Minutes - Human Relations Commission - 08/20/2012
City of Boulder
Human Relations Commission Minutes
Monday, August 20, 2012
1777 Broadway, Boulder, CO
6:00 p.m.
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:
Leisha Conners Bauer
Jonathan Dings
Shirly White
COMMISSIONERS ABSENT:
Peter Osnes excused
Amy Zuckerman excused
STAFF PRESENT:
Karen Rahn
Carmen Atilano
Beth Van Dusen
1. Call to Order
The August 20, 2012 HRC meeting was called to order at 6:05 p.m. by
L. Conners Bauer.
IT. Agenda Adjustments
Reschedule PERL for the September 2012 meeting.
Add Civic Area Plan under Item 6A- K. Rahn will provide an update.
III Approval of Minutes
S. White moved to accept the July 16, 2012 minutes as corrected. J. Dings seconded the
motion. MOTION carries 3-0.
IV Community Participation
Sophie Duncan, 4884 Franklin Drive, Boulder, CO and Sophie Browning, 3186 Gallina
Way, Boulder, CO both representing YOAB addressed the HRC regarding possible
revisions to the Human Rights Ordinance, they are particularly interested in potential
changes to the age discrimination protection specifically with regard to employment.
Regarding increasing the age to 65 YOAB feels that the HRC should also consider
lowering the age for employment and public accommodations. L. Conners Bauer asked
when will the recommendations for the modifications for age discrimination come back
to the HRC? C. Atilano stated, in September. C. Atilano stated that depending upon the
consideration of the HRC we can delay the recommendations further and include them
in an analysis for later consideration.
V. Action Items
A. Community Impact Fund Proposals
1. Bridge House: C. Atilano reported that there was some cross communication
with Bridge House and that they will give a presentation at the September meeting.
C. Atilano asked the HRC if they feel comfortable moving forward on the proposal
without a presentation. L. Conners Bauer responded that the HRC would like to have a
presentation prior to approving funding as the HRC is the only funding source for this
event.
2. Latino Task Force (LTFBC) of Boulder County: Carmen Ramirez and Perla
Delgado presented a Community Impact Fund request in the amount of $5,000.00 for the
Latino Assessment of Boulder County. The first assessment was
conducted ten years ago and provided data for the City and the County. The objective is
to identify values and contributions made by the Latino community that have improved
the quality of life for Boulder County residents and to identify needs for improving the
quality of life for Boulder County Latino residents. The Latino Task Force is requesting
additional funding which will be specific to the City of Boulder. LTF has conducted a
secondary data review, are beginning to form focus groups and conduct surveys and will
finalize the assessment by the end of the year. The LTF is requesting additional funds to
conduct additional focus groups. S. White asked for clarification on the type of
information being gathered in the focus groups. Carmen Ramirez replied that they
(LTFBC) will be asking the groups what kind of things have changed in the last 10 years
in the County and in their own communities and what kind of contributions have Latinos
made in the community. What are the needs, issues and challenges facing Latinos.
Following the focus group, a survey will be conducted. J. Dings asked if LTFBC has
secured funding from any other source. Carmen Ramirez replied that the focus groups
will only be conducted in the City of Boulder and that issues within high schools have
been identified. J. Dings asked for additional information on the cost of the focus groups
and the benefit to the City. J. Dings recused himself from a vote on this proposal. This
proposal will be rescheduled for the September 17, 2012 HRC due to a lack of a quorum.
L. Conners Bauer requested additional budget information as the previous $5,000 HRC
grant was not listed as a source of revenue and this grant request from the HRC is for
$5,130.00.
3. PERL: Grant request deferred until the September 17, 2012 meeting.
B. Diversity Report: Stephanie Greenberg provided details from her data analysis
and her report entitled "What Does Diversity Look Like in the City of Boulder". During
her presentation, Stephanie focused on economic status and living situation(s) with an
emphasis on age, race, linguistic status, household type, income status, homelessness,
disability, and GLBTQ status. The primary quantitative data sources were the 2010
census and the American Community Survey, which is sample survey of 3% of
residential addressed nationwide. L. Conners Bauer asked Stephanie to highlight key
findings with regard to the homeless population. The primary source of data is from the
Point in Time count conducted on January 23, 2012. Veterans, persons of color and
Latinos were over represented. There were 750 homeless individuals counted in the City
of Boulder. Forty percent of those surveyed, who were homeless had at least one person
in their family employed. There were twice as many newly homeless as there were
chronically homeless. Five hundred children were served in the BVSD under the
McKinney Vento Act S. White asked if there is additional ethnicity information
available for the categories where primary data is provided. Stephanie Greenberg replied
that the estimates likely will not be reliable to large sampling errors and that this data is a
very small piece of the population and is hard to capture with the sampling tools
employed. Some of this data has been captured in the County Homeless and Poverty
report. .I. Dings asked about validating LGBQT data with other sources. Stephanie
replied that the only other source may be the county data and that the GLBTQ population
in BVSD is about 5%. 1 Dings moved to accept the report from Stephanie Greenberg.
S. White seconded the motion. Motion carries 3-0.
VI. Discussion/In formational Items
A. HRC Work Plan
1. HHS Senior Services Report: Betty Kilsdouk, Manager, Senior Services
Division introduced herself and provided an overview of the Senior Services Division,
their mission and scope of services provided. L. Conners Bauer asked if Senior
Services are restricted to citizens or residents? Some programs are specifically for
residents and some programs that are administered countywide. K. Rahn specified that
programs are for residents unless there are state or federal eligibility criteria. S. White
asked if documentation is required for programs that are administered with regard to
state and federal programs. Yes, it is a requirement. You must be a legal resident.
S. White commented that the City Community Mediation Services provides conflict
resolution and is not listed as a resource for senior services. L. Conners Bauer asked if
there is outreach to GLBTQ seniors. Outreach to the GLBTQ population is provided
through case-workers. S. White asked if there are specific measurable outcomes that the
Senior Services Division is striving toward and how the HRC can assist with these goals.
B. Kilsdonk cited that the Bilingual Outreach Coordinator position as an example. This
position is funded through a grant and therefore there are specific measurable outcomes
associated. K. Rahn commented that there is a Master Plan revision scheduled which
will likely lead to substantive changes with regard to community indicators. L. Conners
Bauer asked about increased demand for Senior Services with regard to changing
demographics. B. Kilsdonk commented that this a well known trend and will be
addressed in the revisions to the Master Plan.
2. IAOHRA Conference Report: A. Zuckerman was not present at the meeting. Her
notes from the conference and several handouts have been distributed to the HRC.
3. Meeting with Mexican Consulate: C. Atilano reported that there is meeting
scheduled on Friday, August 24, 2012. S. White will attend the meeting with C.
Atilano.
4. Civic Area Plan Update: Karen Rahn reported to the HRC that the City has begun
a Master Plan to develop the Civic Area, which includes the area between 9ch and 17'h
and Arapahoe and Canyon. The primary reasons include relocating city buildings that
are in a high hazard flood zone and to create an attractive civic center with amenities.
Lesli Ellis, Planner with the City of Boulder, Community Planning and Sustainability
will be present at the September 17, 2012 HRC meeting to give an overview of the
project and planning efforts. There is a community visioning process that will take place
at Boulder High School on September 12, 2012.
5. Event Reports: S. White attended the Boulder Asian Festival and J. Dings attended
Rocks Karma Arrows.
B. Follow Up Tasks
1. Analysis of youth in age discrimination in employment and public
accommodations.
2. Reschedule CIF proposals for the September 17, 2012 meeting.
3. Close contract with Stephanie Greenberg
VII. Action Items
No immediate action items.
VIII. Adiournment
J. Dings moved to adjourn the August 20, 2012 meeting. S. White seconded the motion.
The motion passed with a vote of 4-0. The meeting was adjourned at 7:36 p.m.
Attested: Approved:
Board Secretary HRC Chairperson