulderParksandRecreationMasterPlanUpdateis effectivepublicengagement.Theimportanceofpublicinvolvementinthemasterplan processcannotbeunderestimated,andisabsolutelynecessaryiftheplanisto effectivelydelivercommunityorientedparkandrecreationservicestoresidents. Overall,thepublicprocessmustbebalanced,open,andcollaborativeandasaresultwill buildcommunitywidetrustintheplanandtheprocess.Theprocessisdeveloped carefullyinordertocreateanoutcomethatwillsecuresupportfor,andapprovalof,the MasterPlanbyCityCouncil,advisorygroups,citymanagement,departmentstaff,and thediverseusergroupsoftheparkandrecreationdepartmentservices. TheEppleyInstituteforParksandPublicLands(Eppley)providestheleadroleinthe publicengagementportionoftheMasterPlan,usingwellestablishedstrategiesthat haveahistoryofsuccessinpublicforums.ThepublicinvolvementinBouldertodatehas includedthefollowingstrategies: StakeholderInterviews ParkandRecreationAdvisoryBoard(PRAB)studysessionsandupdatesat regularPRABmeetings TechnicalAdvisoryGroup(TAG)reviewsandinput PublicIssues&OpportunityOpenHouses) CommunityParkandRecreationRandomMailSurvey InternetSurveyopentothegeneralpublic Sharingofinformationandcollectingfeedbackonline Thesepublicengagementmethodshavebeencombinedwithotherresearchand observationstodevelopatriangulationapproachtopublicinvolvement.Triangulationis aconceptwhichrecognizesthatnosinglepublicengagementstrategywillaccurately reflectthetruepreferencesofanentirecommunity.Repeatedlyaskingthesameor similarquestionsinavarietyofforumsandthencomparingtheanswerscanidentify commonthemesandissues.Thiscombinationofmethodologyresultsinathorough understandingofthegeneralƉƵďůŝĐ͛Ɛviews,whichcanthenbeincorporatedintothe MasterPlan. Staff,alsohaveanimportantroleintheprocess.ThedepartmentcreatedaTechnical AdvisoryGroup(TAG)thatiscomprisedofpersonnelchargedwithreviewingresearch anddataandmilestonedocumentsforaccuracy.Inaddition,departmentstaffandthe projectteamconductstudysessionswiththeParksandRecreationAdvisoryBoard (PRAB)togaintheirinsightandadviceonkeyissuesoftheMasterPlan. 1 Attachment B Additionalpublicoutreachwillbeheldoverthenextfewmonthsfollowingthe th November27CityCouncil/PRABjointstudysession.ThiswillincludeaPathfinders workshopinearlyspring,acommunitywideopenhousetoshareprogress,ongoing webbaseddiscussionsandPRABstudysessions.Theongoingpublicengagementwill helprefinecorethemesanddevelopstrategicactionitemsthatrepresentthebroad communityneedsandinterests. Thefollowingisreviewofstrategiesimplementedtodate: ^ƚĂŬĞŚŽůĚĞƌ/ŶƚĞƌǀŝĞǁƐ Earlyintheprocess,keystakeholdersrepresentingawidevarietyofbothactiveand passiveusergroups,communityleaders,citystaff,PRAB,andspecialinterestgroups wereinterviewedbymembersoftheprojectteam.Theinterviewnoteswereanalyzed usingqualitativedataanalysismethodstoidentifyrecurringthemesandearlyemerging trends. Stakeholdersareindividualswhorepresentthecommunityasaresultoftheirposition, involvement,interest,oridentityinthecommunity.Thestakeholdersofacommunity generallyrepresentacrosssectionofthecommunityandareinterviewedinorderto obtainasenseofoverallpublicopinion. MeetingswithCitystaffandcommunityrepresentativestookplaceatBPRD AdministrativeOfficesduringtheweekofJanuary30,2012.Appointmentswere scheduledbyBPRDstaff,conductedbyEppleystaffinprivatewiththestakeholders,and typicallylastedonehour.Stakeholderswereassuredofconfidentiality. anumberofimportant Basedonthisearlyanalysis,Boulderstakeholdersidentified focusareas,whichidentifiedkeythemesthatfallunderthefollowingbroadcategories: AssetManagement:Assetandfacilityoperationsonlymarginallyreflecta lifecyclemanagementapproachandthereisdemandinthecommunityfor additionalfacilitiesofcertaintypes. RecreationProgramming:Comparedtoothercommunities,therecreation programsprovidedtoBoulderresidentsaremoreadvancedandspecialized. Also,thereisdemandinthecommunityforadditionalfacilities(i.e.aquatic facilitiesandlittleleaguefields). CommunityHealthandWellness:Itisimportanttodrawconnectionsbetween parksandrecreationandpublichealth,butthereisnoemergentconceptofhow toarticulatethatconnection. CommunityRelationshipsandSocialGood:Innovationisneededtofosterand managepartnerships. SustainabilityGoals:ItisimperativetointegratetheCityofŽƵůĚĞƌ͛Ɛthreepart sustainabilitymodelintothemasterplan. 2 Attachment B OrganizationPreparedness:Someofthefeedbackisrelatedtohowthe organizationoperatesandwillbeconsideredasthedepartmentevaluateshowit providestheservicesthecommunityvalues. AftermoredetailedanalysisandmeetingswithPRAB,TAG,andcitystaff,additional informationfurtherclarifiedtheinitialcategoriesasthecorethemesandissues affectingBoulderParksandRecreation.Thesecorethemesinclude: CommunityHealthandWellness AssetManagementʹ͞dĂŬŝŶŐbettercareofwhatweŚĂǀĞ͟ YouthConnectionandActivity RecreationProgramming CommunityBuildingandRelationships FinancialSustainability EnvironmentalStewardship ŽŵŵƵŶŝƚǇWĂƌŬƐΘZĞĐƌĞĂƚŝŽŶZĂŶĚŽŵDĂŝů^ƵƌǀĞǇ Astheresultsofstakeholderinterviewsbegintorepresenttheviewsofthecommunity asawhole,theadditionalpublicinvolvementservestoadjustorhelpvalidatethemes anddrawoutnewthemesthatmaynothavebeenrepresentedbystakeholders.Using developed.Thesurvey thisstrategy,thecommunityrecreationsurveyinstrumentwas usedacombinationofestablished,scientificallyprovenquestioningandtheidentified corethemesandissues,asaguidefordevelopingspecificquestionsthatwouldprovide thedatatovalidateinformation. Atotalof663useablesurveyswerereturned,yieldingaresponserateof20.7%.Thishas produceda3.8%confidenceintervalataconfidencelevelof95%.Thesurveyresultsare discussedindetailinƉƉůĞǇ͛Ɛreport͞ZĞƐĞĂƌĐŚFindings:Community^ƵƌǀĞǇ͘͟ ThemailsurveyprovidedvaluableinformationaboutBoulderƌĞƐŝĚĞŶƚƐ͛attitudesand preferenceswhenitcomestoparkandrecreationservices.Theobjectivesidentifiedfor thesurveyincluded: Awarenessofcommunityparksandrecreationresources,includingtheBoulder ParksandRecreationDepartmentanditsfacilities Useofthoseresourcesandfacilities,Barriers(perceivedandactual)totheuseof parksandrecreationresources,`1oftheBoulderParksandRecreation Department Associationofparksandrecreationresourcestopublichealth,environmental sustainability,economicsustainabilityandsocialsustainability Importanceofhavingcertainparksandrecreationresourcesinthecommunity Satisfactionwithcommunityparksandrecreationresources,particularlythose oftheBoulderParksandRecreationDepartment Opinionaboutthefollowingspecificissues: 3 Attachment B Potentialneedforadditionalaquaticfacilities o Potentialneedforadditionalbaseball/softballfields o Tradeoffdecisionsaboutsubsidizingcertainprograms/operationswith o userfees Tradeoffdecisionsaboutacquiringnewland/facilitiesversusmaintaining o existinginfrastructure Willingnesstopayforcertainprograms o DĂƐƚĞƌWůĂŶKŶůŝŶĞ TheprojectteamwillkeepthepublicinformedandupdatedabouttheMasterPlanvia severalonlinemethods. Eppleyismanaginganexternalwebsitetoshareinformationandcollectfeedback.The siteiswww.boulder.parksandrecplan.organdcontains: Generalinformationabouttheparkandrecreationmasterplanningprocess. Aprojecttimelineandinformationaboutmajormilestones. Informationabouttheconsultantteam. Informationabouthowtoparticipateinthepublicengagementprocess, includinganonlineformforsubmittingfeedback. Aportaltoaccessthecommunitysurvey. Astheprojectprogresses,theEppleyprojectwebsitewillbeupdatedandexpandedto include: Emergingtrendsforotherresearchbeingconductedaspartoftheplanning process. Informationaboutandfindingsfromspecificpublicengagementeventsand activities. Resultsfromthecommunitysurveyfromboththerandommailtotheonline publicversion. Thedepartmenthasalsoincludedbackgroundresearchdocuments,publicengagement findings(includingPRABstudysessionandregularmeetingupdatematerials)and informationtoaMasterPlanpageontheĚĞƉĂƌƚŵĞŶƚ͛Ɛexternalwebsite.Thepagecan befoundhere: http://www.bouldercolorado.gov/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=17 271&Itemid=3052 Inaddition,thedepartmentislaunchingatopicfocusedontheMasterPlanupdateon theCityofŽƵůĚĞƌ͛Ɛvirtualtownhall,www.inspireboulder.com.Thisplatformwill broadenthereachofparticipantsintheplanningeffortandengagethepublicin questions,pollingandideasubmissionrelatedtotheMasterPlanupdate. 4 Attachment B WƵďůŝĐ/ƐƐƵĞƐtŽƌŬƐŚŽƉƐ OverthreedifferentdatesinlateOctober,ŽƵůĚĞƌ͛ƐParksandRecreationDepartment hostedpublicmeetingsfocusedontheĚĞƉĂƌƚŵĞŶƚ͛ƐMasterPlanUpdate.The meetingswereanOpenHouseformat,withmultiplestationssetuptofacilitatefocused inputonspecifictopicsandtoallowforoneononeinteractionwithstaff.Additionally, themeetingsallowedthecommunitytoengagewithoneanotherinhearingtheneeds andexpectationsofthecommunitythroughtheirownvoice.Therewerestationsfor eachofthesevenkeythemesidentifiedthroughresearchandpublicengagementto date,aswellasanopenstationwherepeoplecoulddiscussunrelatedtopicsandnew ideas.Totalattendanceatthethreemeetingswas75participants͘ SpecificobjectivesoftheMasterPlancomponentofthepublicmeetingswereto: Presentfindingsrelatedtokeyissuesorfocusareasincludingbackground intheirdialogue. informationandquestionsforthepublictoconsider Gatherinputregardingeachofthefocusareastoconfirmandvalidate preliminaryfindings. 5 Attachment C OPIAL EPRT: TTCCRROO OMUNTY URVY CCMMIISSEE 44YVTSWISSJ8LMW6ITTSVX 88LMWVITSVXVIITVIWIRXWVIWIEVGLJMRRHMRKWWTIGGMJMGXSXLIGGSQQYRMX]WYVZI]-X[[MPPYPXMQEXIPP] MRRJSVQXLIGGSRXIRXSJXXLI4EVOWERH6IGVIEXXMSR1EWXIVV4PERFYXXLMWVITSVXHHSIWRSX RRIGIWWEVMP]GSRWXMXYXIXXLIJMREPREEVVEXMZIXLEXX[MPPFITVIIWIRXIHMRXXLITPER%JJXIVXLIJMRHHMRKWSJ XXLMWVITSVXEEVIVIZMI[IIHERHHIIIQIHXSFIEGGYVEXIERHWYJJMGMIIRXP]GSQTVILIRWMZIXLI][MPP FFIJYPP]W]RXXLIWM^IH[MXXLVIWIEVGLLJVSQSXLIVVXSTMGEPEVIEWEWTEVXXSJXLI2IIIHW%WWIWWQQIRX TTVSGIWW8LIIJMREPGSRXXIRXSJXLI11EWXIV4PERRQE]VIJPIGGXWMKRMJMGERRXTSVXMSRWSJXLMWVITSSVXFYX [[MPPRSXGSRWMWXIRXMVIP]SJMX8EFPIHITMGXWXXLITVSKVIWWWSJVIWIEVGGLERHTPERRRMRKJSVXLLMW VVIWIEVGLEVVIE 88EFPI8STMGGEP%VIE6IWWIEVGL4VSKVVIWW ((IZIPSTQIRRX4LEWI2SXIIW 6IWIEVVGLQIXLSHSSPSK]ETTVSZIH 4VIPMQMRREV]VIWIEVGGLERHEREP]]WMWGSQTPIXII (EXEKKETWMHIRXMJMIIHERHVIQEEMRMRKVIWIEVVGL EWWMKRIIH EESFXEMRIH %PPHEX RREV]GSQQYYRMX]TPERMRXXIKVEXMSRVIZZMI[ 4VIPMQM 4VIPMQMRREV]HITEVXQQIRXPIEHIVVWLMTVIZMI[ 8IGLRMGGEP 8%+ VIZMI[ &SEVH 46%& VIZMII[ (ITEVXXQIRXPIEHIIVWLMTVIZMI[[ 8STMGEP6ITSVXVIWIIEVGLERHEREP]WMWGSQTTPIXI 7]RXLIWMWJSVRIIHWWEWWIWWQIRXXERHGSQQYRMX] TPERMRXIKVEXMSR -RXVSHYGXMSR %%GVMXMGEPGSSQTSRIRXSSJXLI&SYPHHIV4EVOWERH6IGVIEXXMSR1EWXIVV4PER9THEEXIMWGMZMG IIRKEKIQIRX-RZSPZMRKXLITYFPMGMWIWWIRXMEEPXSHIZIPSSTMRKETPEERXLEX[MPPVVIGIMZIXLII WWYTTSVXSJVIWMHIRXWERRHXLEX[MPPMRJSVQXLIHITEVXQIRRXMRHIPMZIVVMRKGSQQYYRMX]SVMIRXIHTEVO EERHVIGVIEXMSRWIVZMGIIWXSMXWGMXM^^IRW3ZIVEEPPXLIGMZMGIRKEKIQIIRXTVSGIWWWFIMRKYWIIHJSV XXLMWTPEREMQQWXSFIFEEPERGIHSTTIRERHGSPPEFSVEXMZI%GSQQQYRMX]WYVZI]HIZIPSTIIHF] XXLI)TTPI]-RWXMXYXILEWFIIRGSRRHYGXIHXSKEYKITYFFPMGSTMRMSRRMRXIVIWXWERHFIPMIJWWEFSYX XXLIGYVVIRXTEVOWERHVIGVIEXMSRW]WXIQMR&&SYPHIV8LIIWYVZI]MWSSRITEVXSJEKVIEXIVQQYPXM HHMQIRWMSREEPIJJSVXXSKKEXLIVMRTYXXLVSYKLSYYXXLIGSQQYRMX]3XLLIVTYFPMGTTEVXMGMTEXMSSR EEGXMZMXMIWMRZZSPZIGSRHHYGXMRKWXEOOILSPHIVMRXXIVZMI[WLSSPHMRKTYFPMMGQIIXMRKWWWLEVMRK MRRJSVQEXMSRERHGSPPIGGXMRKJIIHFFEGOSRPMRIIERHSJJIVMMRKETYFPMGGVIZMI[SJHSGYQIRXXW 11IXLSHW Attachment C 796:)=6IWIEVGL*MRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEXI'SQQYRMX]7YVZI] 3FNIGXMZIW 8LIJSPPS[MRKSFNIGXMZIWTVSZMHIHXLIJVEQI[SVOJSVXLIWYVZI]GSQTSRIRXSJTYFPMG IRKEKIQIRXF]WXEXMRKXLIREXYVISJMRJSVQEXMSRRIIHIHXSHIZIPSTEGSQTVILIRWMZIERH [IPPKVSYRHIHQEWXIVTPER8LISFNIGXMZIW[IVIHIZIPSTIHFEWIHYTSRMRTYXJVSQXLI )TTPI]-RWXMXYXIv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o 4SXIRXMEPRIIHJSVEHHMXMSREPEUYEXMGJEGMPMXMIW o 4SXIRXMEPRIIHJSVEHHMXMSREPFEWIFEPPWSJXFEPPJMIPHW o 8VEHISJJHIGMWMSRWEFSYXWYFWMHM^MRKGIVXEMRTVSKVEQWSTIVEXMSRW[MXLYWIVJIIW o 8VEHISJJHIGMWMSRWEFSYXEGUYMVMRKRI[PERHJEGMPMXMIWZIVWYWQEMRXEMRMRKI\MWXMRK MRJVEWXVYGXYVI o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ttachment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vWYRMUYIIMHIRXMJMIVJSSV GGSRZIRMIRGGI8SIRGSSYVEKIEHHHMXMSREPVIWTTSRWIWXLIHIEHPMRIJSVGSQTPIXXMRKXLIWYVZZI][EW II\XIRHIHXSS3GXSFIV Attachment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vWRIIHW 8LI%QIVMGER%WWSGMEXMSRJSV4YFPMG3TMRMSR6IWIEVGL %%436 LEWQYPXMTPIWTIGMJMGHIJMRMXMSRWJSV wVIWTSRWIVEXIx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wVEGIxEWVEGIEPSRISVMR GSQFMREXMSR[MXLSRISVQSVISXLIVVEGIW%WWYGLMX[MPPXSXEPQSVIXLER Attachment C 6IWIEVGL*MRRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEEXI'SQQYYRMX]7YVZI]]796:)== ''LEVXIV11MWWMSR ::MWMSR ;;LEXEVIXLLIGSVIERHHIWWIRXMEPZEPYIWERHHWIVZMGIWXLLIHITEVXQQIRXWLSYPHJSGYWSRMRR &&SYPHIVKMZZIRPMQMXIHVIWSYVGIWEERHJYRHMRKK# 55YIWXMSRSJXLIWYVZZI]EWOWw++IRIVEPP]WTTIEOMRKLSS[MQTSVXEERXMWMXXS]SSYXSLEZIXLIWIMR &&SYPHIV#x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ttachment C 7796:)=6IWIEVGL**MRHMRKW&SSYPHIV1EWXIIV4PER9THHEXI'SQQQYRMX]7YVZII] **MKYVI7YVZZI]5YIWXMSRR+IRIVEEPP]WTIEOMRKKLS[MQTSVVXERXMWMXXS]]SYXSLEZIXXLIWIMR&SYPHIV# 55YIWXMSRSJXLIWYVZZI]EWOWw88LMROEFSYXXXLIGSQQQYRMX]SJ&SSYPHIVSZIVEEPP8S[LEX HHIKVIIHSTEVOWERHVIGVIEXMSRGSRXVMFYXIIXS&SYPHIVVWFIMRKx 66IWYPXWMRHMGGEXI 4EVOWWERHVIGVIIEXMSRXIRHXSGSRXVMFYYXIQSWXXS&SYPHIVvWTTL]WMGEPLIIEPXLUYEPMX ]SJPMJI ERHWIRWISJTPEEGI 4EVOWWERHVIGVIIEXMSRXIRHXSGSRXVMFYYXIPIEWXXS&SYPHIVvWIIGSRSQMGWWYWXEMREFMPMXX]ERH GSQQYRMX]WEJIIX] 88EFPI 5YIIWXMSR 8LLMROEFSYXXLLIGSQQYRMXX]SJ&SYPHIVVSZIVEPP8S[[LEXHIKVIIIHSTEVOWEERH VVIGVIEXMSRGSSRXVMFYXIXS&SYPHIVWFIIMRK -XXIQ+VIEXP]7SQI[[LEX(SIIWRSX'ERXWE]RS GSRXVMFYXIIWGSRXVMFFYXIWGSRRXVMFYXISTMRMSR ETL]WMGEPP]LIIEPXL]GSQQYRRMX]# ERIRZMVSRQIRXEPP]WYWXEMREFFPIGSQQYRMX]## EWSGMEPP]XLVMZZMRKGSQQYRMX]]# ERIGSRSQMGEEPP]WYWXEMREFPIGSQQYRMX]# EREGGIWWMFPIERHTL]WMGEPP]]GSRRIGXIHGSSQQYRMX]# EWEJIGSQQYYRMX]# EGSQQYRMX][MXLETSWMXMZIWIRWISJTPEGI# EGSQQYRMX][MXLELMKLUYEEPMX]SJPMJISZIVEEPP# Attachment C 6IWIEVGL*MRRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEEXI'SQQYYRMX]7YVZI]]796:)== **MKYVI 5YYIWXMSR 8LLMROEFSYXXLLIGSQQYRMX]SJ&SYPHIIVSZIVEPP8S[LEXHIKVIIIHSTEVOWERH VVIGVIEXMSRGSSRXVMFYXIXS&SYPHIVWFIIMRK 66IGVIEXMSRR4VSKVEQWW IIW -JJTEXVSRWGEERI\TIVMIRRGIMRGVIEWIHWEXMWJEGGXMSRERHUUYEPMX]SJWIIVZMGIF]ERRSXLIVTVSZZMHIV [[LIRWLSYPHXLIHITEEVXQIRXI\TTPSVIEPXIVREXMZITVSKVVEQHIPMZIVV]# 88[SMXIQWMRR5YIWXMSREWOVIWTTSRHIRXWXSSMRHMGEXIMJJXLI]EKVIIIXLEXMXMWMQQTSVXERXJSSVXLI 44EVOWERH66IGVIEXMSR(ITEVXQIRRXXSJEGMPMXEEXIERHSVKKERM^IVIGVIIEXMSRSTTSVXYRMXMIWTTVSZMHIH FF]SXLIVSVKKERM^EXMSRWWMRXLIGSQQQYRMX]7TTIGMJMGEPP]SSRIMXIQEWWOIHEFSYXXXLIMQTSVXXERGI SSJJEGMPMXEXMRRKERHSVKEERM^MRKVIGVVIEXMSRSTTTSVXYRMXMIWTTVSZMHIHF]]RSRTVSJMXWW WII8EFPII % WWITEVEXIMXIIQEWOIHEEFSYXSTTSSVXYRMXMIWTVSZMHIHF]TVMZEXIFYWWMRIWWIW WIII8EFPI 88EFPI 5YIIWXMSR -XLLMROMWMXMQTTSVXERXJSVXLII4EVOWERH6IGVIEXMSR(ITEVXQIRXXXSiJEGMPMXEXXIERH SSVKERM^IVIGGVIEXMSRSTTSVXYRMXMIWTVSSZMHIHF]RSSRTVSJMXWMRXXLIGSQQYRRMX] IK=11'%WTSVXWPIIEKYIW -XXIQ6IWTSSRWI 77XVSRKP]EKVII 77SQI[LEXEKVIII 77SQI[LEXHMWEKKVII 77XVSRKP]HMWEKVIII Attachment C 796:)=6IWIEVGL*MRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEXI'SQQYRMX]7YVZI] 8EFPI 5YIWXMSR -XLMROMWMXMQTSVXERXJSVXLI4EVOWERH6IGVIEXMSR(ITEVXQIRXXSi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w-JMX[IVIYTXS]SYLS[[SYPH]SYEPPSGEXIMRXE\IW EGVSWWXLIWIGSQTIXMRKTVMSVMXMIW#x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ttachment C 6IWIEVGL*MRRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEEXI'SQQYYRMX]7YVZI]]796:)== 66IWYPXWMRHMGGEXI 3REEZIVEKIXLILMKLIWXHHSPPEVEPPSGEEXMSR[IRXXS[EVHWQEEMRXEMRMRKII\MWXMRKJEGMPMXMIW 3REEZIVEKIXLIPS[IWXHSSPPEVEPPSGEXMSR[IRXXSS[EVHWEHHHMRKRI[JEEGMPMXMIW **MRERGMEP77YWXEMREFMPMMX] ,,S[WLSYPHHXLIHITEVVXQIRXFEPEERGIVIGVIEEXMSRWIVZMGGIWXLEXTVSSQSXIGSQQYRMX]KSSSHERH GGMZMGFIRIJMMX[MXLVIZIRYITVSHYGGXMSR# %%RMXIQ[MXLL5YIWXMSRSJXLIWWYVZI]EWOWVIWTSRHIRXWXSMRHMGEEXI[LMGLWXXEXIQIRXXLLI] EEKVII[MXLQSVI 88EFPI 5YIIWXMSR ;LMGLWXEXIQIIRXHS]SYEEKVII[MXLQQSVI# -XXIQ6IWTSRWI 44EVOWERHVIGVIEXMSRWIVZMGIWGGSRXVMFYXIXSXLIWSGMEP[IPJEVIISJXLI[LSPIGSQQYRMX]ERRHWSXLI'MX]WLLSYPHJYRH XLVSYKLXE\HSPPZZMGIWEVIWSQIXXMQIWPMQMXIHEWEVIWYPX LIQTVMQEVMP]XEVWIZIRMJWIV 44EVOWERHVIGVIEXMSRWIVZMGIWWWLSYPHFIXLSYKKLXSJPMOIEFYWWMRIWW[LMGLWLSSYPHEXXVEGXEWQER]TISTPIEEWTSWWMFPI [[MPPMRKXSTE]JSSVXLIWIVZMGIWEERHWLSYPHXLIVVIJSVIFIJYRHIIHQEMRP]XLVSYKLYWIVJIIW 66IWYPXWMRHMGGEXI %QEENSVMX]SJVIWWTSRHIRXWJEZSVJYRHMRKWIVZMGIWWERHJEGMPMXXMIWTVMQEVMP]]XLVSYKLXEE\ HSPPEEVW 55YIWXMSRSJXLIWYVZZI]EWOWw77IZIVEPTVSKVEQWSJJIVIHF]XLI'MX]SJ&SYYPHIVVIUYMVIIEJII XXSSJJWIXXLIIJYPPGSWXSJTVSZMHMRKXLIQ*SVIIEGLSJXLIIJSPPS[MRKMXIQWTPIEEWIMRHMGEXII[LEX ]]SYFIPMIZIIMWXLIETTVSTVMEXIQMM\SJWYTTSVVXJVSQXE\IIWZIVWYWYWIIVJIIWx 88EFPI 5YYIWXMSR **SVIEGLSJXLIJSPPS[MRKKMXIQWTPIEWWIMRHMGEXI[[LEX]SYFIIPMIZIMWXLI EETTVSTVMEXIQM\SJWYTTSSVXJVSQXE\IIWZIVWYWYWIIVJIIW -XXIQ8E\IWTE])ZIRQM\9WIVWTE] QSVIQSVI 77TSVXWGPEWWIWSVVXIEQWJSVEHYYPXW 77TSVXWGPEWWIWSVVXIEQWJSV]SYXXL &&IKMRRIVPIZIPVIIGVIEXMSRGPEWWWIWJSVEHYPXW &&IKMRRIVPIZIPVIIGVIEXMSRGPEWWWIWJSV]SYXL %%HZERGIHPIZIIPVIGVIEXMSRGPEEWWIWJSVEHYPXW %%HZERGIHPIZIIPVIGVIEXMSRGPEEWWIWJSV]SYXL 44VSKVEQWJSVEHHYPXWERHWIRMSVWW[MXLPS[MRGSQQIW 44VSKVEQWJSV]SYXLJVSQJEQMPMIIW[MXLPS[MRGSSQIW 44VSKVEQWERHSSVMRGPYWMSRJSVTTISTPI[MXLHMWEEFMPMXMIW Attachment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ttachment C APPENDIX A 7YVZI]-RWXVYQIRX Attachment C 796:)=6IWIEVGL*MRHMRKW&SYPHIV1EWXIV4PER9THEXI'SQQYRMX]7YVZI] APPENDIX B 7YVZI]6IWYPXW 7YVZI] 8LERO]SYJSV GSQTPIXMRKXLMW WYVZI] 4PIEWIEGGITXXLMW GSYTSRJSVSRIJVII HEMP]EHQMWWMSRJSV JOHN Q. PUBLIC ]SYSVEJVMIRHEX OR CURRENT RESIDENT ER]'MX]SJ&SYPHIV 123 MAIN ST 6IGVIEXMSR'IRXIV BOULDER, CO 12345-6789 8VWHGKDVLGRVHOHFFLRQDGRDOD]DUSDUDWRPDUSDUWHHQXQFXHVWLRQDULRDFHUFDGHSDUTXHV \UHFUHDFLyQHQ%RXOGHU0X\SRFDVSHUVRQDVKDQVLGRVHOHFFLRQDGRVSDUDSDUWLFLSDUSRU Envíame una ORTXHVXUHVSXHVWDHVPX\YDOLRVD3DUDUHFLELUXQDFRSLDGHHVWHFXHVWLRQDULRHQHVSDxRO versión OODPHDORPDUTXHHVWDFDVLOOD\GHYROYHUHVWDFRSLDHQHOVREUHDGMXQWR en español Dear Boulder Resident, You are one of a small group of people selected at random to take part in a survey about parks and recreation in Boulder. This study is being conducted by an independent evaluator, the Eppley Institute for Parks and Public Lands, as part of a larger project to update the Boulder Parks and Recreation Department Master Plan. Your participation is an important part of creating a future that will help meet the needs of citizens like you. Only a ,WGRHVQ·WPDWWHULI\RXXVHSDUNVRUUHFUHDWLRQIDFLOLWLHV²ZHQHHGDOORSLQLRQVWREHUHSUHVHQWHG small portion of the Boulder population will receive this survey, so we especially need your response. It takes about 15 minutes to complete, and your answers will remain strictly confidential. As a token of our appreciation, please accept the coupon enclosed above for one free daily admission to any City of Boulder Recreation Center. Please return your completed survey in the enclosed postage-paid envelope by . If there Friday, October 5, 2012 are multiple people in your household, please have this survey completed by one adult (18 or older). If you would like additional information about this project, or would like to take the web version of this survey, . You please visit the Boulder Parks and Recreation Master Plan website at http://boulder.parksandrecplan.org can also contact us at (812) 855-3095. Sincerely, Jane S. Brautigam Stephen A. Wolter City Manager Executive Director Boulder, CO Eppley Institute for Parks and Public Lands Attachment E Appendix A RRedeem this ppass at any CCity of Bouldder Recreationn Center: 3OHHDVHUHPHPEEHUWR UHWXXUQ\RXUVXUYYH\E\East Bouldeer Recreation CCenter 56600 Sioux Drive )UULGD\2FWREHHU North BoulerRecreationCente dd r 3170 BBroadway Streeet South BoulerRecreationCente dd r 1360 Gillaspie Drivee 9DOLLGIRURQHGDLO\DGPLVVLRQIRUDDQ\LQGLYLGXDO No cash valuue. Do not duuplicate. Expiires June 30, 2013. Promo Code: 2214 1. Boulder has several deppartments thhat provide parks, greeenways, artts, recreatioon, and welllness oppportunitiees. Which oone do you ggenerally usse the most?? 3OHDVHVHOHFFWRQHER[ TrnsportatioPrks and Houing and aann aass Open pace & SS Divsion of Pubic Bouder Library RecreationHuma Services iillllnn Mountaain Parks Workks Departmeent Deppartment Depaartment «aintains may «provides a «perates «RIIHs cultural, «PDQges open mmnnoorraa of tHFLW\·VELF\le numbr of places r recreaion centers,recrational, space in nd around hhcceefofott eeaa paths and acivities like athletic fields, andwelless, and the city,including tt nn ggreenways. conncerts, film urbann parks; also educcational trails uused by screeenings, art providdes programs programms for youth, walkerss, hikers, showss, and literarry for dannce, fitness, famillies, and bicyclists, and pprograms. swimmming, yoga, senniors. horsebacck riders. etc. , I haveeQ·WXVHGDQyy of them or GRQ·WNQRZ OR The rest oof this survvey will focus on thee Boulder . PParks andd Recreatiion Deparrtment Even iif you donn·WXVHSDUkks or recreeation servvices, yourr thoughtss are valuaable in hhelping us better undderstand eeYHU\RQH·ss opinions.. Attachment E Appendix A 2. Generally speaking, how important is it to you to have these in Boulder? 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK 7KHPRVW Very Somewhat Not at all &DQ·WVD\ LPSRUWDQW important important important no opinion Community and neighborhood parks (i.e., with features like shelters, playgrounds, paths, etc.) Recreation centers (i.e., with features like pools, gyms, tennis courts, etc.) Health and wellness programs (e.g., exercise, yoga, weight rooms, etc.) Athletic/sports fields and programs Art, dance, and gymnastics programs Inclusion programs (i.e., programs offered to people with disabilities) Facilities for specific recreation activities (e.g., golf courses, bike parks) Historical, cultural, and civic places (e.g., Pearl Street Mall, Chautauqua Park) Forests and natural areas «7KHQSOHDVHLQGLFDWHZKLFKRQHLVWKHPRVW important to you. 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHVWDU 3. Looking at the same list, please indicate how often you visit the places or participate in the programs provided by the Parks and Recreation Department. 6HOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK Very A few times &DQ·WVD\Somewhat A few times Very A few times Somewhat dissatisfied a year a month satisfied no opinion dissatisfied satisfied a week About daily Not at all Community and neighborhood parks (i.e., with features like shelters, playgrounds, paths, etc.) Recreation centers (i.e., with features like pools, gyms, tennis courts, etc.) Health and wellness programs (e.g., exercise, yoga, weight rooms, etc.) Athletic/sports fields and programs Art, dance, and gymnastics programs Inclusion programs (i.e., programs offered to people with disabilities) Facilities for specific recreation activities (e.g., golf courses, bike parks) Historical, cultural, and civic places (e.g., Pearl Street Mall, Chautauqua Park) Forests and natural areas «7KHQSOHDVHUDWHKRZVDWLVILHG you are with the Department·VMRERISURYLGLQJWKHP 6HOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK Attachment E Appendix A 4. Think about the community of Boulder overall. To what degree do SDUNVDQGUHFUHDWLRQFRQWULEXWHWR%RXOGHU·VEHLQJ« 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK Greatly Somewhat Does not &DQ·WVD\ contributes contributes contribute no opinion «D community? physically healthy «DQ community? environmentally sustainable «D community? socially thriving «DQ community? economically sustainable «DQ community? accessible and physically connected «D community? safe «DFRPPXQLW\ZLWKD? positive sense of place «DFRPPXQLW\ZLWKD overall? high quality of life 5. Please indicate how much you agree or disagree with the following statements. 6HOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK ´,WKLQNLWLVLPSRUWDQWIRUWKH3DUNVDQG 7KHPRVW Strongly Somewhat Somewhat Strongly 5HFUHDWLRQ'HSDUWPHQWWR«µLPSRUWDQW agree agree disagree disagree «SURPRWHphysical health and mental well-being «SURYLGHRSSRUWXQLWLHVWRPDNHsocial connections DQGVWUHQJWKHQWKH´social fabricµRIWKHFRPPXQLW\ «HQKDQFHWKHeconomic vitality of the community «HQKDQFHWKHenvironmental sustainability of the community «SURYLGHUHFUHDWLRQDOopportunities to people who otherwise might not be able to participate (e.g., people with disabilities or people with low incomes) «FRQWULEXWHWRFRPPXQLW\safety «HQKDQFHWKHRYHUDOOquality of life «SURYLGHSRVLWLYH\RXWKGHYHORSPHQWDFWLYLWLHVIRU children and teens (age 19 and younger) «SURYLGHUHFUHDWLRQDORSSRUWXQLWLHVIRUadults (20 to 64 years old) «SURYLGHUHFUHDWLRQDORSSRUWXQLWLHVIRUsenior adults (age 65 and older) «facilitate and organize recreation opportunities provided by nonprofits in the community (e.g., YMCA, sports leagues) «facilitate and organize recreation opportunities provided by private businesses in the community (e.g., yoga studios, fitness centers) Attachment E «7KHQSOHDVHLQGLFDWHZKLFKRQHLVWKHPRVW important to you. 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHVWDU Appendix A 6. Consider each pair of statements. From your perspective, choose the one you agree with more. Individuals living outside the City of Boulder should pay There should be no difference in fees between residents and OR higher fees for using Boulder Parks and Recreation facilities non-residents for using City of Boulder facilities and and programs.programs. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW If an individual works or owns a business in the City of If an individual works or owns a business in Boulder, they OR Boulder, they should be entitled to the same parks and should not be entitled to Boulder resident fees for parks and recreation fees as residents. recreation. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Parks and recreation program offerings should focus Parks and recreation program offerings should serve all OR primarily on developing skills at beginner or intermediate different skill levels (i.e., beginner to very advanced). levels. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Activities and programs at parks and recreation facilities Activities and programs at parks and recreation facilities OR should be mostly scheduled or pre-planned, with some should mostly be available for drop-in use, with some being available for drop-in use. pre-planned. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Parks and recreation programs should focus mostly on Some popular sports and fitness programs should be offered, OR popular sports and fitness activities (e.g., Pilates, yoga, but so should diverse or less-popular activities (e.g., cooking, softball, soccer, etc.). drawing, etc.). +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW The Parks and Recreation Department should provide The Parks and Recreation Department should provide OR facilities and programs that complement those provided by facilities and programs identified by residents regardless of others in the community, but should not replicate them. whether they are provided by others in or near Boulder. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Parks and recreation services contribute to the social welfare Parks and recreation services should be thought of like a of the whole community, and so the City should fund them business which should attract as many people as possible OR primarily through tax dollars, even if services are sometimes willing to pay for the services, and should therefore be limited as a result. funded mainly through user fees. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Given the federal requirement that a minimum of 33% all public facilities provide full physical accessibility to individuals with disabilities, I think the Boulder Parks and ReFUHDWLRQ'HSDUWPHQWVKRXOG« «JREH\RQGWKHPLQLPXPHYHQLIWKDWPHDQVQHHGLQJ«PHHWWKHUHTXLUHPHQWEXWQRWJRDQ\IXUWKHU,WZRXOGEH OR more funding for additional construction or remodeling of nice to have more than 33%, buWZHFDQ·WIXQGDOOWKDWZRUN ramps, elevators, etc. right now. +RZVWURQJO\GR\RXDJUHHZLWKWKHVWDWHPHQW\RXFKRVH" 9HU\PXFK0RVWO\6RPHZKDW Attachment E Appendix A 7. Several programs offered by the City of Boulder require a fee to offset the full cost of providing them. For each of the following items, please indicate what you believe is the appropriate mix of support from taxes versus user fees. 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK Even mix of Taxes pay Users pay tax support more more and user fees classes or teams for Sportsadults classes or teams for Sportsyouth -level recreation classes for Beginneradults (e.g., fitness, dance, art, etc.) -level recreation classes for Beginneryouth -level recreation classes for Advancedadults -level recreation classes for Advancedyouth Programs for and with adultsseniorslow incomes Programs for from families with youthlow incomes Programs and/or inclusion for people with disabilities 8. Please rate how important you think it is for the City of Boulder to provide recreation programs for each of the population groups below. 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK 7KHPRVW Very Somewhat Not at all Essential LPSRUWDQW important important important (12 years and younger) Children (13 to 19 years) Teenagers (20 to 64 years) Adults adults (65 years and older) Senior Families with Peopledisabilities with Peoplelow incomes within Peopleethnic minority groups and other to Boulder Touristsvisitors «7KHQSOHDVHLQGLFDWHZKLFKRQHLVWKHPRVW important to you. 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHVWDU Attachment E Appendix A 9. If it were up to you, how would you allocate $100 in taxes across these competing priorities? Providing additional $ ________ recreation programs Providing connections to more places in the community like parks, schools, and shops with $ ________ or other alternative transportation routes pathways and trails Remodeling park and recreation facilities so they are more to people with disabilities accessible $ ________ or limited physical ability Acquiring additional $ ________ parkland Adding park and recreation $ ________ newfacilities park and recreation $ ________ Maintaining or enhancing existingfacilities TOTAL 10. Overall, how satisfied are you with the Boulder Parks DQG5HFUHDWLRQ'HSDUWPHQW·V« 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQHER[IRUHDFK Very Somewhat &DQ·WVD\Somewhat Very satisfied satisfied no opinion dissatisfied dissatisfied «DELOLW\WRSURYLGHTXDOLW\SURJUDPVDQGVHUYLFHV" «DYDLODELOLW\RILQIRUPDWLRQDERXWIDFLOLWLHVDQGSURJUDPV" «FXVWRPHUVHUYLFH" «SUHVHQFHDQGYLVLELOLW\LQWKHFRPPXQLW\" «DELOLW\WRFDUHIRUSDUNand recreation facilities? 11. What is your most preferred way to find out about park and recreation programs? 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQH Boulder Camera newspaper Boulder Parks and Recreation Guide (quarterly publication) Channel 8 (municipal cable TV) Facebook Informational flyers Twitter City of Boulder website Other (please specify): ____________________________________ Email / listserv 12. About how long have you lived in Boulder? ___________ years 3OHDVHPDUN´µLIOHVVWKDQPRQWKV Attachment E Appendix A 13. Counting yourself, how many people live in your household? ___________ individuals Are any 12 years or younger? Yes No Are any ages 13-17 years? Yes No Are you or any other household member 65 or older? Yes No $ERXWKRZPXFKZDV\RXUKRXVHKROG·V total income before taxes in 2011? Less than $25,000 $100,000 to $149,999 $25,000 to $49,999 $150,000 to $199,999 $50,000 to $74,999 $200,000 to $299,999 $75,000 to $99,999 $300,000 or more 15. What is your age? 16. Which of the following best describes your ethnicity? 3OHDVHVHOHFWRQH3OHDVHVHOHFWDOOWKDWDSSO\ 18-24 American Indian, Eskimo, or Aleutian 25-34 Asian or Pacific Islander 35-44 Black or African American 45-54 Chicano/Mexican-American, Latino/Latina, or Hispanic 55-64 White 65-74 Other (please specify): _______________________________ 75 or older 17. What is your gender? Male Female 18. Would you be interested in participating in a follow-up survey in the future? Yes No On behalf of the Parks and Recreation Department, as well as the entire staff of the City of Boulder, thank you for your participation in this important survey. Results will be analyzed during the month of October and summary information will be published on the Parks and Recreation Master Plan website (http://boulder.parksandrecplan.org) in November. Community meetings regarding the planning project will be held in late 2012 or early 2013. Watch the website for details. Thank you again for your time and interest in helping make Boulder an outstanding place to live and ZRUN(QMR\\RXUIUHHSDVVWRRQHRIWKH&LW\·V5Hcreation Centers, and we look forward to seeing you out and about! Attachment E Appendix A Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B Attachment E Appendix B